ratings vs vale (1 Viewer)

i prefer the telegraphs report :laugh:

Im still trying to figure out how everyone is giving tudgay such high ratings every week...

Burge 4 - very strange positioning for the free-kick.

Phillips 4
Martin 4
Pennington 5
Stokes 4

Barton 3 - I'm not one of those fans that hates possession and screams 'forward' every 10 seconds, but Barton's first instinct is to slow us down and go backwards. Kills our attacks and does nothing to stop the opposition's.
Fleck 5 - Played higher up and was good in the first half. Pity he didn't play after half-time.
O'Brien 6

Nouble 6 - Our biggest threat.
Samuel 5 - Why was he on the wing? Worst game I've seen from him.
Tudgay 5


Williams 4
Odelusi 6
Jackson 3 - genuinely forgot he'd even come on.

Today was atrocious. Everything, even the very basics of the game, looks a real struggle for most of these players at the moment.

skybluesam98 said:

Im still trying to figure out how everyone is giving tudgay such high ratings every week...

Click to expand...

Same with O'Brien. Thought he was shocking yesterday.

CCFC_Charlie said:

Same with O'Brien. Thought he was shocking yesterday.

Click to expand...

Besides the goal he didn't do much of note it has to be said.

Sutty said:

Burge 4 - very strange positioning for the free-kick.

Phillips 4
Martin 4
Pennington 5
Stokes 4

Barton 3 - I'm not one of those fans that hates possession and screams 'forward' every 10 seconds, but Barton's first instinct is to slow us down and go backwards. Kills our attacks and does nothing to stop the opposition's.
Fleck 5 - Played higher up and was good in the first half. Pity he didn't play after half-time.
O'Brien 6

Nouble 6 - Our biggest threat.
Samuel 5 - Why was he on the wing? Worst game I've seen from him.
Tudgay 5


Williams 4
Odelusi 6
Jackson 3 - genuinely forgot he'd even come on.

Today was atrocious. Everything, even the very basics of the game, looks a real struggle for most of these players at the moment.

Click to expand...

Would agree about Nouble. Think he looked our most threatening player yesterday.

Barton concerns me. He definitely has bags of talent and he started the game off well yesterday for the first 20 mins or so, but then after that the game seemed to pass him by.

Thought myself that Fleck had a better game than O'Brien and I didn't think Philips was as bad as a rating of 4.

Burge 4 not sure about free kick need to see again, dodgy kicking
Phillips 5
Martin 3 this bloke is the worst player on the ball we've ever had
Pennington 4 one min looks amazing the next he's got big mistake in him. Bit like Ben turner u know he's going to be good but how quickly can he cut out the errors.
Stokes 4 - fans near me were blaming him for second goal but he was left 2 on 1
Barton 5 interesting tactic to use him to screen pope
Fleck 6 great first half but should have scored just after ht and got worse the further he dropped back
O'brien 6 good goal but then usual head down rubbish
Nouble 5 he should be ripping this league up and isn't.
Tudgay 5 strange positioning throughout the game
Samuels 5

Williams 3
Odelisu 7 this lad looks class need to keep him fit
Jackson 3 lad behind me constantly bangs on about his pace as if he's huckerby. Webster could probably out sprint him

Central midfielder in on loan Monday please Mr. Mowbray.

speedie87 said:

Burge 4 not sure about free kick need to see again,

Click to expand...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IWAUfPD-SoA
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=glH66GdPVcM

Burge 5
Phillips 5
Pennington 6
Martin 4
Stokes 4
Barton 3
O'brien 5
Fleck 5
Nouble 5
Tudguy 5
Samuel 4

Odelusi 6
Jackson 3
Williams 3


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk - so please excuse any spelling or grammar errors