Transfer Rumour Transfer listed (1 Viewer)

AFCCOVENTRY · Nov 26, 2024

No not being dramatic. Even with a new manager we’ve got a problem where we have half the squad which are not good enough

It feels like a rebuild is needed on the rebuild

Big player churn is needed to sort this mess out.

Defence all need to go for starters.

Midfield is so not dynamic or creative and have an abundance of attackers who don’t produce the goods consistently.

Cash in and rebuild Frank (or whoever comes in)

covmutley · Nov 26, 2024

Your being dramatic

Nick · Nov 26, 2024

We need to figure out our defenders.

Is Kitching going to cost us 5 mill or whatever and see his contract out sat on the bench?

JohnWH · Nov 26, 2024

Cash in on who exactly?
Genuinely interested who we 1) don't suit us, and 2) we can con someone else to buy.

quinn1971 · Nov 26, 2024

robins knew the start of the season the defensive players weren’t good enough, boddy said in an interview in the summer we’re 2 defenders short, even he knew, we recruited for a 4 3 3 hoping we’d just score more every game, just haven’t seen a good defender in any of them since they‘ve been here, need a McFadz type, watch them, nobody organises anything

Ccfcisparks · Nov 26, 2024

For the majority of these players we need to try and make them work, they are on too big expensive contracts to try and palm off for a loss.

Rodders1 · Nov 26, 2024

quinn1971 said:
robins knew the start of the season the defensive players weren’t good enough, boddy said in an interview in the summer we’re 2 defenders short, even he knew, we recruited for a 4 3 3 hoping we’d just score more every game, just haven’t seen a good defender in any of them since they‘ve been here, need a McFadz type, watch them, nobody organises anything

McFadz could only play in a back 5. But I assume you mean leader / communicator type of CB?

quinn1971 · Nov 26, 2024

Rodders1 said:
McFadz could only play in a back 5. But I assume you mean leader / communicator type of CB?

yeah, that type of player, we haven’t got one centre half that reads the game or organises us,

Perennial Lurker · Nov 26, 2024

Nick said:
We need to figure out our defenders.

Is Kitching going to cost us 5 mill or whatever and see his contract out sat on the bench?

Don't get what has gone wrong with Kitching ? At times last season he looked a fantastic player , one of the first names on the team sheet

ccfc1234 · Nov 26, 2024

Most of our clean sheets are with Kitch and Thomas. Play them in a 4 with Bidwell back in and we would look more solid. Binks is unlucky as he is a tidy footballer but we need a more uncompromising defensive style in the next few weeks.

Rodders1 · Nov 26, 2024

ccfc1234 said:
Most of our clean sheets are with Kitch and Thomas. Play them in a 4 with Bidwell back in and we would look more solid. Binks is unlucky as he is a tidy footballer but we need a more uncompromising defensive style in the next few weeks.

I wouldn’t mind Binks at LB if needed… he’s decent on the ball and obviously not a weakness in the air.

Mucca Mad Boys · Nov 26, 2024

Rodders1 said:
I wouldn’t mind Binks at LB if needed… he’s decent on the ball and obviously not a weakness in the air.

Probably him or Kitching at LB in the long run and there’s a decent bit of balance there ‘in theory’.

The big concern I’d have is their pace v wingers.

shmmeee · Nov 26, 2024

ccfc1234 said:
Most of our clean sheets are with Kitch and Thomas. Play them in a 4 with Bidwell back in and we would look more solid. Binks is unlucky as he is a tidy footballer but we need a more uncompromising defensive style in the next few weeks.

“Most of our clean sheets”

haven’t we had two?

Sky Blue Goblin · Nov 26, 2024

To be fair, we had a good spell with them last year and had a decent defence for most of it.

Not sure what’s changed but feel good coaching and motivation could go a long way without having to sell a bulk of the lads

stupot07 · Nov 26, 2024

quinn1971 said:
robins knew the start of the season the defensive players weren’t good enough, boddy said in an interview in the summer we’re 2 defenders short, even he knew, we recruited for a 4 3 3 hoping we’d just score more every game, just haven’t seen a good defender in any of them since they‘ve been here, need a McFadz type, watch them, nobody organises anything

If Robins knew the defensive players weren't good enough, why did he re-sign Binks?

ccfc1234 · Nov 26, 2024

shmmeee said:
“Most of our clean sheets”

haven’t we had two?

Sorry, was including last season.

Mucca Mad Boys · Nov 26, 2024

shmmeee said:
“Most of our clean sheets”

haven’t we had two?

4 including the League Cup and 75% of those had Thomas and Kitching at CB.

This should tell the incoming manager a lot.

quinn1971 · Nov 26, 2024

stupot07 said:
If Robins knew the defensive players weren't good enough, why did he re-sign Binks

you’ll have to ask him that, his words not mine

CBS16 · Nov 26, 2024

It's a complicated squad to work with, so many different types of player, which on paper is handy for options but as soon as a starting player is out or dropped his replacement suits a totally different style. We then rejig something else in the team to balance it, then the line up changes again and it's back to square one. We don't have an identity and we've not signed players to fit a specific idea. Bit of a mess and maybe one or 2 leaving and the new manager bringing in a few of us own will address that?

ptr · Nov 26, 2024

Rodders1 said:
I wouldn’t mind Binks at LB if needed… he’s decent on the ball and obviously not a weakness in the air.

I really don’t think playing players out of position is what we need right now.

fernandopartridge · Nov 26, 2024

Rodders1 said:
I wouldn’t mind Binks at LB if needed… he’s decent on the ball and obviously not a weakness in the air.

He's not a left back and not good enough to play there in our system, he should never have been signed

AFCCOVENTRY · Nov 27, 2024

This summer Wright will be off and likely MVE. Plus Vik moving means a decent kitty will be available. They won’t be staying for a 3rd season in the Championship.

SkyB · Nov 27, 2024

I only come on this forum when I'm at work, so always the day or a couple of days after the games, and the headloss when we play badly is unmatched.

Burnley will be top 2 this season, the wages of there bench was equivalent to our starting line up. While we're no longer the poor fish in the pond, we're still nowhere near the top 3 in the Div.

Not to diminish what Carr has done but he's played the same formation against the 3 top teams in the division, it was bound to be found out eventually.

SBAndy · Nov 27, 2024

fernandopartridge said:
He's not a left back and not good enough to play there in our system, he should never have been signed

See I don’t think either of the specialist left backs are particularly good enough either. Binks starting at LB but either forming a back 3 when we attack or pivoting into CM to free up one of them could work potentially.

Generally, though, I do see us reaching a critical mass where we’re going to have to move a couple on at a loss if possible just to free up some cash flow. The squad cohesion is a mess.

KenilworthSkyBlue · Nov 27, 2024

AFCCOVENTRY said:
This summer Wright will be off and likely MVE. Plus Vik moving means a decent kitty will be available. They won’t be staying for a 3rd season in the Championship.

Sheaf's contract expires in 2026. Unless he's offered a new one he'll likely be off as well.

JSL · Nov 27, 2024

I find it incredible that teams like Leeds, WBA and Sheffield United seem to jettison good quality players each year for various financial needs and manage to sign free transfers who don't seem to hamper their progress and performance. Why are we not that savvy?

San Francisco · Nov 27, 2024

JSL said:
I find it incredible that teams like Leeds, WBA and Sheffield United seem to jettison good quality players each year for various financial needs and manage to sign free transfers who don't seem to hamper their progress and performance. Why are we not that savvy?

Much, much better recruitment team than ours I’d imagine.

Marty · Nov 27, 2024

You would expect us to have 20mill+ to spend again in the summer. MVE, Wright, Sheaf will all leave at the minimum imo and you then have the likes of Eccles, Simms and Bassette that others may take a punt on. Gyokeres sell on too. Just hope we've learnt our lesson and stop signing players from no mark leagues.

SBAndy · Nov 27, 2024

Marty said:
You would expect us to have 20mill+ to spend again in the summer. MVE, Wright, Sheaf will all leave at the minimum imo and you then have the likes of Eccles, Simms and Bassette that others may take a punt on. Gyokeres sell on too. Just hope we've learnt our lesson and stop signing players from no mark leagues.

Aren’t you advocating signing someone from the Polish league?

Marty · Nov 27, 2024

SBAndy said:
Aren’t you advocating signing someone from the Polish league?

Yes, as a cheap decent option off the bench that may develop. Not as first choice number 1 or our Gus Hamer replacement.

skybluecam · Nov 27, 2024

JSL said:
I find it incredible that teams like Leeds, WBA and Sheffield United seem to jettison good quality players each year for various financial needs and manage to sign free transfers who don't seem to hamper their progress and performance. Why are we not that savvy?

Wages. I’m sure their wage bills are still significantly higher than ours. And Leeds/SU offer realistic chances of playing in the Premier League.

JSL · Nov 27, 2024

skybluecam said:
Wages. I’m sure their wage bills are still significantly higher than ours. And Leeds/SU offer realistic chances of playing in the Premier League.

Does it matter when we save millions on transfer fees? The end result over a typical contract length will be the same surely.

mmttww · Nov 27, 2024

We're not going to throw a bunch of players in the bin that we signed for millions on long term deals.

PUSB-We_are_going_up · Nov 27, 2024

They all have the ability to come good, players like Kitching, Simms, BTA, EMC have all shown us moments or spells where they have proven to have an ability to at least play football

fatso · Nov 27, 2024

mmttww said:
We're not going to throw a bunch of players in the bin that we signed for millions on long term deals.

Then operation premier league is fooked.

It doesn't matter who is managing this squad, it's just not good enough without another rebuild.

There's a number of players that need to be moved on. Such as:-

Collins
Wilson
Dasilva
Bidwell
Binks
Kitching
Allen
Torp
BTA
Tavares
Lats

That's a whole team of mediocre players who wouldn't get anywhere near a top 6 team!
And I'm being generous in not including EMC, Dovin and Raphael in the above, as they still need a chance to impress.

Your not getting rid of that number of very average players very quickly.
which means we are probably looking at another 2 or 3 seasons before we can realistically challenge for automatic promotion.

Transfer Rumour Transfer listed (1 Viewer)

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency