Non AMP
Sky Blues Talk
  • Home
  • Forums
  • General Discussion
  • Off Topic Chat
This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

Do you want to discuss boring politics? (28 Viewers)

  • Thread starter mrtrench
  • Start date Jun 14, 2020
Forums New posts
Prev
  • 1
  • …
  • 1093
  • 1094
  • 1095
  • 1096
  • 1097
  • …
  • 1493
Next
First Prev 1095 of 1493 Next Last

Ian1779

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,291
PVA said:
To the question 'would Corbyn beat these Tories?', he's forecast to lose his seat!


Click to expand...
I’ll take a bet with you now it won’t happen.
 
D

Deleted member 5849

Guest
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,292
Ian1779 said:
I’ll take a bet with you now it won’t happen.
Click to expand...
The more a narrative of a landslide is pushed, the less likely it is to happen.
 
Reactions: Earlsdon_Skyblue1 and Sky Blue Pete

Ian1779

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,293
Deleted member 5849 said:
The more a narrative of a landslide is pushed, the less likely it is to happen.
Click to expand...
I always find these polls interesting - the Labour victory is not in question, I also think SNP will not drop that low.
 
P

PVA

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,294
Ian1779 said:
I’ll take a bet with you now it won’t happen.
Click to expand...

No I think he will win fairly comfortably really.
 
Reactions: Ian1779
D

Deleted member 5849

Guest
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,295
Ian1779 said:
I always find these polls interesting - the Labour victory is not in question, I also think SNP will not drop that low.
Click to expand...
I dunno, SNP have lost a charismatic leader and are mired in chaos themselves. You'd think all three national parties would be eyeing Scotland up as an opportunity.
 
Reactions: Sky_Blue_Dreamer and Earlsdon_Skyblue1

MalcSB

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,296
duffer said:
You sign at 16, you're in until you're 22, and "frontline" at first or not, you're committing to risk your life for your country at a point in the near future. Seems like we're happy to trust them to do that.

As for the 13 year old thing, no one is asking for them to get the vote, the amount of them earning enough to pay tax is miniscule, and of course under-16s are still in full time education.

What's your rationale for not giving them the vote? Are you scared they might vote the wrong way, or is it that some of them might have spots? Talk about rubbish...
Click to expand...
You said if you are old enough to die for your country, you are old enough to vote. Under 18s need parental permission to sign up to the armed forces. If they can’t be trusted to make that decision, why entrust them with a vote. They can’t be sent to the front line below 18, so your argument is wrong. We don’t trust them at 16 in relation to the armed forces. Wrong again.

Under 18s have to remain in training e.g, apprenticeships. Most if not all at the apprentice Rate will barely exceed the tax threshold maybe paying £1 a month. Only about 25% of 16 year olds are in such schemes. Your qualifification seems to be payment of income tax. Presumably the 75% still in full time education shouldn't get the vote then. What about the unemployed by your logic.

The rational part of a teenagers brain isn't fully developed - yet another reason why 16 year olds should not be entitled to vote.

Duffer by name, Duffer by nature.
 

fernandopartridge

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,297
MalcSB said:
You said if you are old enough to die for your country, you are old enough to vote. Under 18s need parental permission to sign up to the armed forces. If they can’t be trusted to make that decision, why entrust them with a vote. They can’t be sent to the front line below 18, so your argument is wrong. We don’t trust them at 16 in relation to the armed forces. Wrong again.

Under 18s have to remain in training e.g, apprenticeships. Most if not all at the apprentice Rate will barely exceed the tax threshold maybe paying £1 a month. Only about 25% of 16 year olds are in such schemes. Your qualifification seems to be payment of income tax. Presumably the 75% still in full time education shouldn't get the vote then. What about the unemployed by your logic.

The rational part of a teenagers brain isn't fully developed - yet another reason why 16 year olds should not be entitled to vote.

Duffer by name, Duffer by nature.
Click to expand...
I'm sure somebody posted up a video of an elderly woman in Mansfield or somewhere demonstrating that rational thought had long since departed.
 

MalcSB

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,298
fernandopartridge said:
I'm sure somebody posted up a video of an elderly woman in Mansfield or somewhere demonstrating that rational thought had long since departed.
Click to expand...
Probably wouldn’t be capable of voting in that case.
 

Sick Boy

Super Moderator
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,299

Tory donor John Caudwell tells the BBC he is voting Labour

Phones4U founder John Caudwell gave the Conservatives £500K before the last general election.
www.bbc.com

"We can't tax rich people in order to help the poor because they'll go off to Monaco and other places, we have to create real genuine wealth.”

"the loony Left"

You just love to see it.
 
Reactions: Brighton Sky Blue and wingy

fernandopartridge

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,300
Sick Boy said:

Tory donor John Caudwell tells the BBC he is voting Labour

Phones4U founder John Caudwell gave the Conservatives £500K before the last general election.
www.bbc.com

"We can't tax rich people in order to help the poor because they'll go off to Monaco and other places, we have to create real genuine wealth.”

"the loony Left"

You just love to see it.
Click to expand...
To be fair Starmer has been pretty clear that tough decisions will continue to be made in relation to the poor so that people like Mr Caldwell can continue to amass wealth
 
Reactions: duffer and Sick Boy

Earlsdon_Skyblue1

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,301
torchomatic said:
US lenders caused the 2008 global crash.
Click to expand...

I reckon about 90% of this thread haven't been outside since 2008.

Honestly, absolutely staggering to read some of this shit. Not reflective of the real whatsoever.
 

torchomatic

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,302
Earlsdon_Skyblue1 said:
I reckon about 90% of this thread haven't been outside since 2008.

Honestly, absolutely staggering to read some of this shit. Not reflective of the real whatsoever.
Click to expand...
Yes, staggering.

The 2007–2008 financial crisis, or the global financial crisis (GFC), was the most severe worldwide economic crisis since the Great Depression. Predatory lending in the form of subprime mortgages targeting low-income homebuyers,[1] excessive risk-taking by global financial institutions,[2] a continuous buildup of toxic assets within banks, and the bursting of the United States housing bubble culminated in a "perfect storm", which led to the Great Recession.
 
Reactions: Earlsdon_Skyblue1

chiefdave

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,303
MalcSB said:
The rational part of a teenagers brain isn't fully developed - yet another reason why 16 year olds should not be entitled to vote.
Click to expand...
My Dad has no clue where he is or what's going on. On the occasions he does recognise me he thinks I'm his brother, he's never had a bother. He's had his polling card and will be sent his postal vote form.

If you go down the route of assessing people's mental capacity to make the 'right' decision in a considered way you're opening a whole can of worms.
 
Reactions: Sky Blue Pete

MalcSB

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,304
chiefdave said:
My Dad has no clue where he is or what's going on. On the occasions he does recognise me he thinks I'm his brother, he's never had a bother. He's had his polling card and will be sent his postal vote form.

If you go down the route of assessing people's mental capacity to make the 'right' decision in a considered way you're opening a whole can of worms.
Click to expand...
Will he vote, or will you do it for him?

No 16 year olds have fully developed the rational part of the brain. A minority of adults have lost that ability so not really a valid comparison,

Votes for 16 year olds is absolutely fucking ridiculous and to introduce it would be gerrymandering. There is no logical reason a school kid should be able to vote - other than gerrymandering. You and your comrades know it and are wriggling like the canned worms you mention to justify it using inaccurate statements.
 
Last edited: Jun 18, 2024
Reactions: Sky Blue Pete

David O'Day

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,305
Philosoraptor said:
If I can just come in here and just clear a few things up.

The cause of the global crash is not the concern here. Well, unless you had money in there, or had to bail out those who did.

Some would say more importantly, It's all about who had control of the UK economy and who did fuck all about it!

To give an analogy, it is like closing the barn door after the horse has bolted.
Click to expand...
the main cause of the financial crisis was the us repeal of the glass-steagal laws that allowed us banks to mix sub prime directives and sell them to banks around the world

someone needs to take your laptop off you
 
Reactions: torchomatic

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,306
Ian1779 said:
I always find these polls interesting - the Labour victory is not in question, I also think SNP will not drop that low.
Click to expand...
It’s plausible, the SNPs record in government (since 2007) is terrible! With no prospect of a 2nd referendum any time soon and a chance to kick the tories out, Labour will regain a lot of the central belt in Scotland.
 

David O'Day

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,307
Mucca Mad Boys said:
It’s plausible, the SNPs record in government (since 2007) is terrible! With no prospect of a 2nd referendum any time soon and a chance to kick the tories out, Labour will regain a lot of the central belt in Scotland.
Click to expand...
The SNP have a lot of the same issues the Tories have in Westminster
 
Reactions: Mucca Mad Boys

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,308
David O'Day said:
The SNP have a lot of the same issues the Tories have in Westminster
Click to expand...

Likewise with Welsh Labour too. Which is my logic when I say anyone expecting big changes from an incoming Labour government will be disappointed by the next election.

Totally agree that the Tories absolutely deserve to kicked out of government, the alternative just isn’t going to be much better in my view.
 

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,309
duffer said:
Ah, so you're not big on democracy then. I'd say if you're old enough to die for your country, or work and pay tax to it, you're old enough to vote.

As for FPTP, I'd like to live in a country where every vote counts.

Just because your opinion is rigid, doesn't mean it's correct, of course. Similarly, being over-18, or even much, much, older, does not necessarily make one wise.
Click to expand...

My preference for FPTP is more technical.

Bearing in mind the rarity that a party will reach 51% of the popular vote, coalition governments become the norm. Which, imo, isn’t what the electorate votes for (in most cases). Let’s use this election to make a hypothetical example:

Labour is currently polling at 45-46% so would need either the Lib Dems or Greens to form a coalition. Why should a junior party have the power to force through policies the electorate didn’t give a mandate for?

Continuing with the this election as an example, I believe the party with the most votes should form the government. Labour polling on 45%, hypothetically could be thwarted by a coalition of the other parties. This happened in Spain this year where a centre-right party ‘won’ the election but the centre-left party formed the government. In the Netherlands, Geert Wilders ‘won’ the election but will not be the next PM.

PR systems tend to be more fragmented to parties rarely poll above 40% so tend to need ‘rainbow coalitions’ (multiple parties) and governments can be brought down by these junior parties.

Take Brexit for example, at 52:48, if we had a PR electoral system, we wouldn’t have had a decisive conclusion to that issue. FPTP delivered a government with a large majority to push through their agenda, likewise with this upcoming election where Labour. The term ‘elective dictatorship’ is apt and actually, a perk of our system.

As for 16-17 year old votes, there’s a reason most countries only enfranchise them for local/municipal elections rather than national elections.
 

chiefdave

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,310
MalcSB said:
Will he vote, or will you do it for him?
Click to expand...
I won't do it for him because I don't think he should be voting when he has no fucking clue what day of the week it is. There's a pretty decent chance one of the carers or my mum will 'help' him fill it in and post it back.
 

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,311
chiefdave said:
I won't do it for him because I don't think he should be voting when he has no fucking clue what day of the week it is. There's a pretty decent chance one of the carers or my mum will 'help' him fill it in and post it back.
Click to expand...

I also disagree with postal voting, 20% of votes being cast in this way doesn’t quite sit right with me. There’s also a reason it’s not allowed in Northern Ireland too.
 

chiefdave

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 18, 2024
  • #38,312
Mucca Mad Boys said:
I also disagree with postal voting, 20% of votes being cast in this way doesn’t quite sit right with me. There’s also a reason it’s not allowed in Northern Ireland too.
Click to expand...
I postal vote. Only way I can be certain I'll get to use my vote as I can be sent away for work at very short notice and wouldn't be able to make it back.
 

skybluetony176

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 19, 2024
  • #38,313
Mucca Mad Boys said:
I also disagree with postal voting, 20% of votes being cast in this way doesn’t quite sit right with me. There’s also a reason it’s not allowed in Northern Ireland too.
Click to expand...
Where are you getting postal voting is not allowed in Northern Ireland from?
 

duffer

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 19, 2024
  • #38,314
MalcSB said:
You said if you are old enough to die for your country, you are old enough to vote. Under 18s need parental permission to sign up to the armed forces. If they can’t be trusted to make that decision, why entrust them with a vote. They can’t be sent to the front line below 18, so your argument is wrong. We don’t trust them at 16 in relation to the armed forces. Wrong again.

Under 18s have to remain in training e.g, apprenticeships. Most if not all at the apprentice Rate will barely exceed the tax threshold maybe paying £1 a month. Only about 25% of 16 year olds are in such schemes. Your qualifification seems to be payment of income tax. Presumably the 75% still in full time education shouldn't get the vote then. What about the unemployed by your logic.

The rational part of a teenagers brain isn't fully developed - yet another reason why 16 year olds should not be entitled to vote.

Duffer by name, Duffer by nature.
Click to expand...

Grow up mate, seriously, that's a really weak insult - do you think I've not heard it before? You're not very good at the cheap shots, so I'd give it a rest, it's just a bit... awkward. And at least I tried for a bit of fun and self-deprecation with my username, yours seems to reflect a certain lack of imagination... probably down to that rigidity of thought that you admit that you suffer from.

Regardless, when you sign up for the Army at sixteen, are you committing yourself to a role in the armed forces that may involve frontline service? (I'll help here, the answer is yes.) You seem to have forgotten that part of your argument, conveniently.

So let's move on to rationality. Actually, current science suggests that the brain doesn't fully mature until about age 25, so by your argument, we shouldn't allow people to vote until they're at least that old. No?

In fact, the whole 'too irrational to vote", holds no water at all unless you're proposing some kind of independent "rationality' test all citizens would have to pass in order to vote. Are you arguing for that?

I'm simply saying that 16-18 year olds should get the vote. I'm not dancing on the head of a pin about how much tax they pay, or even if they're in full time education or out of work. I'm just pointing out that they're clearly mature enough to work, and are expected to do so, and/or to continue to learn, and to contribute to society via taxation or otherwise. Not quite the same as school kids.

On that basis, there's no 'rational' reason to deny 16-18 year olds the vote, other than your obvious fear that they might vote for a party you don't like. Which is what you're really saying here, isn't it? Come on now, fess up old chap, you can't bluff a duffer.
 
Last edited: Jun 19, 2024
Reactions: torchomatic

duffer

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 19, 2024
  • #38,315
Mucca Mad Boys said:
I also disagree with postal voting, 20% of votes being cast in this way doesn’t quite sit right with me. There’s also a reason it’s not allowed in Northern Ireland too.
Click to expand...

It doesn't quite 'sit right' with you? Is that entirely rational, it's just it sounds a lot like an emotional hot-take based on an incomplete understanding.

Are you 16-18 by any chance?

How do I get a postal vote in Northern Ireland?

The Electoral Office of Northern Ireland (EONI) must receive applications for absent voting by 17:00 BST on Friday.
www.bbc.co.uk
 
Reactions: Brighton Sky Blue, torchomatic and Sick Boy

MalcSB

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 19, 2024
  • #38,316
duffer said:
Grow up mate, seriously, that's a really weak insult - do you think I've not heard it before? You're not very good at the cheap shots, so I'd give it a rest, it's just a bit... awkward. And at least I tried for a bit of fun and self-deprecation with my username, yours seems to reflect a certain lack of imagination... probably down to that rigidity of thought that you admit that you suffer from.

Regardless, when you sign up for the Army at sixteen, are you committing yourself to a role in the armed forces that may involve frontline service? (I'll help here, the answer is yes.) You seem to have forgotten that part of your argument, conveniently.

So let's move on to rationality. Actually, current science suggests that the brain doesn't fully mature until about age 25, so by your argument, we shouldn't allow people to vote until they're at least that old. No?

In fact, the whole 'too irrational to vote", holds no water at all unless you're proposing some kind of independent "rationality' test all citizens would have to pass in order to vote. Are you arguing for that?

I'm simply saying that 16-18 year olds should get the vote. I'm not dancing on the head of a pin about how much tax they pay, or even if they're in full time education or out of work. I'm just pointing out that they're clearly mature enough to work, and are expected to do so, and/or to continue to learn, and to contribute to society via taxation or otherwise. Not quite the same as school kids.

On that basis, there's no 'rational' reason to deny 16-18 year olds the vote, other than your obvious fear that they might vote for a party you don't like. Which is what you're really saying here, isn't it? Come on now, fess up old chap, you can't bluff a duffer.
Click to expand...


On your revised argument, should 16 year olds be able to marry without parental permission, drive a car or a lorry, be regarded as an adult if arrested for a crime. Should child benefit and child maintenance stop at 16 as they are not children?

If it“s a question of maturity, then go the whole hog. It isn’t, it’s gerrymandering. If the majority of 16 year olds belonged to a right wing organisation - let’s say a Farage Youth - Labour would not be including this in their manifesto.
 
Reactions: Earlsdon_Skyblue1

clint van damme

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 19, 2024
  • #38,317
MalcSB said:
On your revised argument, should 16 year olds be able to marry without parental permission, drive a car or a lorry, be regarded as an adult if arrested for a crime. Should child benefit and child maintenance stop at 16 as they are not children?

If it“s a question of maturity, then go the whole hog. It isn’t, it’s gerrymandering. If the majority of 16 year olds belonged to a right wing organisation - let’s say a Farage Youth - Labour would not be including this in their manifesto.
Click to expand...

Yet you were OK with the tories gerrymandering by bringing in voter ID.
 
Reactions: Sky_Blue_Dreamer, Sick Boy, Brighton Sky Blue and 1 other person

torchomatic

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 19, 2024
  • #38,318
clint van damme said:
Yet you were OK with the tories gerrymandering by bringing in voter ID.
Click to expand...
Exactly! Just what I've been banging on about.
 

MalcSB

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 19, 2024
  • #38,319
clint van damme said:
Yet you were OK with the tories gerrymandering by bringing in voter ID.
Click to expand...
Where have I said that?
 

torchomatic

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 19, 2024
  • #38,320
MalcSB said:
On your revised argument, should 16 year olds be able to marry without parental permission, drive a car or a lorry, be regarded as an adult if arrested for a crime. Should child benefit and child maintenance stop at 16 as they are not children?

If it“s a question of maturity, then go the whole hog. It isn’t, it’s gerrymandering. If the majority of 16 year olds belonged to a right wing organisation - let’s say a Farage Youth - Labour would not be including this in their manifesto.
Click to expand...

MalcSB said:
Where have I said that?
Click to expand...
I guess that's the point.
 

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 19, 2024
  • #38,321
duffer said:
It doesn't quite 'sit right' with you? Is that entirely rational, it's just it sounds a lot like an emotional hot-take based on an incomplete understanding.

Are you 16-18 by any chance?

How do I get a postal vote in Northern Ireland?

The Electoral Office of Northern Ireland (EONI) must receive applications for absent voting by 17:00 BST on Friday.
www.bbc.co.uk
Click to expand...

I wish I was 16-18 again!

Sorry, I missed out the small detail of ‘on demand’ absentee voting i.e. in Northern Ireland it’s restricted and a reason given for a proxy/postal vote.

No, there’s been some reports that indicate the system could be prone to tampering and what not. It was introduced in 2001 so a very new concept.
 

MalcSB

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 19, 2024
  • #38,322
torchomatic said:
I guess that's the point.
Click to expand...
Wasn’t it the independent electoral commission who was asking for voter ID for years?

Do you believe everything that Rees-Mogg says? Especially without considering the context in which he said it?
 
Reactions: torchomatic and Brighton Sky Blue
B

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 19, 2024
  • #38,323
duffer said:
It doesn't quite 'sit right' with you? Is that entirely rational, it's just it sounds a lot like an emotional hot-take based on an incomplete understanding.

Are you 16-18 by any chance?

How do I get a postal vote in Northern Ireland?

The Electoral Office of Northern Ireland (EONI) must receive applications for absent voting by 17:00 BST on Friday.
www.bbc.co.uk
Click to expand...
Think his dog ate that page out of the A-level Politics revision guide
 
Reactions: wingy and Deleted member 5849

clint van damme

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 19, 2024
  • #38,324
MalcSB said:
Where have I said that?
Click to expand...

Earlier in the thread. You said you were OK with voter ID.
Yet its a clear attempt at gerrymandering by the tories, (I posted a link to Rees Mogg admitting it)
 
Reactions: torchomatic

clint van damme

Well-Known Member
  • Jun 19, 2024
  • #38,325
MalcSB said:
Wasn’t it the independent electoral commission who was asking for voter ID for years?

Do you believe everything that Rees-Mogg says? Especially without considering the context in which he said it?
Click to expand...

For someone who mentions logical thinking and honesty so often in his posts you're not displaying much of either regarding this issue.
 
Prev
  • 1
  • …
  • 1093
  • 1094
  • 1095
  • 1096
  • 1097
  • …
  • 1493
Next
First Prev 1095 of 1493 Next Last
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

  • Ian17792 minutes ago
  • SBT4 minutes ago
  • chiefdave12 minutes ago
  • CCFCSteve13 minutes ago
  • ... and 3 more.
  • Total: 25 (members: 7, guests: 18)
    Share:
    Facebook Twitter Reddit Pinterest Tumblr WhatsApp Email
    • Home
    • Forums
    • General Discussion
    • Off Topic Chat
    • Default Style
    • Contact us
    • Terms and rules
    • Privacy policy
    • Help
    • Home
    Community platform by XenForo® © 2010-2021 XenForo Ltd.
    Menu
    Log in

    Register

    • Home
    • Forums
      • New posts
      • Search forums
    • What's new
      • New posts
      • Latest activity
    • Members
      • Current visitors
    • Donate to the Season Ticket Fund
    X

    Privacy & Transparency

    We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:

    • Personalized ads and content
    • Content measurement and audience insights

    Do you accept cookies and these technologies?

    X

    Privacy & Transparency

    We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:

    • Personalized ads and content
    • Content measurement and audience insights

    Do you accept cookies and these technologies?