Player ratings (early) (1 Viewer)

Sky Blue Pete · Sep 17, 2019

Marosi - 7.5 excellent composed passing. Great save at 1-0 to stay ahead
Dabo - 7 defensively sound, silly booking supported the attack well
Mason - 8 great to have him back so improved on last season never stopped running. Good play for Godden’s goal
Mcfazdean - 8 won everything in the air
Hyam - 8 working so well together
Shipley - 7 tired second half but worked his socks off
Walsh - 7.5 this guy is so good. Hope he stays for the season
Westbrook - 7 justified keeping his place but right to change when robins did
Kastaneer - 6.5 more involved than hiwula, deserved his goal
Godden - 8 great team player works his socks off
Jobello - 6.5 better but still his crossing needs to improve

Subs

Eccles - 6 nice cameo
Ohare - 8 does what he does and his goal was lovely

Good game - enjoyable night out

Skyblueweeman · Sep 17, 2019

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

Dimi_Konstantflapalot · Sep 17, 2019

You need to get some mates

Sky Blue Pete · Sep 17, 2019

Dimi_Konstantflapalot said:
You need to get some mates

Will you be my friend

rob9872 · Sep 17, 2019

Sky Blue Pete said:
Marosi - 7.5 excellent composed passing. Great save at 1-0 to stay ahead
Dabo - 7 defensively sound, silly booking supported the attack well
Mason - 8 great to have him back so improved on last season never stopped running. Good play for Godden’s goal
Mcfazdean - 8 won everything in the air
Hyam - 8 working so well together
Shipley - 7 tired second half but worked his socks off
Walsh - 7.5 this guy is so good. Hope he stays for the season
Westbrook - 7 justified keeping his place but right to change when robins did
Kastaneer - 6.5 more involved than hiwula, deserved his goal
Godden - 8 great team player works his socks off
Jobello - 6.5 better but still his crossing needs to improve

Subs

Eccles - 6 nice cameo
Ohare - 8 does what he does and his goal was lovely

Good game - enjoyable night out

Garbage. Did you even go to the game? Jobello easily motm for his hattrick and I thought Marosi could have done better with their second.

SkyBlueDom26 · Sep 17, 2019

Sky Blue Pete said:
Will you be my friend

eastwoodsdustman · Sep 17, 2019

Sky Blue Pete said:
Marosi - 7.5 excellent composed passing. Great save at 1-0 to stay ahead
Dabo - 7 defensively sound, silly booking supported the attack well
Mason - 8 great to have him back so improved on last season never stopped running. Good play for Godden’s goal
Mcfazdean - 8 won everything in the air
Hyam - 8 working so well together
Shipley - 7 tired second half but worked his socks off
Walsh - 7.5 this guy is so good. Hope he stays for the season
Westbrook - 7 justified keeping his place but right to change when robins did
Kastaneer - 6.5 more involved than hiwula, deserved his goal
Godden - 8 great team player works his socks off
Jobello - 6.5 better but still his crossing needs to improve

Subs

Eccles - 6 nice cameo
Ohare - 8 does what he does and his goal was lovely

Good game - enjoyable night out

What are the euro millions numbers tonight please? I feel like buying a football club.

Sky Blue Pete · Sep 17, 2019

eastwoodsdustman said:
What are the euro millions numbers tonight please? I feel like buying a football club.

Lol I started as a bit of fun but got carried away. Sorry those of you who think karma or fate is affected by this type of tripe

Dimi_Konstantflapalot · Sep 17, 2019

Sky Blue Pete said:
Will you be my friend

No, I bet your surname is Phile

Sky Blue Pete · Sep 17, 2019

Dimi_Konstantflapalot said:
No, I bet your surname is Phile

Nope

steve cooper · Sep 17, 2019

You forgot about the dog running onto the pitch, taking the ball round the keeper and heading in

Sky Blue Pete · Sep 17, 2019

steve cooper said:
You forgot about the dog running onto the pitch, taking the ball round the keeper and heading in

I so hope that happens now

Ricketts · Sep 17, 2019

Why only a 7.5 for Walsh. He was immense. Did you even watch the game?

I'll bet you are one of those that rings in to CWR.

Sky Blue Pete · Sep 17, 2019

Ricketts said:
Why only a 7.5 for Walsh. He was immense. Did you even watch the game?

I'll bet you are one of those that rings in to CWR.

Didn’t call ohare starting

Esoterica · Sep 17, 2019

80% of the player ratings are just people's confirmation bias anyway, so we might as well all submit them in advance.

Sky Blue Pete · Sep 17, 2019

Esoterica said:
80% of the player ratings are just people's confirmation bias anyway, so we might as well all submit them in advance.

That’s where I started and got carried away

Exit Stage Left · Sep 17, 2019

Ricketts said:
Why only a 7.5 for Walsh. He was immense. Did you even watch the game?

I'll bet you are one of those that rings in to CWR.

He also scored the winner.

PVA · Sep 17, 2019

Sky Blue Pete said:
Marosi - 7.5 excellent composed passing.

Well you fell at the first hurdle there.

DannyThomas_1981 · Sep 17, 2019

Marosi - 6. suicide ball
Dabo - 6 not troubled defensively. wayward distribution second half. always looking to be involved.
Mason - 7 impressive return.
Mcfazdean - 7 he's excellent at bringing the ball forward.
Hyam - 7 not really troubled. good distribution.
Shipley - 7 great energy.
Walsh - 7 not to blame for their goal although started poorly today. then grew into the game. class finish.
O'Hare - 7 looked different class in the first 30. brilliant at bringing Godden and the wide men into the game. we didn't use him enough after half time.
Hiwula - 7 excellent first 30. didn't impose himself enough after that. well taken goal. should have been 2. faded but still looked dangerous.
Godden - 7 good as always. but should have taken one of his chances.
Jobello - 6 a game in which he should have imposed himself far more given our possession.

Subs

Max - not on for long enough - I would have liked to have seen more of Max and Godden operating together.
Kast - too short a cameo to really judge.

Will take the result!!!

hill83 · Sep 17, 2019

Esoterica said:
80% of the player ratings are just people's confirmation bias anyway, so we might as well all submit them in advance.

Can’t read anything into them. I’ve never submitted player ratings. It’s all nonsense.

covcity4life · Sep 17, 2019

Marosi 5 poor decision cost us once and nearly again after.

Mcfadz 6

Hyam 6

Dabo 6 he makes mistakes but inpacts game.more than sterling did it feels like

Mason 7 v good first came back

Walsh 6 poor mistske for pen, few bad passes but he does keep it tickijg regardless and brillisnt winner

Shipley 6.5 was poor till that amazing thru ball to hiwula. Then played well enough but nothing special till that brill work for winner. Ive had my issues with shipley but he can be clutch as the americans say

O hare 6.5 always looks likely to make somethinf hapoen when hes om ball. Today fibal produxt wasnt there but he still makes us dangerous

Hiwula 5 good goal but missed a good chance then faded

Jobello 4 poor game bar a few good crosses

Godden 6.5 works so hard and sets up others too even when hes not scoring

Kastaneer 5
Biamou not on long enough but good hold up and pass outwide which may have led to fk for walshm cant remmeber

Esoterica · Sep 17, 2019

hill83 said:
Can’t read anything into them. I’ve never submitted player ratings. It’s all nonsense.

Apart from mine, which are correct.

hill83 · Sep 17, 2019

Esoterica said:
Apart from mine, which are correct.

As mine would be if I did them. They’d be out of 100 though and be much more in depth and nuanced. Probably accompanied by a video of me pointing at a screen.

Sky Blue Pete · Sep 17, 2019

covcity4life said:
Marosi 5 poor decision cost us once and nearly again after.

Mcfadz 6

Hyam 6

Dabo 6 he makes mistakes but inpacts game.more than sterling did it feels like

Mason 7 v good first came back

Walsh 6 poor mistske for pen, few bad passes but he does keep it tickijg regardless and brillisnt winner

Shipley 6.5 was poor till that amazing thru ball to hiwula. Then played well enough but nothing special till that brill work for winner. Ive had my issues with shipley but he can be clutch as the americans say

O hare 6.5 always looks likely to make somethinf hapoen when hes om ball. Today fibal produxt wasnt there but he still makes us dangerous

Hiwula 5 good goal but missed a good chance then faded

Jobello 4 poor game bar a few good crosses

Godden 6.5 works so hard and sets up others too even when hes not scoring

Kastaneer 5
Biamou not on long enough but good hold up and pass outwide which may have led to fk for walshm cant remmeber

You know we won don’t you?

Esoterica · Sep 17, 2019

hill83 said:
As mine would be if I did them. They’d be out of 100 though and be much more in depth and nuanced. Probably accompanied by a video of me pointing at a screen.

The 100 scale is the thinking man's way and deftly avoids the pitiful self-humiliation of awarding players a .5 mark.

HuckerbyDublinWhelan · Sep 17, 2019

Marosi - 5 a number of times nearly gifted them goals, goal was a poor pass from him.

Dabo - 6, did alright, passing was a bit off

Mason - 7

Hyam - 7

McFadzean - 8

Shipley - 8. 2 assists played well

Walsh - 8, started shaken but grew into the game lovely play for his goal

O’Hare - 9 brilliant first start, hope it continues

Hiwula - 6, took goal well, could have easily had a few more. Runs were good but last touch was awful

Godden - 6, thought it was his worst game for us so far. Tried with what he got, but wasn’t the same player he has been

Jobello -6, a lot of puff but not much coming off for him

Subs:
Biamou and Kastaneer - didn’t really influence anything so no rating

Overall delighted with the win. Think the weekend break is coming at a good time for us - we look a little jaded

fernandopartridge · Sep 17, 2019

Sky Blue Pete said:
You know we won don’t you?

Yes but didn't play well, the players will rate their own performance based on nothing but their perception of how they played regardless of outcome, why would anyone do differently?

covcity4life · Sep 17, 2019

Sky Blue Pete said:
You know we won don’t you?

Are we judging the performance or the result?

And you know marosi cost us first goal right?. Thats worth a 7? Lmao

Laighing stock of forum you are.

stevefloyd · Sep 17, 2019

I am just going to go mad and give them all a high mark for battling until the end and bringing all 3 points back

harvey098 · Sep 17, 2019

I’ve been saying not to put O’Hare in the middle 3 (I wanted him in the forward 3) but I was so wrong. He was great in there. His touch is fabric.

Mcfadz 8
O’Hare 7.5
Mason 7.5
Shipley 7.5
The rest 7’s

ccfcway · Sep 17, 2019

covcity4life said:
Marosi 5 poor decision cost us once and nearly again after.

Mcfadz 6

Hyam 6

Dabo 6 he makes mistakes but inpacts game.more than sterling did it feels like

Mason 7 v good first came back

Walsh 6 poor mistske for pen, few bad passes but he does keep it tickijg regardless and brillisnt winner

Shipley 6.5 was poor till that amazing thru ball to hiwula. Then played well enough but nothing special till that brill work for winner. Ive had my issues with shipley but he can be clutch as the americans say

O hare 6.5 always looks likely to make somethinf hapoen when hes om ball. Today fibal produxt wasnt there but he still makes us dangerous

Hiwula 5 good goal but missed a good chance then faded

Jobello 4 poor game bar a few good crosses

Godden 6.5 works so hard and sets up others too even when hes not scoring

Kastaneer 5
Biamou not on long enough but good hold up and pass outwide which may have led to fk for walshm cant remmeber

No way was McFaz a 6. MOTM and captains performance

Sky Blue Pete · Sep 17, 2019

covcity4life said:
Are we judging the performance or the result?

And you know marosi cost us first goal right?. Thats worth a 7? Lmao

Laighing stock of forum you are.

Bollox! Marosi definite 6. Were you at the game?
Jobello 4??

Shipley 6.5

Absolute tosh

Sky Blue Pete · Sep 17, 2019

ccfcway said:
No way was McFaz a 6. MOTM and captains performance

He is the joker of the forum

Sky Blue Pete · Sep 17, 2019

stevefloyd said:
I am just going to go mad and give them all a high mark for battling until the end and bringing all 3 points back

Get your 4/10’s out!!

covcity4life · Sep 17, 2019

ccfcway said:
No way was McFaz a 6. MOTM and captains performance

6 is good. Cant argue with a 7 tho

Player ratings (early) (1 Viewer)

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency