Nottingham forest game postponed (1 Viewer)

edgy said:

What "costly" mistakes has Wilson made? As in directly cost us points? Not saying he hasn't but I've not attributed much blame his way during his stint in nets.

Click to expand...

To be honest, I think you might be right in that he hasn't cost us many points with his errors but that is more by luck than judgement. There have been too many errors that luckily for us have gone unpunished and that shouldn't go unnoticed just because of luck. That also isn't to say he's done a 'bad' job. He has done better than I imagined a League One second choice keeper would have done stepping into a team unexpectedly.
On a separate note, this isn't a slate of Kelly at all as I like him a lot, but it concerns me that everyone has decided that he was the entire reason we won games. It is like saying Wilson is better than Marosi because we have had more wins since. There has been a distinct more defensive system change that coincided with Wilson replacing Marosi and around the period Kelly came back in. I think people shouldn't look at a teams win % with a specific player in and treat is as gospel. Not saying you have by the way.

edgy said:

What "costly" mistakes has Wilson made? As in directly cost us points? Not saying he hasn't but I've not attributed much blame his way during his stint in nets.

Click to expand...

Given away how many pens? 2 or 3 (can't remember exactly). Shit kick at PNE that led to free kick for 2nd goal and then not claiming the ball as it ricocheted around the box for the same goal. No mans land for the goal against Sheff Weds. Not to mention the flap for the disallowed goal away to Wycombe.

Not calculated how many points that's cost us but it's at least 4 goals. I can't remember Marosi making errors costing us four goals in his whole career.

I think Wilson has been better than we could have hoped for, but it's a real stretch to claim he's been as good as Marosi.

superskyblue said:

Given away how many pens? 2 or 3 (can't remember exactly). Shit kick at PNE that led to free kick for 2nd goal and then not claiming the ball as it ricocheted around the box for the same goal. No mans land for the goal against Sheff Weds. Not to mention the flap for the disallowed goal away to Wycombe.

Not calculated how many points that's cost us but it's at least 4 goals. I can't remember Marosi making errors costing us four goals in his whole career.

I think Wilson has been better than we could have hoped for, but it's a real stretch to claim he's been as good as Marosi.

Click to expand...

I think there isn't too much between them and Wilson has done okay. I prefer Marosi, but remember the games last season both home and away against Rotherham for starters on his mistakes.

Colin Steins Smile said:

I think there isn't too much between them and Wilson has done okay. I prefer Marosi, but remember the games last season both home and away against Rotherham for starters on his mistakes.

Click to expand...

Those are the only two I can remember actually. I'm sure there's another one or two I've forgotten. But the point is that's 40odd games vs 10.

Colin Steins Smile said:

I think there isn't too much between them and Wilson has done okay. I prefer Marosi, but remember the games last season both home and away against Rotherham for starters on his mistakes.

Click to expand...

There isn’t too much between them is Paxman like idiocy

Grendel said:

There isn’t too much between them is Paxman like idiocy

Click to expand...

I take it that you disagree with my view.
Have you considered that you’re probably in the wrong job .....you’re a “shoe in“ for the role as Victor Meldrew. It’s that or your wife bought you a city shirt with Biamou on the back for Xmas

Colin Steins Smile said:

I take it that you disagree with my view.
Have you considered that you’re probably in the wrong job .....you’re a “shoe in“ for the role as Victor Meldrew. It’s that or your wife bought you a city shirt with Biamou on the back for Xmas

Click to expand...

Wilson is older than Marosi and haa played less than 40 league games

There is a reason for that