Jukes Disallowed Goals (2 Viewers)

ashbyjan · Apr 4, 2011

At the time I didn't see much wrong with either - the first just looked like Loach dropped the ball and the second the off-side was difficult to judge but he didn't appear to be away from the defender when Clingan took the shot. Just wondered if anyone had seen a replay of the incidents? Obviously BBC didn't show them on FLS as that would be far too unbiased but wondered if they might have appeared somewhere else.

Nick · Apr 4, 2011

They are on the website

Take a look here!

Looking at it, both goals should have stood but the 2nd one was close.

I think their Goalie even admitted on Twitter it should have been a goal.

SkyBlue_Am · Apr 4, 2011

Well on Sky Sports highlights they show sammy clingans smashing shot of the bar and Luka tapping it in but called offside

http://www.skysports.com/video/inline/0,26691,16487_6851586,00.html

But no one seems to have recorded the Loach dropped catch number one for the goal only the second one where Luka hit the bar!

Nick · Apr 4, 2011

SkyBlue_Am said:
Well on Sky Sports highlights they show sammy clingans smashing shot of the bar and Luka tapping it in but called offside

http://www.skysports.com/video/inline/0,26691,16487_6851586,00.html

But no one seems to have recorded the Loach dropped catch number one for the goal only the second one where Luka hit the bar!

It is on the link above

SkyBlue_Am · Apr 4, 2011

Nick said:
It is on the link above

:facepalm: I was too slow in replying with have a look at your link now

TheRoyalScam · Apr 4, 2011

Can't see anything wrong with the first disallowed goal, but the second one Lukas looked offside to me. Coverage didn't show that sitter Holt missed from either - biased?
:blue:

Nick · Apr 4, 2011

Yep, it didn't show any of Graham's misses.

Maybe he requested them not to show it :facepalm:

DazzleTommyDazzle · Apr 4, 2011

Watched them both in slow motion on the Offal.

The first is a really bad decision. The keeper fumbles the ball and then falls into Juke who isn't moving.

The second is harder to see, but using the pause button (not sad or anything....) he looks at least level.

He's had a bit of bad luck this season, with the "over the line" no goal at Ipswich plus these 2.

Looking on the bright side - at least it made no difference to the result!

ashbyjan · Apr 4, 2011

Thanks Nick - first one definitely nothing wrong with it, second one hard to tell as he's not in shot when Sammy hits shot so would give lino benefit of the doubt on that one.

SkyBlue_Am · Apr 4, 2011

DazzleTommyDazzle said:
Watched them both in slow motion on the Offal.

The first is a really bad decision. The keeper fumbles the ball and then falls into Juke who isn't moving.

The second is harder to see, but using the pause button (not sad or anything....) he looks at least level.

He's had a bit of bad luck this season, with the "over the line" no goal at Ipswich plus these 2.

Looking on the bright side - at least it made no difference to the result!

haha that is good commitment il go with your analysis

TheRoyalScam · Apr 4, 2011

Nick said:
Yep, it didn't show any of Graham's misses.

Maybe he requested them not to show it :facepalm:

I meant Graham, not that cheating diving t#sser Holt.

We'll_live_and_die · Apr 4, 2011

Didn't he look sharp when he came on though. I've not rated his efforts this season, but he looked pretty good this weekend.

Coventry La La La · Apr 4, 2011

Their keeper got way to much protection from the linesman.... I was expecting that Loach to be a quality keeper but hes nowere near Westwood's level.

Nick · Apr 4, 2011

Coventry La La La said:
Their keeper got way to much protection from the linesman.... I was expecting that loach to be a quality keeper but hes nowere near Westwood's level.

It does my head that you aren't allowed near goalies now.

If a goalie comes running out you literally have to move out of his way else they get a foul? If they run into you going for the ball then you are fouling them?

rob9872 · Apr 4, 2011

Has anyone got a link please of Juke's goal against Hibs last season? I took a guy from work to see the Watford game and I was explaining about this goal, but the BBC link is no longer available and youtube is a banned site here.

Many thanks in advance

AngryAnt · Apr 4, 2011

Just seen the goals on the bbc.. Both of the disallowed goals should have stood, theres no foul in the first one and the second he was level.
Not that im biased or anything, but non-Coventry friends agree.

Coventry La La La · Apr 4, 2011

Jutkieiwicz ---> ointlaugh: <------ Referee and Linesman.

SkyBlueKay · Apr 4, 2011

Gutted that those 2 goals didn't stand, there was absolutely nothing wrong with the first and I didn't think he was offside for the 2nd! He had an absolutely cracking game!

We'll_live_and_die · Apr 4, 2011

Wouldn't a 4-0 drubbing by the city have been fantastic. I thoroughly enjoyed the day, 4-0 would have been icing on the cake.

Nonleagueherewecome · Apr 4, 2011

Definitely nothing wrong with the first, as Loach himself admits! He just dropped it and it bounced off Lukas and in. I will say that he made a couple of other good saves from King and McSheffrey, so didn't have a complete 'mare.

Second one is tougher.."I've seen them given", but I reckon he was maybe JUST offside, although from the TV angle it's hard to tell. He may be just level. Also, I was certain on the day that Loach touched the ball anyway! Hence Lukas couldn't be offside. But I can't tell just now as this work PC I'm on is too slow to show it in freeze-frame!

On another matter-the Cov Telegraph says it was Bell who passes to Aron in the build up to Lukas' goal. I coulda sworn it was Sammy...

Nick · Apr 4, 2011

Yep, it was Clingan...

Coventry La La La · Apr 4, 2011

Just watched Duke's interview on skybluesplayer he said he spoke to Loach after then game and Loach's reaction was he got away with murder.
( The Juke goal were Loach dropped the ball )

Cobi Jones's Dreads · Apr 4, 2011

I have to say I've always hated that Scott Loach IMO he's one of the worst GK's in the division yet he seems to have massive plaudits and is capped at England youth level, maybe i'm missing something but has always looked really doggy against Cov.

sw88 · Apr 4, 2011

First one shud have stood after watching link on here (thanks Nick). Second one is more difficult although is say he was on. Neither watford defender or keeper appeal, but lino flags! even ref doubted the lino for the first one as had to ask him what he saw. Once again we were robbed by an official but Atleast this time it didn't affect the result and we got the points we deserved!

Paxman II · Apr 5, 2011

first one...Goal.
second one...Goal.

The second one was called offside not when Juke played the ball and put it in the net where he seemed to be level but when the shot fro Clingan was struck (off camera) but surely Juke would have been judged 'not interfering with play'? besides when the ball hits crossbar and rebounds into play he can't be called offside. So it must have been the instant the shot was struck out of camera but as i said 'not interfering with play' and so a goal.

i'll get my coat...

Pigeon · Apr 5, 2011

Shame for him, he's worked so hard in the last few games, would have really deserved the hat-trick.

TheRoyalScam · Apr 5, 2011

2nd goal: Jutkiewicz would have become 'active' as soon as he touched the ball.

Nonleagueherewecome · Apr 5, 2011

Yeah, it's that crazy "phase of play" crap that you need a qualification in Quantum Physics to understand...Quantum Physics being officially recognised as "more complicated" than Rocket Science these days

TheRoyalScam · Apr 5, 2011

Nonleagueherewecome said:
Yeah, it's that crazy "phase of play" crap that you need a qualification in Quantum Physics to understand...Quantum Physics being officially recognised as "more complicated" than Rocket Science these days

Rocket Science.....:thinking about:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=THNPmhBl-8I

musicmanskyblue · Apr 5, 2011

At least the first was definitely a goal.. and very unlucky with the second..

Shame really as although it was still a great result, we would have scored at least 3... how often in the last few seasons have we scored 3 in a game.

One for the stat experts.. cant be many teams who have so rarely scored 3-4 goals in games in the past few seasons..

Nonleagueherewecome · Apr 5, 2011

Must really get to Barnsley fans that we seem to do it with ease almost every time we play them, even when we are terrible. Heh heh. :claping hands::claping hands::claping hands:

Jukes Disallowed Goals (2 Viewers)

Well-Known Member

Administrator

New Member

Administrator

New Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Super Moderator

New Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Facebook User

Super Moderator

Well-Known Member

Administrator

New Member

Well-Known Member

Chief Commentator!

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency