Michael Rose (1 Viewer)

[SlowerThanPlatt]

Left out the squad the squad today, thought Covid or injury, Robins says his decision and we had enough cover on the bench (really?). Always seems to be the fall guy

 

---

[stay_up_skyblues]

He wouldn’t have come on so this is a bit of a non-story for me. When’s the last time he subbed a CB injury notwithstanding?

 

[fernandopartridge]

He wouldn’t have come on so this is a bit of a non-story for me. When’s the last time he subbed a CB injury notwithstanding?

It isn't a non story when Hyam who was culpable for a goal at Preston (and was otherwise hopeless with the ball that night) is seemingly untouchable.

 

[lifeskyblue]

Left out the squad the squad today, thought Covid or injury, Robins says his decision and we had enough cover on the bench (really?). Always seems to be the fall guy

Odd decision if not injured/Ill. Harshly dropped from first 11 but not even on bench and no other central defender there either. V v strange.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[stay_up_skyblues]

It isn't a non story when Hyam who was culpable for a goal at Preston (and was otherwise hopeless with the ball that night) is seemingly untouchable.

I mean him being dropped from bench. If you feel he should be starting ahead of Hyam then that’s a different argument.

 

[PVA]

Should have started today, he was the best of the back 3 against Preston.

I will probably be alone in this but I think our best back three is Hyam - Fadz - Rose

 

[SlowerThanPlatt]

He wouldn’t have come on so this is a bit of a non-story for me. When’s the last time he subbed a CB injury notwithstanding?

He has had one on the bench in every game barring today and Blackburn when Clarke Salter had Covid

 

[Evo1883]

Should have started today, he was the best of the back 3 against Preston.

I will probably be alone in this but I think our best back three is Hyam - Fadz - Rose

We definitely need the balance that salter gives us , it's hyam or Rose.. no doubt hyam at fault today

 

[Brighton Sky Blue]

We definitely need the balance that salter gives us , it's hyam or Rose.. no doubt hyam at fault today

That error yes, but aside from that he played fine. Rose being dropped from the squad altogether is a bit baffling

 

[eastwoodsdustman]

I think Rose will be in vs Hull on Saturday

 

[PVA]

We definitely need the balance that salter gives us , it's hyam or Rose.. no doubt hyam at fault today

I think the left footed thing is way overrated, Rose is a good passer of the ball even on the left hand side.

JCS does lots of things well but he frustrates the hell out of me. Look how slow and casual he closed down for the goal and then he just stopped. I remember Blues fans complaining about this.

Plus I still have nightmares about that Luton game

 

[GaryMabbuttsLeftKnee]

I think Rose will be in vs Hull on Saturday

I hope so. Sheaf often framed as the person who costs us goals the most directly with mistakes, but Hyam undoubtedly made more mistakes leading to goals and it’s never mentioned. Seems to be you either think he’s untouchable or awful, when reality is he’s been pretty decent but also cost us a lot of goals


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Evo1883]

I think the left footed thing is way overrated, Rose is a good passer of the ball even on the left hand side.

JCS does lots of things well but he frustrates the hell out of me. Look how slow and casual he closed down for the goal and then he just stopped. I remember Blues fans complaining about this.

Plus I still have nightmares about that Luton game

Not sure I thought we looked much more solid overall than in the previous 2 matches , his ability to help feed maatson, in the first half they worked brilliantly together .

I think there's definitely something in it

 

[stay_up_skyblues]

He has had one on the bench in every game barring today and Blackburn when Clarke Salter had Covid

He has. I’m just making the observation he wouldn’t have come on today had he been on the bench so I’m not sure it’s a valid criticism of the manager. Albeit there are one or two to be made, this isn’t It IMO.

 

[Londonccfcfan]

Rose replacement JCS was imperious today. Rightly dropped.

Fads and Hyam didnt have their best of games 2nd half. But over the season.

The best 3 centre backs played today. End of story.

 

[stay_up_skyblues]

Wouldn’t be against seeing how Rose for Hyam against Hull pans out, as much as I do rate Dom, Rose is unlucky with the amount of first team opportunities he gets.

 

[Brighton Sky Blue]

Rose replacement JCS was imperious today. Rightly dropped.

Fads and Hyam didnt have their best of games 2nd half. But over the season.

The best 3 centre backs played today. End of story.

From the starting XI fair enough, from the bench too?

 

[Londonccfcfan]

Not sure I thought we looked much more solid overall than in the previous 2 matches , his ability to help feed maatson, in the first half they worked brilliantly together .

I think there's definitely something in it

JCS covers up all of Maatsens faults better too.

 

[Londonccfcfan]

From the starting XI fair enough, from the bench too?

Agree a bit baffled by that too.

 

[Brighton Sky Blue]

Agree a bit baffled by that too.

If we're going to drop people from the bench how about the sub keeper who will hardly ever be required. Give ourselves that bit more of a choice off the bench elsewhere

 

[Sky Blue Harry H]

We definitely need the balance that salter gives us , it's hyam or Rose.. no doubt hyam at fault today

I agree about the balance bit. I like Rose, but away at Preston he looked really uncomfortable on the ball several times when he was given it out on the left and we were supposed to be pushing for an equaliser. Looked like a square peg in a round hole.

 

[Londonccfcfan]

If we're going to drop people from the bench how about the sub keeper who will hardly ever be required. Give ourselves that bit more of a choice off the bench elsewhere

Really don't get his argument about having JJ on the bench hes never gonna come on or ever look likely to come on ever. Baffling. To see Jones on there.

 

[Brighton Sky Blue]

Really don't get his argument about having JJ on the bench hes never gonna come on or ever look likely to come on ever. Baffling. To see Jones on there.

I think he's there for being 3-0 up with 10 minutes to go

 

[no_loyalty]

Rose replacement JCS was imperious today. Rightly dropped.

Fads and Hyam didnt have their best of games 2nd half. But over the season.

The best 3 centre backs played today. End of story.

Hyam has been poor in a fair few games but seems to be the golden boy, Rose has been very unlucky to miss out today.

 

[cc84cov]

It isn't a non story when Hyam who was culpable for a goal at Preston (and was otherwise hopeless with the ball that night) is seemingly untouchable.

Compare that then to walker dropped after scoring 2

 

[cc84cov]

Really don't get his argument about having JJ on the bench hes never gonna come on or ever look likely to come on ever. Baffling. To see Jones on there.

Why not try jones for O’Hare who looked shattered

 

[SlowerThanPlatt]

Really don't get his argument about having JJ on the bench hes never gonna come on or ever look likely to come on ever. Baffling. To see Jones on there.

Does seem a body on the bench atm with no intention to use him. After 3 years out can’t imagine that’s what he had in mind

 

[SkyblueTexan]

Should have started today, he was the best of the back 3 against Preston.

I will probably be alone in this but I think our best back three is Hyam - Fadz - Rose

On current form our best back 3 is Rose, Fadz and JCS

 

[Offhegoes]

Jones is a back up for O’Hare, and that’s his best hope. He’s not a wing back, and with 4 fit centre forwards he won’t get in up front ahead of Waghorn and Walker. It is frustrating, as I’m keen to see if he’s got the goods for this league. I still have a sneaky feeling he could be our secret weapon as the season progresses.

 

[Londonccfcfan]

Does seem a body on the bench atm with no intention to use him. After 3 years out can’t imagine that’s what he had in mind

Its ridiculous when our natural width comes from wing backs. We had Kane on bench too. Really doesnt make sense at Jones on the bench over Rose. The fact MR tried to justify it still doesnt make any sense.

 

[Sky_Blue_Dreamer]

He wouldn’t have come on so this is a bit of a non-story for me. When’s the last time he subbed a CB injury notwithstanding?

Fadz looked like he may have picked up a small injury in the first half. Over a quarter of our players on the pitch are CB's. If one should get injured or whatever we'd probably have to change the system or have somelike like Sheaf fill in. Why take that risk when there are 7 positions on the bench so it's not like there isn't space for at least 3 potential game-changers.

Wilson wouldn't have come on but we put him on the bench every week, purely for the rare occasion that the keeper is either injured or sent-off. It's an insurance policy just in case.

 

[Sky_Blue_Dreamer]

Might be way off but I wonder if the club are trying to convince Hyam to sign a new contract and dropping him would harm those prospects.

 

[SlowerThanPlatt]

Might be way off but I wonder if the club are trying to convince Hyam to sign a new contract and dropping him would harm those prospects.

I can’t imagine Hyam’s stock is any higher than us tbh

 

[slowpoke]

Regards Rose other than injury I suspect there’s been words over him being dropped can’t see any other reason him not being on the subs bench.

 

[Skybluefaz]

I felt we were a CB light from the summer window and I still think we are. Hopefully we can address it in January.