Hypothetical question about success (1 Viewer)

What would you prefer?

  • Keeping the clubs tradition but struggling

    Votes: 11 68.8%
  • Rebranding of CCFC but success on the pitch

    Votes: 5 31.3%

  • Total voters
    16

SlowerThanPlatt

Well-Known Member
So with all the anger over Cardiff last year and Hull City (Tigers) this year what would the City fans prefer?

Would you be happier scrapping in League One and in the Championship but retaining our name and sky blue kit or could you sell your footballing soul and accept us turning into Coventry Reds and playing in a red shirt with the knowledge we'd be in the top six of the Premiership after 3 years and have won the FA Cup?
 

Last edited:

Kingokings204

Well-Known Member
Much rather league football and Coventry to be everything that makes me a fan. Coventry City. Not the Cardiff dragons or whatever they are and then they get relegated. The football gods will always win.
 

hill83

Well-Known Member
"The football gods will always win"
Cringe

Success over the colour of a shirt which is ultimately meaningless.
 

Chez78

New Member
Tricky.

The loyal fan in me says stay true to your roots and history, however having been starved of any kind of success for so long I'm not sure how I would react if say Red Bull took us over bought the Ricoh threw all their might behind us a re-branded us RB Coventry.

My gut instinct is I would be full of rage and hate right until they signed Ronaldo then I'd be back signing red bull army whilst jumping up and down pumped up on to much taurine
 

Sutty

Member
Keeping the tradition for me, no question.

Furthermore, selling the club's soul is by no means a guarantee of success on the pitch. I chatted to a couple of Cardiff fans a year or so ago and their view was 'he's putting a ton of money in so I'm right behind him'. Problem being, how far does that extend? Sure, you might be happy to deal with the colours changing, the badge changing, but what about the name? The location? Once you sell out to a man interested in his own personal image in the far east there's no telling how far he'll go. And for all that uncertainty, what do they get? A promotion and swift relegation.

I'd guarantee a fair few of our fans would have taken a colour change to get Sisu in back in 2007. Look how that's worked out. There are no guarantees in football.

The Cardiff-going-red thing pissed me off for a whole number of reasons, not least that it was the embodiment of a footballing society that doesn't care about it's roots. 20,000 people turn up to watch Cardiff on a matchday. Ultimately that's nothing in the world of English football though. The money is made by getting a club to the Premier League and marketing it worldwide. In a game that's driven by cash, the clubs that care about their roots and their local support get trampled on and left behind.

I read the other day that Liverpool estimate that they have around half a billion fans worldwide. The 40-odd thousand that show up at Anfield, buy a shirt, hold a scarf and sing You'll Never Walk Alone do not matter a jot. The vast majority of the income will be from the 499,960,000 other fans around the world. English football, the Premier League in particular, is now the world's game, with no meaningful links to its roots. Until something like Germany's 50+1 is introduced that will remain the case.

So yeah, tradition please!
 

ccfcway

Well-Known Member
stuff moves on. For me, the only thing that I 100% couldn't accept is not being in Coventry..............
 

letsallsingtogether

Well-Known Member
I voted keep tradition but only if we are at the Ricoh not Northampton and not in Tims tinpot ground.
 
L

limoncello

Guest
Biggest mammal I could kill with my bare hands would likely be a giraffe.
 

Neutral Fan

Member
So with all the anger over Cardiff last year and Hull City (Tigers) this year what would the City fans prefer?

Would you be happier scrapping in League One and in the Championship but retaining our name and sky blue kit or could you sell your footballing soul and accept us turning into Coventry Reds and playing in a red shirt with the knowledge we'd be in the top six of the Premiership after 3 years and have won the FA Cup?

It's the PREMIER LEAGUE. Hasn't been called the Premiership for years.
 

bigfatronssba

Well-Known Member
It's the tradition for me. I don't support ccfc for success.

If you change everything about the club how is it the same team you started supporting as a kid?
 

Ian1779

Well-Known Member
I remember when McGinnity tried to change the badge. The new one was fucking hideous. How he thought fans would be up for that shows how out of touch he was.
 

skybluetony176

Well-Known Member
I remember when McGinnity tried to change the badge. The new one was fucking hideous. How he thought fans would be up for that shows how out of touch he was.

Imagine how out of touch he would have been if he tried to move the club away from Coventry to Northampton or even the "Coventry area", whatever that means.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top