Is there a (realistic) fans' choice for manager? (1 Viewer)

CJparker · Feb 19, 2013

Putting aside the long-shots like Adkins, do we feel that there is genuinely a fans' choice candidate who the majority are keen on? Last time I seem to remember that being Wise, before MR got the job. I don't get the same feeling now.

I'd like Coyle but doubt he will come here.

Megson would be a solid but unspectacular choice.

Wouldn't say no to Tisdale or Trollope, or Sean Dyche for that matter.

Steve Kean - not my personal choice but he has been mentioned by some. Wouldn't surprise me as he was employed by the only owners worse than SISU !!

I'd give a second chance to any out of Adams, Black, Coleman, Nilsson or Thorn.

Nightmare scenario is Alex McCliesh. Steve Cotterill would be on my "no no" list too, along with McClaren. The name Gareth Southgate also makes me shudder, as does Staunton. Jewell has also cocked up too many times for me.

Phil Brown would actually be ok in my opinion, I liked him when he was at Hull.

CovisGod · Feb 19, 2013

Agree with half of your post, I however would prefer to chew my own nuts off than have Thorn back as manager

skybluegod · Feb 19, 2013

I would have black that's the only one ATM but if coyle would come then him

WONDERLAMPS · Feb 19, 2013

Dyche is at burnley

covboy9 · Feb 19, 2013

CJparker said:
Putting aside the long-shots like Adkins, do we feel that there is genuinely a fans' choice candidate who the majority are keen on? Last time I seem to remember that being Wise, before MR got the job. I don't get the same feeling now.

I'd like Coyle but doubt he will come here.

Megson would be a solid but unspectacular choice.

Wouldn't say no to Tisdale or Trollope, or Sean Dyche for that matter.

Steve Kean - not my personal choice but he has been mentioned by some. Wouldn't surprise me as he was employed by the only owners worse than SISU !!

I'd give a second chance to any out of Adams, Black, Coleman, Nilsson or Thorn.

Nightmare scenario is Alex McCliesh. Steve Cotterill would be on my "no no" list too, along with McClaren. The name Gareth Southgate also makes me shudder, as does Staunton. Jewell has also cocked up too many times for me.

Phil Brown would actually be ok in my opinion, I liked him when he was at Hull.

Dyche is at Burnley!!!!

Coleman are you kidding??

Adams,Thorn and rolly just NO

Mcleish and Mclaren? read title of your post man!

i'd go for Nicky Barmby

Speng · Feb 19, 2013

CJparker said:
Putting aside the long-shots like Adkins, do we feel that there is genuinely a fans' choice candidate who the majority are keen on? Last time I seem to remember that being Wise, before MR got the job. I don't get the same feeling now.

I'd like Coyle but doubt he will come here.

Megson would be a solid but unspectacular choice.

Wouldn't say no to Tisdale or Trollope, or Sean Dyche for that matter.

Steve Kean - not my personal choice but he has been mentioned by some. Wouldn't surprise me as he was employed by the only owners worse than SISU !!

I'd give a second chance to any out of Adams, Black, Coleman, Nilsson or Thorn.

Nightmare scenario is Alex McCliesh. Steve Cotterill would be on my "no no" list too, along with McClaren. The name Gareth Southgate also makes me shudder, as does Staunton. Jewell has also cocked up too many times for me.

Phil Brown would actually be ok in my opinion, I liked him when he was at Hull.

Are you mad ????

Speng · Feb 19, 2013

Doh , I get it CJ Parker ... Your a wind up merchant

covboy9 · Feb 19, 2013

Steve Kean c u next tuesday

Grendel · Feb 19, 2013

Speng said:
Are you mad ????

No he is WUM and a troll - and he's getting worse.

sky blue john · Feb 19, 2013

untill the club has got the accounts unfrozen and sorted out a rent deal. I don't see any point of trying to get a new manager because only the desperados will be interested !!!

CovisGod · Feb 19, 2013

He makes some reasonable points for If its a wind up post, I'd happily have Coyle here

skybluegod · Feb 19, 2013

covboy9 said:
Dyche is at Burnley!!!!

Coleman are you kidding??

Adams,Thorn and rolly just NO

Mcleish and Mclaren? read title of your post man!

i'd go for Nicky Barmby

No chance on Nick Barmby he left hull because he wasn't getting proper backing and he went public saying that. He's someone who wants to buy lots of players which we can't do

Steve.B50 · Feb 19, 2013

Someone out f work who players decent football and lives locall.

Eric Black

SkyBlueBlood · Feb 19, 2013

This is a wind up isn't it?

Would not touch any of them except Black with a barge pole. In fact most of them would drive me away completely. Terrible list.

CJparker · Feb 19, 2013

I'm not winding anyone up - I do get fed up by people going "urgh no way" when pretty much any manager is mentioned

SkyblueBazza · Feb 19, 2013

CovisGod said:
Agree with half of your post, I however would prefer to chew my own nuts off than have Thorn back as manager

Vote Thorn, VOTE THORN )

CJparker · Feb 19, 2013

Call me a WUM if you like, the sad reality is that these are the best candidates out there who have a chance of joining us !!

SkyblueBazza · Feb 19, 2013

Isn't Appleton due a move soon?

SkyblueBazza · Feb 19, 2013

He'd be popular I'll bet :-/

wolfie · Feb 19, 2013

sky blue john said:
untill the club has got the accounts unfrozen and sorted out a rent deal. I don't see any point of trying to get a new manager because only the desperados will be interested !!!

totally agree with you, and who knows we may have the best management team right under our noses.

vRS19TD · Feb 19, 2013

Paul Buckle?? Just left Luton.

rupert_bear · Feb 19, 2013

Stick with Carsley and invite Eric Black to assistant manager/first team coach

JulianDarbyFTW · Feb 19, 2013

I know it wouldn't be a popular decision, but I'd go for Megson. He did a great job at West Brom, and Owen Coyle proved what a good job Megson did at Bolton. He's universally disliked, but I think that's more to do with his eminently punchable face rather than to do with his ability.

Sky Blue Pete · Feb 19, 2013

Definitely need an experienced hand. Curbishley would be my choice

covmark · Feb 19, 2013

CJparker said:
Putting aside the long-shots like Adkins, do we feel that there is genuinely a fans' choice candidate who the majority are keen on? Last time I seem to remember that being Wise, before MR got the job. I don't get the same feeling now.

I'd like Coyle but doubt he will come here.

Megson would be a solid but unspectacular choice.

Wouldn't say no to Tisdale or Trollope, or Sean Dyche for that matter.

Steve Kean - not my personal choice but he has been mentioned by some. Wouldn't surprise me as he was employed by the only owners worse than SISU !!

I'd give a second chance to any out of Adams, Black, Coleman, Nilsson or Thorn.

Nightmare scenario is Alex McCliesh. Steve Cotterill would be on my "no no" list too, along with McClaren. The name Gareth Southgate also makes me shudder, as does Staunton. Jewell has also cocked up too many times for me.

Phil Brown would actually be ok in my opinion, I liked him when he was at Hull.

Come on CJ your constant wummery is becoming boring

mark82 · Feb 20, 2013

JulianDarbyFTW said:
I know it wouldn't be a popular decision, but I'd go for Megson. He did a great job at West Brom, and Owen Coyle proved what a good job Megson did at Bolton. He's universally disliked, but I think that's more to do with his eminently punchable face rather than to do with his ability.

Megson struggled at Sheffield Wednesday. When he left there results picked up and they got promoted. No thanks.

vRS19TD · Feb 20, 2013

I can actually see SISU appointing Graham Westley just to p*ss us all off even further!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

coundonskyblue · Feb 20, 2013

<p>

JulianDarbyFTW said:
I know it wouldn't be a popular decision, but I'd go for Megson. He did a great job at West Brom, and Owen Coyle proved what a good job Megson did at Bolton. He's universally disliked, but I think that's more to do with his eminently punchable face rather than to do with his ability.

He wouldn't come here, to him were a tin pot club remember.

BrisbaneBronco · Feb 20, 2013

sky blue john said:
untill the club has got the accounts unfrozen and sorted out a rent deal. I don't see any point of trying to get a new manager because only the desperados will be interested !!!

Carsley till the summer is realistic.

Actually SISU could be really smart and do a great bit of PR

Appoint Di Canio who has left a club who renaged on financial promises.
We lost Robins due to rent issue.

Sends a message that there are no financial issues at CCFC.

But to do this the funds would have to come from somewhere else due to accounts being frozen.

torchomatic · Feb 20, 2013

I'd like Tisdale.

I wouldn't really like Black, Brown, McAllister, Megson, Dowie or any other one of our ex-managers. We should look forward, not back.

I'd even give Morrell a go.

CJparker · Feb 20, 2013

covmark said:
Come on CJ your constant wummery is becoming boring

Right, so you think all those candidates are awful and stupid? Reality is, they are the best we can get.

Is there a (realistic) fans' choice for manager? (1 Viewer)

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Super Moderator

New Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency