In sickness and in health (1 Viewer)

Noggin said:

If they had made it legal though they weren't getting what they wanted, there is of course a very simple solution to that, for sisu to sign an agreement giving them what they wanted at the same time as acl sign the original cva. This solution is so damn obvious that it shows either sisu weren't willing to accept the 150k offer or the 150k wasn't really an offer.

I feel like sisu are the problem because they could easily have said we are willing to drop the JR and sign a 10 year lease at 150k a year but we can't do it as part of a cva (assuming appleton is correct with that), the fact they didn't say that suggests they weren't willing too.

For me though it's irrelevant, sisu are almost completely to blame even if the 150k offer wasn't legit as we know the 400k one was, the 400k one is more than fair and infinitely superior for everyone involved, the fans, sisu and acl compared to what we have now.

The thing that is so ridiculous is that even if sisu really planned to build a stadium and only planned to play in the rioch for say 4 years of a 10 year lease signing it and having to pay 6 years at 400k while not using it is still massively superior to the option they have chosen. which to me can only mean they are still planning to win by distressing acl into giving in.

Click to expand...

Deleted member 5849 said:

I'll grant you your pedantry as I'd probably do the same

Doesn't alter my general point however, that their refusal to change their proposal (and their dogmatic refusal to talk directly with Fisher) suggests an attempt to make an offer that is not actually an offer.

In the PR stakes, an offer that can't be accepted is a rather good tactic...

Click to expand...

Deleted member 5849 said:

The fact the offer could never be accepted even if they wanted to, as it didn't comply with the law.

Click to expand...

Deleted member 5849 said:

Why not indeed? You'd think they would indeed have said they were more than happy to take that deal for five years while they build a stadium. It's the natural thing for them to do, and slightly curious they didn't.

Them not doing that and them being disingenuous, murky and dubious doesn't autmoatically make the other side right however. Unfortunately this is a world where both sides appear to be doing their best to be disengenuous and murky!

Click to expand...