Prices can go up as well as down (1 Viewer)

blunted · Sep 6, 2024

Well a good few people think we have a strict transfer policy where we can only now buy to improve and profit. Here is my take on most of the current squad regarding making money at this moment in time:
Dovin, Asante, Bassette, Rudoni, Binks, Raphael too early to judge Neutral.
Up in price as free transfers although possible small fee only: Bidwell, Wilson.
Up in price as free transfer or small compensation fee but a better fee: JDS, Lati.
Up in price from Academy: Eccles.
Large rise in value: MVE, Haji Wright, Sheaf.
Slight rise in value: Tatsu, Allen, Simms.
No change: Collins, Thomas,
Down in value: Kitching, EMC, Torp.
This is only my opinion regarding this moment in time and form as I see it since they have joined the club. Some will go up, others down. Injuries have an impact (see Tatsu).
My take so far is don't buy L1 players for over £4 million.

skybluecam · Sep 6, 2024

How is EMC not in the too early to judge category lmao

mark82 · Sep 6, 2024

EMC needs to be in too early to judge.
Torp probably in the no change given the modest fee.
Allen will probably go on a free, but think we've had value for money there anyway.

COVKIDSNEVERQUIT · Sep 6, 2024

blunted said:
Well a good few people think we have a strict transfer policy where we can only now buy to improve and profit. Here is my take on most of the current squad regarding making money at this moment in time:
Dovin, Asante, Bassette, Rudoni, Binks, Raphael too early to judge Neutral.
Up in price as free transfers although possible small fee only: Bidwell, Wilson.
Up in price as free transfer or small compensation fee but a better fee: JDS, Lati.
Up in price from Academy: Eccles.
Large rise in value: MVE, Haji Wright, Sheaf.
Slight rise in value: Tatsu, Allen, Simms.
No change: Collins, Thomas,
Down in value: Kitching, EMC, Torp.
This is only my opinion regarding this moment in time and form as I see it since they have joined the club. Some will go up, others down. Injuries have an impact (see Tatsu).
My take so far is don't buy L1 players for over £4 million.

" Down in Value" Kitching, EMC, Torp.

Still have Time to Improve.

HadjiChippo · Sep 6, 2024

EMC has taken a step up in career and will take time for him to adjust, you get far less freedom and time in the championship, regardless of how good you are. I trust he’ll come good once he’s up to speed and had a good run of minutes.

It took Haji a good run of game time to get up to speed and adapt, now I’d put him up there with anyone in this division going forward.

Im not ready to discount Torp either, he’s definitely shown glimpses of being a very good player last season and has also been here a very short time in a new country, and one of the most competitive leagues in the world.

Plus, the profits we could potentially make on MVE and Haji alone will dwarf a decent proportion of our spend and should allow for more reinvestment in the future.

Northants Sky Blue · Sep 6, 2024

blunted said:
My take so far is don't buy L1 players for over £4 million.

And buying 3 for nearly 16m is a big big gamble - especially when your manager has a reputation of working with low budgets

Cally Fedora · Sep 6, 2024

Kitching will go way up in value for me. Dovin as well.

Razzle Dazzle Dean Gordon · Sep 6, 2024

What did we pay for Torp?

Marty · Sep 6, 2024

Razzle Dazzle Dean Gordon said:
What did we pay for Torp?

Too much.

Razzle Dazzle Dean Gordon · Sep 6, 2024

Marty said:
Too much.

I've got £2m in mind but may have completely made that up, just noticed Mark calling it a 'modest fee' is all

Brighton Sky Blue · Sep 6, 2024

Seems some people are taking their frustrations on the debacle in midfield out on players who have barely been here a calendar year.

Earlsdon_Skyblue1 · Sep 6, 2024

I really wish we had won the game against Norwich. This international break is painful!

Ashdown · Sep 6, 2024

EMC has to improve I think. He came fairly highly rated so hasn’t just turned into a poor player. He needs something good to happen to him to give him confidence .
A goal or decent assist will do wonders

Brighton Sky Blue · Sep 6, 2024

Ashdown said:
EMC has to improve I think. He came fairly highly rated so hasn’t just turned into a poor player. He needs something good to happen to him to give him confidence .
A goal or decent assist will do wonders

Or the gap between the leagues is genuinely big and he will need time to adapt.

skybluecam · Sep 6, 2024

Marty said:
Too much.

He was £2m and I bet he’s on a very modest wage too.

You don’t get ready made championship stars for that sort of money.

BlueSkiesForever · Sep 7, 2024

I think @blunted is right tbf, if you look at the current value of the players rather than speculating on what they could make, then Kitching is worth nowhere near what we paid for him, same for Torp, he’s alright but he’s no better than average for this league. EMC I agree is too early to call but Kitching and Torp have been here long enough to make a reasonable assessment on them. All 3 of them have potential to improve, Torp for example has a wonder-strike on him but needs to pick up on his movement and awareness a bit.

As for Dasilva, Lati, Allen and Bidwell, if we did get any fee for them it’d be so minute that it’s basically negligible. The real money is in Van Ewijk first and foremost, then Sheaf, Haji and Simms.

blunted · Sep 7, 2024

skybluecam said:
How is EMC not in the too early to judge category lmao

Yeah, think he will get better but over 4 million looks high at present.

Ricketts · Sep 7, 2024

EMC looks amazing when played in his preferred (I would assume) left side position

StrettoBoy · Sep 7, 2024

Ricketts said:
EMC looks amazing when played in his preferred (I would assume) left side position

He’s definitely better on the left.

He needs time to adjust to playing at a higher level but I think he will. He has strength and pace which are key attributes.

stevefloyd · Sep 7, 2024

He's got something for sure he is fast but not super fast and when he starts believing in himself and maybe get a goal or 2 he will become a firm favourite

blunted · Sep 7, 2024

On reflection, this thread would have been better served much later in the season.
Almost impossible to predict how players will progress at this stage.
Even Vic and Gus started slowly and many people on here were criticising Sheaf.
The only thing I would say is, that at over £4 million a piece Kitch and EMC should be showing so much in training that they start league matches.
Early days for EMC, we will see.

Legia Sky Blue · Sep 8, 2024

blunted said:
On reflection, this thread would have been better served much later in the season.
Almost impossible to predict how players will progress at this stage.
Even Vic and Gus started slowly and many people on here were criticising Sheaf.
The only thing I would say is, that at over £4 million a piece Kitch and EMC should be showing so much in training that they start league matches.
Early days for EMC, we will see.

Highlighted is correct. EMC's best position is where we play £7m Wright so in terms of cost Wright should be ahead of him. Kitching has simply been stymied by being suspended at the start of the season and by his replacement Binks having a half decent start to the season. There's a long way to go in this season yet!

Warwickhunt · Sep 8, 2024

Ashdown said:
EMC has to improve I think. He came fairly highly rated so hasn’t just turned into a poor player. He needs something good to happen to him to give him confidence .
A goal or decent assist will do wonders

Robins needs to give him a few games on the left and we will see there is a player there

Sky_Blue_Dreamer · Sep 8, 2024

Warwickhunt said:
Robins needs to give him a few games on the left and we will see there is a player there

With Wright away on international duty I hope EMC gets the nod on the left.

blunted · Nov 24, 2024

With a new Manager (sorry Head Coach) I wonder where the value of players stands now.
Bassette had a great game yesterday but can't be judged on one game and a few OK sub appearances.
A fit Haji has gone up in price.
Taking out free transfers and home grown talent (Eccles), can't think of a player that has increased dramatically in value.
MVE has been poor this season, Tatsu is still not back to his best following injuries and Sheaf is suffering from not being fully fit.
Lot of potential not realised.
Interesting to see how new person has improved our players at the end of the season.

wingy · Nov 25, 2024

blunted said:
Well a good few people think we have a strict transfer policy where we can only now buy to improve and profit. Here is my take on most of the current squad regarding making money at this moment in time:
Dovin, Asante, Bassette, Rudoni, Binks, Raphael too early to judge Neutral.
Up in price as free transfers although possible small fee only: Bidwell, Wilson.
Up in price as free transfer or small compensation fee but a better fee: JDS, Lati.
Up in price from Academy: Eccles.
Large rise in value: MVE, Haji Wright, Sheaf.
Slight rise in value: Tatsu, Allen, Simms.
No change: Collins, Thomas,
Down in value: Kitching, EMC, Torp.
This is only my opinion regarding this moment in time and form as I see it since they have joined the club. Some will go up, others down. Injuries have an impact (see Tatsu).
My take so far is don't buy L1 players for over £4 million.

Especially as the owner doesn't appear to or manager if he has any influence over things refuses to get the one thing that makes all of those assessments move positive,IE profitable!

Ashdown · Nov 25, 2024

I thought that was the best performance from Tats in a long time. He was very often our danger man and his crossing was better than the others. If we had any players other than Thomas that can head a ball we’d have won easily.

Prices can go up as well as down (1 Viewer)

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Super Moderator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency