Summer transfer window 2024 (7 Viewers)

BlueSkiesForever · Jul 28, 2024

skybluegod said:
If the calibre of player/right players are only available once/if that happens then it's the right thing to wait. You can't force the transfer market without being top of the tree in terms of transfers and we certainly aren't.

Whilst I get your point and do agree that if the right player isn’t available we shouldn’t buy them, but I do also think that there surely must be a player out there that is the right player, even at all budgets? What exactly is the perfect player anyway?

Even for a professional scout it’s hard to know what a player will turn into before you suggest them to the management. It’s not like there’s only 50 midfielders to choose from, there’s literally hundreds and hundreds of potential targets, either at say £5-7 mil (if we get the Vik money) or at say £1-2 mil (if we don’t get the Vik money). I’m always happy to be wrong but I do find it odd that there simply is no midfielder in the whole world that doesn’t fit the bill

Hobo · Jul 28, 2024

Brighton Sky Blue said:
Well, Lati is the main example in the squad and he genuinely is a 'jack of all trades master of none' in my view. If you can find a player who's what we need in multiple positions it makes obvious sense to sign him. Burroughs who's equally strong on either foot could be one if he improves this season, for one example.

Eccles has proved he can play in a variety of roles. EMC maybe another going forward that van play across the front three? The best one we had season before last was Doyle. Very young but acquitted himself well across all three centre back positions. I think it was an attribute that passed many fans by?

skyblue_55 · Jul 28, 2024

We are all hoping that the Arsenal at least , show an interest in Vik ?
At Arsenal though , they are stating that Nketiah has to be moved on first , before the alleged €80 - 100 million is agreed on !
Then surely , all our dream team players , to finish this season’s jigsaw , can be completed ?

ccfc1234 · Jul 28, 2024

Hobo said:
Eccles has proved he can play in a variety of roles. EMC maybe another going forward that van play across the front three? The best one we had season before last was Doyle. Very young but acquitted himself well across all three centre back positions. I think it was an attribute that passed many fans by?

Ipswich had some big loans in their team. We should look to send a couple out on loan so we can bring in a top quality loan perhaps in the LB area and spend some money on a 6 and a 9.

Hobo · Jul 28, 2024

BlueSkiesForever said:
Whilst I get your point and do agree that if the right player isn’t available we shouldn’t buy them, but I do also think that there surely must be a player out there that is the right player, even at all budgets? What exactly is the perfect player anyway?

Even for a professional scout it’s hard to know what a player will turn into before you suggest them to the management. It’s not like there’s only 50 midfielders to choose from, there’s literally hundreds and hundreds of potential targets, either at say £5-7 mil (if we get the Vik money) or at say £1-2 mil (if we don’t get the Vik money). I’m always happy to be wrong but I do find it odd that there simply is no midfielder in the whole world that doesn’t fit the bill ..

But you have to find them and scout them. You can't just say he plays in midfield and has played X amount of games so must be ok?

If all those players are out there and that easy to find show us your list. Please don't say it's not my job. Because I will say don't criticise the people doing the job then because you obviously know Jack about it.

The bottom line is every professional club in the world is looking for the next diamond.

Hobo · Jul 28, 2024

ccfc1234 said:
Ipswich had some big loans in their team. We should look to send a couple out on loan so we can bring in a top quality loan perhaps in the LB area and spend some money on a 6 and a 9.

I have said in previous posts if we miss out on targets we may need to look at loans. But until Prem teams have their pre season and settle on what their squads are the top quality loans aren't available until later in the window.

Deleted member 9744 · Jul 28, 2024

ccfc1234 said:
Ipswich had some big loans in their team. We should look to send a couple out on loan so we can bring in a top quality loan perhaps in the LB area and spend some money on a 6 and a 9.

I don’t think it is realistic to consider promotion if we ignore the loan market.

junglej13 · Jul 28, 2024

I think we knew this anyway but seems Sporting have released a statement today about our sell on clause for Viktor reducing to 10%.

Seems to read like they have had to pay us €1m to trigger this...

Edit - I have considered deleting this for fear of opening up the thread on the percentage amount again!

BlueSkiesForever · Jul 28, 2024

Hobo said:
But you have to find them and scout them. You can't just say he plays in midfield and has played X amount of games so must be ok?

If all those players are out there and that easy to find show us your list. Please don't say it's not my job. Because I will say don't criticise the people doing the job then because you obviously know Jack about it.

The bottom line is every professional club in the world is looking for the next diamond.

I know what you mean and I’m not discounting your argument, I’m just questioning the point that’s often made on here that “well the player isn’t available so that’s that”. It just seems like a throwaway comment to me.

You say that I should provide a list of players because “I’m criticising the scouts” but it’s not the scouts I’m criticising, it’s the point previously made that I’m criticising, the idea that there’s no player out there that’s right for us. How do we know that’s the case? We may not get someone in for a variety of reasons not just because “there’s not a soul out there that’s right for us”.

Also, why do we have to find “gems” all the time? We all like having the next best kept secret in our team, or unearthing a hidden talent for the price of a bag of chips, but sometimes a team just needs known quality or experienced players. (I’m down for both potential and experience btw, I’m not having a go at you or suggesting what you said is wrong, we just need a bit of balance in the team imo.)

Edit: ffs that was once again a lot longer than I intended

Alkhen · Jul 28, 2024

junglej13 said:
I think we knew this anyway but seems Sporting have released a statement today about our sell on clause for Viktor reducing to 10%.

Seems to read like they have had to pay us €1m to trigger this...

Edit - I have considered deleting this for fear of opening up the thread on the percentage amount again!

It's 13.5% as verified by the SBT mathematics team

skybluegod · Jul 28, 2024

BlueSkiesForever said:
I know what you mean and I’m not discounting your argument, I’m just questioning the point that’s often made on here that “well the player isn’t available so that’s that”. It just seems like a throwaway comment to me.

You say that I should provide a list of players because “I’m criticising the scouts” but it’s not the scouts I’m criticising, it’s the point previously made that I’m criticising, the idea that there’s no player out there that’s right for us. How do we know that’s the case? We may not get someone in for a variety of reasons not just because “there’s not a soul out there that’s right for us”.

Also, why do we have to find “gems” all the time? We all like having the next best kept secret in our team, or unearthing a hidden talent for the price of a bag of chips, but sometimes a team just needs known quality or experienced players. (I’m down for both potential and experience btw, I’m not having a go at you or suggesting what you said is wrong, we just need a bit of balance in the team imo.)

Edit: ffs that was once again a lot longer than I intended

Where did I say there isn't a player out there for us you have filled in gaps to what I said to suit an argument.

We will 100% sign somebody there is no doubt for me. But I also suspect we would prefer to wait to see if we can go out and sign the a preferred target rather than settling for somebody. Which is what it should be.

Chris1987 · Jul 28, 2024

Thoroughly laughable how some on here seem to think that there is player available at any price that will be right for the position we need to fill.

Deleted member 9744 · Jul 28, 2024

Chris1987 said:
Thoroughly laughable how some on here seem to think that there is player available at any price that will be right for the position we need to fill.

And that we can just go handing out endless four year contracts to players that we then decide aren't up to it.

BlueSkiesForever · Jul 28, 2024

skybluegod said:
Where did I say there isn't a player out there for us you have filled in gaps to what I said to suit an argument.

We will 100% sign somebody there is no doubt for me. But I also suspect we would prefer to wait to see if we can go out and sign the a preferred target rather than settling for somebody. Which is what it should be.

Tbf you did say “if”, so I’m not saying that you personally are saying we won’t sign anyone, I’m just talking about the point that I’ve seen on here many times which is something along the lines of “there’s no players available therefore we can’t sign anyone”. Obviously that’s not word for word what you said but it’s in a similar ballpark. I’m not having a go at you personally, it’s more that particular argument that I disagree with.

BlueSkiesForever · Jul 28, 2024

Chris1987 said:
Thoroughly laughable how some on here seem to think that there is player available at any price that will be right for the position we need to fill.

But there’s literally hundreds of potential players to look at, think of all the leagues we could possibly look at across the world and all the teams in those leagues and all the midfielders in those teams, it’s literally hundreds and hundreds.

I’m not expecting our scouts to have scouted the whole world but you’d think they’d have done a hell of a lot of research and for that research to yield zero results just doesn’t seem right to me. Even if the top 10 targets turn us down you’d think there’d be another 20-30 targets behind that ready to inquired about?

Chris1987 · Jul 28, 2024

BlueSkiesForever said:
But there’s literally hundreds of potential players to look at, think of all the leagues we could possibly look at across the world and all the teams in those leagues and all the midfielders in those teams, it’s literally hundreds and hundreds.

I’m not expecting our scouts to have scouted the whole world but you’d think they’d have done a hell of a lot of research and for that research to yield zero results just doesn’t seem right to me. Even if the top 10 targets turn us down you’d think there’d be another 20-30 targets behind that ready to inquired about?

That's why they're scouts and you aren't.

BlueSkiesForever · Jul 28, 2024

Chris1987 said:
That's why they're scouts and you aren't.

Yeah and? That’s blatantly obvious, we’ll all just fans on here (I assume), doesn’t mean I can’t have a good old speculation about the reasoning behind why we’ve not signed a defensive CM so far

There must be someone somewhere that’s right for us in some regard, we’re not even after an exact Sheaf replacement, just a decent CM that can be rotated with Eccles/Torp/Sheaf/Allen etc.

Perennial Lurker · Jul 28, 2024

Chris1987 said:
Thoroughly laughable how some on here seem to think that there is player available at any price that will be right for the position we need to fill.

And to hell with FFP , as long as we get the right player !
So many on here miss the constraints we are working within when they mention multiple signings .
As said earlier we've had 4 in and 4 out ,how much realistically is left of our allocated wage budget
Honestly some need to think before posting about numerous new signings which are quite frankly not needed in certain positions

Perennial Lurker · Jul 28, 2024

BlueSkiesForever said:
Yeah and? That’s blatantly obvious, we’ll all just fans on here (I assume), doesn’t mean I can’t have a good old speculation about the reasoning behind why we’ve not signed a defensive CM so far

There must be someone somewhere that’s right for us in some regard, we’re not even after an exact Sheaf replacement, just a decent CM that can be rotated with Eccles/Torp/Sheaf/Allen etc.

I'm underwhelmed by this post

Chris1987 · Jul 28, 2024

BlueSkiesForever said:
Yeah and? That’s blatantly obvious, we’ll all just fans on here (I assume), doesn’t mean I can’t have a good old speculation about the reasoning behind why we’ve not signed a defensive CM so far

There must be someone somewhere that’s right for us in some regard, we’re not even after an exact Sheaf replacement, just a decent CM that can be rotated with Eccles/Torp/Sheaf/Allen etc.

Exactly so just be patient.

Chris1987 · Jul 28, 2024

Perennial Lurker said:
And to hell with FFP , as long as we get the right player !
So many on here miss the constraints we are working within when they mention multiple signings .
As said earlier we've had 4 in and 4 out ,how much realistically is left of our allocated wage budget
Honestly some need to think before posting about numerous new signings which are quite frankly not needed in certain positions

And constantly using loads of words to spout bollocks

Perennial Lurker · Jul 28, 2024

Chris1987 said:
And constantly using loads of words to spout bollocks

He's got to be an only child hasn't he ?

Chris1987 · Jul 28, 2024

Perennial Lurker said:
He's got to be an only child hasn't he ?

A special one

Perennial Lurker · Jul 28, 2024

Chris1987 said:
A special one

Marty · Jul 28, 2024

Antoni Kozubal at Lech Poznan is someone the club should keep tabs on. One of the best performers for Lech over the opening weekends of the Ekstraklasa season. Still only 19, only seen him from the highlights of games but has quick feet, good range of passing, calm in possession, wouldn't be ready for the Championship just yet but potentially in a year or two, if I remember I'll give there next game a watch and have a better idea on him.

wingy · Jul 28, 2024

BlueSkiesForever said:
Yeah and? That’s blatantly obvious, we’ll all just fans on here (I assume), doesn’t mean I can’t have a good old speculation about the reasoning behind why we’ve not signed a defensive CM so far

There must be someone somewhere that’s right for us in some regard, we’re not even after an exact Sheaf replacement, just a decent CM that can be rotated with Eccles/Torp/Sheaf/Allen etc.

Maybe we're shipping one out?
Who knows!

Perennial Lurker · Jul 28, 2024

wingy said:
Maybe we're shipping one out?
Who knows!

I think we may need to if we are to fully recruit

BlueSkiesForever · Jul 28, 2024

Perennial Lurker said:
And to hell with FFP , as long as we get the right player !
So many on here miss the constraints we are working within when they mention multiple signings .
As said earlier we've had 4 in and 4 out ,how much realistically is left of our allocated wage budget
Honestly some need to think before posting about numerous new signings which are quite frankly not needed in certain positions

Who said anything about cost? I’m not talking about cost at all, I’m simply disagreeing with the idea that there may be no players out there that fit the bill. Whether the player costs 500K or £5 mil, I’m sure there must be someone out there that’s right for us.

BlueSkiesForever · Jul 28, 2024

Perennial Lurker said:
He's got to be an only child hasn't he ?

Got a sister, unfortunately for her

Monty · Jul 29, 2024

Perennial Lurker said:
And to hell with FFP , as long as we get the right player !
So many on here miss the constraints we are working within when they mention multiple signings .
As said earlier we've had 4 in and 4 out ,how much realistically is left of our allocated wage budget
Honestly some need to think before posting about numerous new signings which are quite frankly not needed in certain positions

Fully agree with all these comments. There is a limit to the squad size of only 25 players over the age of 21 too. As a whole I think most of us are fairly happy with our potential starting 11 therefore we want the rest of the squad to improve so we have sufficient cover. We are not going to spend millions on cover as unsurprisingly expensive players will expect to start. I do wonder if the injuries and preseason performances at the moment will have made us switch targets. I know I hoped Burroughs would be a solution however his reviews haven't been great on here. I thought Obikwu potentially could stop us needing a new forward thinking if Simms was injured then Wright would.play down the middle but with Simms and Wright injured we are looking light. But it is getting the right player in at the right price. They need a certain skillset, need potential to improve, need to fit into the squad and need to be the right price. So not a panic buy. If we buy some players will need to move on to to create space in the squad, I can envisage 5 in, 3 outs plus potentially some youngsters loaned out. The main outs been Wilson or Collins, Burroughs and then possibly someone like Palmer who.although I think would be invaluable from the bench might want to be a starter.

SkyB · Jul 29, 2024

junglej13 said:
I think we knew this anyway but seems Sporting have released a statement today about our sell on clause for Viktor reducing to 10%.

Seems to read like they have had to pay us €1m to trigger this...

Edit - I have considered deleting this for fear of opening up the thread on the percentage amount again!

To me this suggests it's 10% of the full transfer rather than 10% of profit made on it?

Deity · Jul 29, 2024

Doesn’t capital gain imply on the profit Sporting Make on the player not the total fee ?

StrettoBoy · Jul 29, 2024

Preston North End reportedly set to pip Standard Liege to wing-back signing

Preston North End are set to win the race for Ilay Camara ahead of Standard Liege, with Burnley and Coventry City also keen.

footballleagueworld.co.uk

biggymania · Jul 29, 2024

SkyB said:
To me this suggests it's 10% of the full transfer rather than 10% of profit made on it?

No - it's capital gain. Meaning we've already received 24M (hence the reduction from 15% to 10%).

So - assuming Sporting sell him for 100M - that would be a capital gain of 76M so a kickback of 7.6M EUR to Coventry or about 6.4M GBP.

The reduction from 15% to 10% means we've already received 4M EUR of the performance related bonuses, I think.

EDIT: However, that article claims we received 2M EUR of bonuses and Sporting paid us another 1M to exercise an option. It sounds like they had an option to pay 1M to further reduce the % and have took it. This in & of itself implies a transfer might be happening but for them to lose on that deal Gyokeres would have to sell for less than 43M - so I think this is a no brainer for Sporting to take that option.

Brighton Sky Blue · Jul 29, 2024

StrettoBoy said:
Preston North End reportedly set to pip Standard Liege to wing-back signing

Preston North End are set to win the race for Ilay Camara ahead of Standard Liege, with Burnley and Coventry City also keen.

footballleagueworld.co.uk

The other two clearly aren’t that keen if he’s going there.

Summer transfer window 2024 (7 Viewers)

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Deleted member 9744

Guest

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Deleted member 9744

Guest

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency