the rumpo kid
Well-Known Member
Collins persistence to try and punch or parry the ball away is costing us and doesn't work, for his few mistakes early on in the season Wilson's handling was much better.
On the positive side, he manages to keep the ball in play with his distribution, unlike Wilson.
RidiculousTime to bring Wilson back in I think, Collins has been largely good but cant help but worry about his positioning, I think Wilson is the better shotstopper which first and foremost is the important part of being a goalkeeper not being able to pass a ball accurately 60 yards
No, thanks. Collins hasn’t jumped out the way of a shot yet.Time to bring Wilson back in I think, Collins has been largely good but cant help but worry about his positioning, I think Wilson is the better shotstopper which first and foremost is the important part of being a goalkeeper not being able to pass a ball accurately 60 yards
lol Robbings the goalkeeper coach making Collins drop the ballI'm wondering if Robbins is trying to coach something new in to Collins at the moment as I think he's getting worse. It's like he has something on his mind like looking for who he's going to pass to before he catches the ball etc which then makes him drop it as his eye is off the ball. Just trying to think why he's got dramatically worse!
Lol I have no idea as I say it makes no sense but the only thing I can think of is in trying to speed up distribution they have given him too much to think about otherwise wtf happenedlol Robbings the goalkeeper coach making Collins drop the ball
Speed up he does it even slower nowLol I have no idea as I say it makes no sense but the only thing I can think of is in trying to speed up distribution they have given him too much to think about otherwise wtf happenedhe looked so solid!
That's cause it takes him 2 times to catch itSpeed up he does it even slower now
Apart from this season when it cost us goals ?Not convinced at all about Collins. Wilson is the better shot stopper. And I don't remember Wilson ever parrying shots consistently like Collins does.
Wilson has a bit of a cult following. It's a bit like replacing Biamou in that regard where he's obviously better but people will choose not to see it.I swear all this chat is because one poster mentioned Collins parrying the ball a lot - which ALL keepers do nowadays, for better or worse - and now a bunch of people are building some weird 'Collins isn't good enough' book club. Kinda terrifying.
I do think he's the better keeper but I also think he's lost some composure recently!Collins is far superior to Wilson.
That said he's not top quality but Robins seems to like to prioritise the money on the outfield players.
Collins looks to me to be far calmer, there was one moment vs Swansea where he had to come out of the box to make an interception, I think he headed it or chested it to a CB.
He's done that a few times recently, whereas Wilson tended to get stuck in no man's land or just clatter into a player in similar scenarios.
Collins is definitely the better GK for me.
The Championship keeper that has always impressed me is Johansson at Rotherham, probably because he has a lot to do!
A lot of the chat is because he had a Stormer against us about three years ago, but the rest of that season he was pretty mediocre. Umm assuming he's improved since then?Always statistically near the top of the keeper charts. Rotherham look doomed this season and would be a big fan of him coming in.
Think last season he ranked best compared to the xG against himA lot of the chat is because he had a Stormer against us about three years ago, but the rest of that season he was pretty mediocre. Umm assuming he's improved since then?
, for his few mistakes early on in the season Wilson's handling was much better.
I did say apart from a few mistakes. Wilson is a better handler.West Brom home and Preston away would suggest otherwise.
He's far better than Wilson all round, it's not blind panic every time a cross comes into the boxI think Collins has a lot of improvement to make. His handling is less than convincing. Shots straight at him are not sticking. He is comfortable passing it around at the back and making angles to do so but some of his kicking is poor. Quite a few times he's hit a flat kick straight at an opponent. Still early days though so hopefully he can improve as Wilson did.
100% easily the best keeper in the division.The Championship keeper that has always impressed me is Johansson at Rotherham, probably because he has a lot to do!
Collins is a better keeper full stopNo, thanks. Collins hasn’t jumped out the way of a shot yet.
Wilson has a bit of a cult following. It's a bit like replacing Biamou in that regard where he's obviously better but people will choose not to see it.
Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?