Chris1987
Well-Known Member
To be fair I was questioning his criteria for judging the "reversal of the course of the club ( his words) . Absolutely nothing else.Dont just jump to conclusions
Last edited:
To be fair I was questioning his criteria for judging the "reversal of the course of the club ( his words) . Absolutely nothing else.Dont just jump to conclusionsPeople who wanted Robins to stay because 6th to 9th wasn't that much of a regression now arguing it was.
People who wanted Robins out because we dropped from 6th to 9th now arguing that's actually no big deal, good old SBT.
@Chris1987 said:Ah so we can use one 3 place lower league finish as an explanation for reversing the course of a club .
Good to know that at least in depth long term parameters are being used to formulate this judgement
On twitter today there are pictures of him training.
A couple of them should have been careful what they wished for.People who wanted Robins to stay because 6th to 9th wasn't that much of a regression now arguing it was.
People who wanted Robins out because we dropped from 6th to 9th now arguing that's actually no big deal, good old SBT.
As has been pointed out, that is with a sample size of one.In terms of league position we’ve got worse every season.
in my opinion Mark Robins was brilliant for City …. But it should be seen in context. Promotion via the play offs was the minimum expected of a club of our scale and resources in LG2, yes we were a shadow of our former selves but still big by league comparison. He did a great job in lg1 and i do believe we would have got promoted had the season not been cut short, but none of us will ever know.
His record in the championship is mixed in my view.
First couple of years we scraped by and that was a good result given relative resources. We then had the leagues best forward in Vik and 2 of the leagues best midfielders in Hamer and COH and we surpassed expectations to get into the play offs final. Last year our league form was pretty average, this year it was poor. Which ever way you try to position that, it’s a pretty mixed few seasons. It’s not the unstinting progress that some would have you believe.
Then you have all the off field stuff.
King had to make a decision as to whether he thought Robins was the right man to get us promoted. Time will tell But his achievements in Lg2 and Lg1 shouldn’t really be relevant to that decision.
I personally would have given Robins longer, but not much longer maybe 4-6 weeks.
No that’s first season we looked likely to go down all season. We finished really strongly and our end position flattered us.We stayed up comfortably in the second year of the Championship and got 64 points, 27 points more than the 3rd bottom team, stop trying to re-write history. Even the first season we finished 12 points off the relegation places, so the comment "we scraped by" is bollocks really isn't it.
No that’s first season we looked likely to go down all season. We finished really strongly and our end position flattered us.
Absolute clown.No it didn't. Your league position doesn't flatter you, of all the nonsense youve spouted that's probably the stupidest.
No one wanted Robins out when we dropped to 9th. When we dropped to 17th however...People who wanted Robins to stay because 6th to 9th wasn't that much of a regression now arguing it was.
People who wanted Robins out because we dropped from 6th to 9th now arguing that's actually no big deal, good old SBT.
The last 4 games could all be against weaker opposition meaning the position before that was actually false. The final position is the only thing that be judged on.Absolute clown.
If you are in the bottom 3 all season and win the last 4 matches to pull clear have you had a season fighting relegation, yes of course you have. Your final points total is not the only consideration when reflecting on how your season has gone.
Absolute clown.
If you are in the bottom 3 all season and win the last 4 matches to pull clear have you had a season fighting relegation, yes of course you have. Your final points total is not the only consideration when reflecting on how your season has gone.
Short memories some of these fans, remember Hamer when he did a goodbye vid at the training groundWhy wouldn't he train?
Absolute clown.
If you are in the bottom 3 all season and win the last 4 matches to pull clear have you had a season fighting relegation, yes of course you have. Your final points total is not the only consideration when reflecting on how your season has gone.
On twitter today there are pictures of him training.
He just doesn't like Doug King, he just can't see the Woods for the trees. No point debating with him.
It's not just a DK debate, it's whether Robins was the right manager as well.Jesus Christ how does Doug King debate open on every forum
Who for?
Story of this season.It's not just a DK debate, it's whether Robins was the right manager as well.
Every thread turns into chaos at the moment on here, it's boring as hell.
It's not just a DK debate, it's whether Robins was the right manager as well.
Every thread turns into chaos at the moment on here, it's boring as hell.
Bollocks.No that’s first season we looked likely to go down all season. We finished really strongly and our end position flattered us.
He's a professional footballer who's still on our pay roll. I would expect him to be training at Ryton until his moves confirmed.
Your missing the point, possibly deliberately i can’t tell.You are an absolute clown. I don't believe we spent much, if any, time in the bottom 3 all season. I've checked the data for 11, 23, 34 games played and in each of them we're outside the bottom 3.
At the half way stage of the season we were 17th and 7 points off the relegation spots.
You've got clowns like Diety who can't help but try and put down what Robins achieved.
I'd have more respect if they just came out and said it.
But while they keep doing it I'll keep calling them out.
That doesn't mean I want Lampard gone, I'm fully behind him and will give him time, but just because we're in a new era no need to keep digging at the last one.
Thats not my view and i remember how widely we celebrated when we knew we were safe. It wasn’t a shrug of the shoulders because he had felt safe all season.Your missing the point, possibly deliberately i can’t tell.
Look at the Premier League table now. Take West Ham or Palace. They are having an awful season buy anyone’s measure but if the second half of the season mirrors the first they will be well clear of relegation. It wont change that their season has been awful.
I understand CVD.
We all have our opinions on Mark Robins, but we've all been there at the lowest of the lows and without Robins and Adi, we don't get back to Championship and come within a kick of the Premier League. A lot of players contributed to that success too, but most of the plaudits have to go to Mark and Adi. I would like to think that all fans are forever thankful for their efforts.
I haven’t seen a single comment saying Robins wasn’t great for our club.Unfortunately it doesnt look as though some are
If Lati goes for profit does that count as a succesful signing?
Because the recruitment is starting to look not quite as bad as has been made out.
Stop diggingYour missing the point, possibly deliberately i can’t tell.
Look at the Premier League table now. Take West Ham or Palace. They are having an awful season buy anyone’s measure but if the second half of the season mirrors the first they will be well clear of relegation. It wont change that their season has been awful.
Anyway, sorry to quote my own post,but genuinely interested to hear people's opinions on it.
Dovin now No.1, EMC looks a player, Kitching back in the fold, (early days) and profit turned on Palmer and lati.
We certainly haven't wasted 42 mil.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?