who are your all time best city 11 ? (3 Viewers)

classicfooty · Jun 25, 2012

whos your all time greatest city players from goalkeeper to strikers?

Chipfat · Jun 25, 2012

Oggy
Neilsen
Peake
Gillespie
Pearce
Robson
Hadji
Hucthinson
Mccailster
Dublin
Keane

Subs
Danny Thomas
Brian Burrows
Peter Ndlovu
D Huckerby
Mickey Gynn
Kevin Gallacher
G Boetang

Grendel · Jun 25, 2012

Ogrizovic
Thomas
McDonald
Gillespie
Shaw
Yorath
Hunt
Hutchinson
Dublin
Quinn
Whelan

Sky Blue Kid · Jun 25, 2012

Glazier
Nielsen
Kilcline
Curtis
Shaw
Hadji
McCallister
Wise
Hunt
Dublin
Hutchinson

Houchens Head · Jun 25, 2012

Think this type of thread has been done to death! We seem to have one of these post every couple of months or so.
There are so many age ranges on these forums that we all have our favourites but from different eras. My choice would be from the 1960's. That's all I'll bother to say.

ccfcway · Jun 25, 2012

tourch will be here in a minute commenting about this !

Real · Jun 25, 2012

GK Oggy

RB Nilsson
CB Kilcline
CB Babb
LB Pearce

RM Bennett
CM McCallister
CM Palmer
LW Froggat

CF Hartson
CF Keane.

It's difficult because I rated Peake as much as Kilcline, but I've tried to pick a team where one persons talent compliments another. Now I've put my team down I've remembered the brilliant David Speedie, but I think a Hartson/Keane combo would work better than Hartson/Speedie. The reason I went with Palmer above some better players is because his signing brought out the best in McCallister.

---
I am here: http://tapatalk.com/map.php?5txjpp

6 Generations · Jun 25, 2012

Hutchison, not Hutchinson!!! Oh! Tommy Tommy! Tommy, Tommy, Tommy, Tommy HUTCHISON.

classicfooty · Jun 25, 2012

wow thanks for that houchens head, not sure why you bothered to say anything really

slyblue57 · Jun 25, 2012

1.Jim Blythe
2.Danny Thomas
3.Roland Nielsen
4.Trevor Peake
5.George Curtis
6.Terry Yorath
7.Micky Bennet
8.Willie Carr
9.colin Stein
10.Robbie keane
11.Tommy Hutchison

mark82 · Jun 25, 2012

GK Oggy

RB Borrows
CB Kilcline
CB Konjic
LB Burrows

RM Hadji
CM McAllister
CM Wise
LW Froggat

CF Speedie
CF Quinn

skybluesalex · Jun 25, 2012

GK- Dimi Konstantopulos

Def- Arjan De Zeeuw
Def- Colin Hawkins
Def- David McNamee
Def- Gary Borrowdale

Mid- Ellery Cairo
Mid- Guillaume Beuzelin
Mid- Michael Hughes
Mid- Wayne Andrews

Fwd- RoyO'Donovan
Fwd- Colin Cameron

DiveDiveWhereverYouMayBe · Jun 25, 2012

Colin Cameron was a defensive midfielder, you would have to go 4-5-1 or that team would get found out in the top flight.

SkyBlueM · Jun 25, 2012

Quick pick from the players I have seen play

GK. Oggy
RB. Neilsen
CB. Gillespie
CB. Peake
LB. Pearce
RM. Gallacher
CM. Yorath
CM. McAllister
LM. Hutchison
CF. Dublin
CF. Wallace

neilyboy67 · Jun 25, 2012

oggy
nielsson
mcdonald
peake
gillespie
hutchison
bennnett
mcallister
yorath
dublin
speedie

SkyBlue_Bear83 · Jun 25, 2012

skybluesalex said:
GK- Dimi Konstantopulos

Def- Arjan De Zeeuw
Def- Colin Hawkins
Def- David McNamee
Def- Gary Borrowdale

Mid- Ellery Cairo
Mid- Guillaume Beuzelin
Mid- Michael Hughes
Mid- Wayne Andrews

Fwd- RoyO'Donovan
Fwd- Colin Cameron

Sub in Eastwood and Bell when we need fresh legs in the last 20 mins of the game :/

DiveDiveWhereverYouMayBe · Jun 25, 2012

Is it akin to being a fan of SISU if I think that David Bell, given a run of games and an upsurge in confidence (hopefully with more backing from the stands than he is normally given), can do a job in League 1? I am not a fan of David Bell, but I would obviously like him to turn a corner and improve with us.

Addition: I know I will get slated and this is just a football forum. He gets a few cries of derision throughout the crowd at bad passes, etc. but is not roundly booed. I just wonder if he knocked in a couple of goals, got a few more fans off his back, he might end up being on the team sheet through merit rather than desperation. Now an off form Clingan has gone, I am not sure who, on form, could spray a cross field pass with any more accuracy.

Skybluefaz · Jun 25, 2012

Oggy
Warnock
Breen
Dublin
Nilsson

Hadji
McAllister
Wise
Thompson

Hartson
Keane

Skybluefaz · Jun 25, 2012

Only picked from players I've seen. Would stick Micky Quinn in front of Hartson actually.

Somerset Sky Blue · Jun 25, 2012

Real - Thought you would have picked Shaw in CB?

Real · Jun 25, 2012

Somerset Sky Blue said:
Real - Thought you would have picked Shaw in CB?

Defenders who can't head a ball was never my thing. ;-)

---
I am here: http://tapatalk.com/map.php?scviq4

Houchens Head · Jun 26, 2012

classicfooty said:
wow thanks for that houchens head, not sure why you bothered to say anything really

Because these threads get boring. It's the same old thing time and again. Can't anyone think of something different?
I'll start: What's your all time favourite City line up? .............................. Oh bollocks!! It's been done already!

johnniericoh · Jun 26, 2012

DiveDiveWhereverYouMayBe said:
Is it akin to being a fan of SISU if I think that David Bell, given a run of games and an upsurge in confidence (hopefully with more backing from the stands than he is normally given), can do a job in League 1? I am not a fan of David Bell, but I would obviously like him to turn a corner and improve with us.

Addition: I know I will get slated and this is just a football forum. He gets a few cries of derision throughout the crowd at bad passes, etc. but is not roundly booed. I just wonder if he knocked in a couple of goals, got a few more fans off his back, he might end up being on the team sheet through merit rather than desperation. Now an off form Clingan has gone, I am not sure who, on form, could spray a cross field pass with any more accuracy.

I have said this before but David Bell is probably one of the most skilful players we currently have.

No I am not joking - look at his first touch and layoffs not bad me thinks - unfairly maligned as mentioned above but I think he will shine for us next year - so you knockers out there get off his back and instead please give DB some encouragement - I think we will be pleasantly surprised.

PUSB

SkyBlueJohnso · Jun 26, 2012

Bell has to deliver this season, if he can't deliver in Lg1 his contract should be terminated!!!

he definitely has something, and deserves a fair chance with a decent run in the side.

johnniericoh · Jun 26, 2012

Glazier

Neilsson
Curtis
Peake
Pearce

Hutchison
Yorath
E Hunt
Bennet

Dublin
Hudson

Subs:

Oggy

Coop
Cattlin

McAllister

Wallace

lordsummerisle · Jun 26, 2012

johnniericoh said:
I have said this before but David Bell is probably one of the most skilful players we currently have.

No I am not joking - look at his first touch and layoffs not bad me thinks - unfairly maligned as mentioned above but I think he will shine for us next year - so you knockers out there get off his back and instead please give DB some encouragement - I think we will be pleasantly surprised.

PUSB

That's the problem.

Players like Bell, Baker, McPake, Deegan, Hussey, Clingan, Eastwood etc, were always no better than League One players, but were lauded as great signings by many, and a sign of the spotting abilities of Coleman/Thorn/Ranson*(* delete as appropriate, depending on whether player any good or not and current popularity)

Some said if we keep on signing League One quality players then it is where we will end up, and ultilmately where we will stay,unless we have a manager who can generate outperformance from the players.

Don't think that we have.

classicfooty · Jun 26, 2012

Houchens Head said:
Because these threads get boring. It's the same old thing time and again. Can't anyone think of something different?
I'll start: What's your all time favourite City line up? .............................. Oh bollocks!! It's been done already!

i genuinly hadnt seen it before and i wanted some ideas to create a classic city side on pro evolution soz

Nonleagueherewecome · Jun 26, 2012

Debec
Pickering
Carey
Heath
Guerrero
Normann
Telfer
Robertson
Jenkinson
Gayle
Benjamin

Nonleagueherewecome · Jun 26, 2012

skybluesalex said:
GK- Dimi Konstantopulos

Def- Arjan De Zeeuw
Def- Colin Hawkins
Def- David McNamee
Def- Gary Borrowdale

Mid- Ellery Cairo
Mid- Guillaume Beuzelin
Mid- Michael Hughes
Mid- Wayne Andrews

Fwd- RoyO'Donovan
Fwd- Colin Cameron

Reckon your lot could beat my lot, even with a midfielder up front. I can only think you really rated Dowie & Adams judgement!

ccfc1973 · Jun 26, 2012

1 Oggy
2 B Borrows
3 S Pearce
4 McAllister
5 Babb
6 Peake
7 Bennett
8 Speedie
9 Dublin
10 T Gibson
11 Ndlovu
subs
Blyth
Robson
Huckerby
Quinn
Nilsson
Hadji
Gallacher

Houchens Head · Jun 26, 2012

classicfooty said:
i genuinly hadnt seen it before and i wanted some ideas to create a classic city side on pro evolution soz

Yeah, I suppose it creates interest for those fairly new to the forum. There's certainly a lot of difference of opinions on who would line-up though. There have been so many greats through the club - and some not so great - I find it hard to make a final selection. Every time I look through other folks choices I think "Bloody hell, I forgot him!" and then I'm back to square one! :facepalm:

who are your all time best city 11 ? (3 Viewers)

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Fairly well known member from Malvern

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Super Moderator

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Fairly well known member from Malvern

Member

New Member

Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Fairly well known member from Malvern

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency