Liquid Gold
Well-Known Member
Found one of the voters
Found one of the votersOr is it a case of they have a clue and you dont. Who is right ?
I dont rly thibk its a crazy statement tbh. Syaing Biamou contributed more isn't the same as saying Biamou is a better player. Other than some timely goals I wasn't blown away by walker and I want to see much more from him next seasonHe is.
I think that’s fair. It’s not a mark on their talent or ability it’s on their performance over the season and one had a real stop start and the other player up top on his own when everyone was out injuredI dont rly thibk its a crazy statement tbh. Syaing Biamou contributed more isn't the same as saying Biamou is a better player. Other than some timely goals I wasn't blown away by walker and I want to see much more from him next season
Or is it a case of they have a clue and you dont. Who is right ?
Even though Walker had a stop start season, got injured, had covid, wasnt first choice and played in a team that doesnt necessarily play to his strengths...... he still ended up with a strike rate that virtually matched that of Luton's James Collins, who was supposedly in high demand and 30 years of age.
I dont rly thibk its a crazy statement tbh. Syaing Biamou contributed more isn't the same as saying Biamou is a better player. Other than some timely goals I wasn't blown away by walker and I want to see much more from him next season
That a great but I litwrraly said said walker is better??Walker is a far better player, and I say that as someone who isn't part of the anti max sect.
I want to see more from Walker as well (and Godden), but I think injury and illness was the reason we didn't.
I agree, regardless of covid and injuries, the jury is still out on Walker for me. I'm not sure he contributes enough to our all round play for which our system is set up, and I didnt think his movement was particularly good. He did score some important goals though. Hopefully with a full preseason and injury free season we will see a better Walker, but I could see why Forest were happy to let him go.I dont rly thibk its a crazy statement tbh. Syaing Biamou contributed more isn't the same as saying Biamou is a better player. Other than some timely goals I wasn't blown away by walker and I want to see much more from him next season
I agree, regardless of covid and injuries, the jury is still out on Walker for me. I'm not sure he contributes enough to our all round play for which our system is set up, and I didnt think his movement was particularly good. He did score some important goals though. Hopefully with a full preseason and injury free season we will see a better Walker, but I could see why Forest were happy to let him go.
Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
No one is disputing that though. Just that it's not crazy to vote Biamou as having contributed more this season thats allI agree about the jury being out and have said so many times throughout 5he season, (again, I've said the same about Godden), but you have to think if they stay fit they would contribute more goal and improve our league position whereas I think Max had gone as far as he could.
No one is disputing that though. Just that it's not crazy to vote Biamou as having contributed more this season thats all
You said Wilson didn't contribute to us staying up though. And he played in games we picked up pts and some clean sheets tooIt is as statistically he had the most game time and contributed the least
It's like he never leftI logged on here to see what was happening with Liam Walsh, to find out a Max v Walker debate is going on. Confused.com !!
It's like he never left
This nonsense has years to run yet. The cult v the sect!
They should both pick an 11 and sort it out on the pitchThis nonsense has years to run yet. The cult v the sect!
I suspect that statistically, Walsh smiles more per game than Biamou and Walker combined.I logged on here to see what was happening with Liam Walsh, to find out a Max v Walker debate is going on. Confused.com !!
I'd be more than happy if that came offComing back to the subject if the thread I think we will try to get both Walsh and James
Walsh never really wanted to go back to Bristol and James has been a very positive influence at the club
Think everyone accepts Hamer will likely go at some stage. If we could pick up a replacement that we know is decent on a free transfer at 23 years of age and it meant maybe we had a surplus of defensive midfielders until Jan we'd be crazy not to be in for Walsh and James.Coming back to the subject if the thread I think we will try to get both Walsh and James
Walsh never really wanted to go back to Bristol and James has been a very positive influence at the club
Coming back to the subject if the thread I think we will try to get both Walsh and James
Walsh never really wanted to go back to Bristol and James has been a very positive influence at the club
It'd be stupid or us not to at least enter into discussions with both as they are likely to generate interest (James esp) and so neither are guranteed to sign for us. If we put all our eggs into one basket chasing one and they went elsewhere we could be left with neither. If they're both agreeable to joining I'd be tempted to bring them both in on a free despite the surfeit of midfielders it would result in.Coming back to the subject if the thread I think we will try to get both Walsh and James
Walsh never really wanted to go back to Bristol and James has been a very positive influence at the club
Cant see Hamer being here next season, (hope I'm wrong) and I think Eccles will end up ahead of Sheaf sooner or later.A Midfield of Kelly, James, Hamer, Sheaf & Walsh would be decent at Championship level for a team of our standing.
Would also enable Eccles to go & have a full season on loan at a decent, footballing League One side.
No way should Eccles go out on loan he has done all that and has shown he is ready to force his way in the team can cover full back too.A Midfield of Kelly, James, Hamer, Sheaf & Walsh would be decent at Championship level for a team of our standing.
Would also enable Eccles to go & have a full season on loan at a decent, footballing League One side.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?