Cardiff player ratings (1 Viewer)

Nick · Jan 1, 2025

Not good though in the slightest the way the game went

Sheaf and BTA terrible.
Dovin a couple of good saves.
Saka woke up for a bit.
Simms a good spell

Overall. We needed to go in for the kill sooner, when we had 2 strikers we should have been putting the ball in the box.

Ccfcisparks · Jan 1, 2025

Can’t be arsed to do them.

Saka and Dovin only ones above a 6

Londonccfcfan · Jan 1, 2025

Saka, Dovin and Simms only ones to come out of that with credit.

Londonccfcfan · Jan 1, 2025

Really missing EMC and Haji Wright.

Milans getting worse.

Jamesimus · Jan 1, 2025

Dovin 7
MVE 4
Bobbert 4
Lati 5
Bidwell 5
Sheaf 2
Eccles 3
Torp 4
Sakamoto 6
Rudoni 4
Simms 5

BTA 4
Bassette 4
Rapha 10 (MOM)

Maybe harsh on a few, but we were not brave enough to win that.

skybluecam · Jan 1, 2025

Dovin 7
MVE 4
Thomas 5
Lati 5
Bidwell 4
Sheaf 2
Torp 5
Eccles 3
Rudoni 5
Simms 6
Saka 6

rondog1973 · Jan 1, 2025

Dovin best of a bad bunch
Bidwell average
Lati, Thomas and Milan poor
Eccles and Saka improved 2nd half after dreadful 1st
Torp and Rudoni meh
Simms okay although really should have put that header away
Sheaf dismal
Subs inadequate

Nick · Jan 1, 2025

Mve was an embarrassment too. Take any money

steve101 · Jan 1, 2025

Dovin 6
Van Erwijk 4
Thomas 5
Latibeudiere 5
Bidwell 6
Eccles 5
Sheaf 5
Torp 4
Sakamoto 6
Simms 6
Rudoni 6

Thomas-Asante 4
Bassette 5
Raphael n/a

Blind-Faith · Jan 1, 2025

Dovin 7
MVE 4
Thomas 5
Lati 5
Bidwell 6
Sheaf 5
Torp 6
Eccles 5
Rudoni 5
Simms 5
Saka 7

stupot07 · Jan 1, 2025

Dovin 6
MVE 3
Thomas 3
Lati 4
Bidwell 6 MOTM
Sheaf 3
Eccles 3
Torp 3
Sakamoto 5
Rudoni 3
Simms 5

Subs
BTA 3
Bassette 4
Rapha N/a

Ref 8 - gave us a chance with a soft sending off, but got pissed off we didn't take it so blew early.

Brighton Sky Blue · Jan 1, 2025

Dovin saved us a point late on because his teammates up front were useless. No idea why we went 4-2-4, it looked like madness.

Dovin 7
MVE 5
Thomas 2
Lati 5
Bidwell 6
Eccles 6
Sheaf 3
Rudoni 5
Saka 7
Simms 6

Subs
BTA 4
Rapha N/A
Bassette 6

rondog1973 · Jan 1, 2025

Just how bad is this league BTW? 3 points today would have seen us top half!

Alkhen · Jan 1, 2025

Dovin 8, goal wasn't his fault and saved our skin late on

Bidwell 6, not his best but a massive upgrade on DaSilva

Lati 5, sloppy at times

Thomas 4, poor today, too slow on the ball, think someone needs to tell him he's not Baresi, needs to progress the ball quicker

MVE 5, lot of running but nothing really achieved, must be knackered though has zero backup ior competition in our 'elite deck'

Eccles 4, as poor as I've seen him first half

Sheaf 4, so sloppy and risky near our box. Needs dropping but for who?

Torp 4, again didn't offer much

Rudoni 6, played out of position, did ok but prefer him in the middle

Tats 7, extra couple of points for the second half, again looks like he could do with a rest or someone on his heels as competition

Simms 7, would have given him more but he did fade a bit. For 60 mins he held everything up, worked his target role well. Won nearly every ball played to him and tried to play other in. Looked a thankless task. Good power and running for goal. If others had been at his level I think we would have been really praising that effort. Needs a good run now

Subs:

Norm 5 didn't offer much

BTA 4 bad miss. Struggling to see where he gets the minutes needed to sharpen up. Odd signing

Rapha 11 got on the pitch, hallelujah

SeaSeeEffCee · Jan 1, 2025

10s all round and an 11 for Super Frank!

lord_garrincha · Jan 1, 2025

I expect 2 midfielders to come in January.

As it stands, them 3 are a joke.

Cally Fedora · Jan 1, 2025

Dovin mom 7.

6’s most of the rest.

Torp 4.

Otis · Jan 1, 2025

Dovin, Simms and Bidwell were decent overall. The rest, a bit of a mess unfortunately.

We can't keep just turning up for one half. It's getting ridiculous now.

clint van damme · Jan 1, 2025

lord_garrincha said:
I expect 2 midfielders to come in January.

As it stands, them 3 are a joke.

We don't need another midfielder!

covboy9 · Jan 1, 2025

Is it me or does the standard in championship this season seem absolutely rubbish meaning us and opponents

covcity4life · Jan 1, 2025

Nick said:
Not good though in the slightest the way the game went

Sheaf and BTA terrible.
Dovin a couple of good saves.
Saka woke up for a bit.
Simms a good spell

Overall. We needed to go in for the kill sooner, when we had 2 strikers we should have been putting the ball in the box.

The crosses were poor today bar 1 or 2

speedie87 · Jan 1, 2025

Dovin 7 great save on the 1 on 1
mve 5
thomas 4 shocking defending for their goal, just needed to jockey him into the corner but dived in and let him pass , and lots of dodgy passes 1st half
lati 5
bidwell 6
sheaf 4
eccles 5 shocking pass for their goal
torp 5 lightweight and fairly useless as normal
saka 6 awol first half , better 2nd
Simms 6 some shocking touches first ten mins but then improved
Rudoni 6 ok first half

tokyojim · Jan 1, 2025

Ponderous garbage. The midfield movement is shocking. None of the midfielders are making themselves available so you end up with endless passing across the back which it would appear we don't have the basic skills for. We're a tough watch.

Dovin 7
MVE 1. And that's generous. What has happened to him?
Thomas 3. Passing was shocking.
Lati 5
Bidwell 6
Sheaf 2
Eccles 4
Torp 5
Sakamoto 6
Rudoni 5
Simms 7

Alkhen · Jan 1, 2025

clint van damme said:
We don't need another midfielder!

We might have numbers but it's totally out of balance. We lack creativity, a spark player like O'Hare or to a lesser extent Palmer. Also we have no cover for Sheaf so can drop him or rest him..

clint van damme · Jan 1, 2025

Alkhen said:
We might have numbers but it's totally out of balance. We lack creativity, a spark player like O'Hare or to a lesser extent Palmer. Also we have no cover for Sheaf so can drop him or rest him..

It was a quote from King, should have put it in quotation marks!
But youre probably right, we have numbers, just not the balance.

play_in_skyblue_stripes · Jan 1, 2025

Bobby Thomas had a nightmare today. Passing was woeful as well as defending.

Observation, players are seeming reluctance to pass to BTA.

First half was really bad. Fantastic opportunity to win as dominated 2nd half and new ref gave us everything. Dovin pulled off a great save to avoid an embarrassing loss.

Cardiff keeper was fantastic. A fair result overall even though we were all over Cardiff in second half.

Anyone who thinks this is a top 6 side is going to be massively disappointed.

Brighton Sky Blue · Jan 1, 2025

play_in_skyblue_stripes said:
Bobby Thomas had a nightmare today. Passing was woeful as well as defending.

Observation, players are seeming reluctance to pass to BTA.

First half was really bad. Fantastic opportunity to win as dominated 2nd half and new ref gave us everything. Dovin pulled off a great save to avoid an embarrassing loss.

Cardiff keeper was fantastic. A fair result overall even though we were all over Cardiff in second half.

Anyone who thinks this is a top 6 side is going to be massively disappointed.

This side got a club legend sacked and will tank Lampard’s career if he lets them.

shmmeee · Jan 1, 2025

Jamesimus said:
Dovin 7
MVE 4
Bobbert 4
Lati 5
Bidwell 5
Sheaf 2
Eccles 3
Torp 4
Sakamoto 6
Rudoni 4
Simms 5

BTA 4
Bassette 4
Rapha 10 (MOM)

Maybe harsh on a few, but we were not brave enough to win that.

Would give Rudi a 5 but otherwise agree with this. ESP Rapha

bigron · Jan 1, 2025

Doug king, you have wrecked this club. Sacked our legendary manager, bought a load of over-priced wet lettuce's and killed the positivity and feel-good factor. Bring back Sisu

shmmeee · Jan 1, 2025

bigron said:
Doug king, you have wrecked this club. Sacked our legendary manager, bought a load of over-priced wet lettuce's and killed the positivity and feel-good factor. Bring back Sisu

3/10 low effort

Jamesimus · Jan 1, 2025

shmmeee said:
Would give Rudi a 5 but otherwise agree with this. ESP Rapha

Yeah fair, I guess he was out of position too.

shmmeee · Jan 1, 2025

Jamesimus said:
Yeah fair, I guess he was out of position too.

He was OK. Not terrible. The awful corners drag him from a 6 IMO.

TomRad85 · Jan 1, 2025

I always found Eccles and Sheaf together uninspiring even though I thought they were both decent players. Even the latter isn't true atm.

Grendel · Jan 1, 2025

tokyojim said:
Ponderous garbage. The midfield movement is shocking. None of the midfielders are making themselves available so you end up with endless passing across the back which it would appear we don't have the basic skills for. We're a tough watch.

Dovin 7
MVE 1. And that's generous. What has happened to him?
Thomas 3. Passing was shocking.
Lati 5
Bidwell 6
Sheaf 2
Eccles 4
Torp 5
Sakamoto 6
Rudoni 5
Simms 7

This is ridiculous. I’ve been puzzled by MVE and his decline but he did ok and to suggest simms was 7 times better is insane

Terry_dactyl · Jan 1, 2025

Well…I think it’s fair to say that was a game of 2 halves.

I can see BTA getting some shit, presumably for the ‘miss’. I’d have to see it again. My initial thought was that it was just too high for him. In which case what you gonna do? Other than that I thought he actually looked quite good.
Simms getting a lot plaudits and I’m not really too sure what he did. He was alright 2nd half.

Every player (except Dovin) should be embarrassed about that first half performance. Atrocious. Possibly the worst of the year…special mention to Thomas for ‘jumping in’ which allowed the cross for their goal (school boy stuff) and regularly passing to their players…but he wasn’t the only one.
Those crosses/balls into the box that Sheaf kept doing .

Anyway, it was an exciting game and I’d have taken a point before hand.

Nice not to be the people having to travel along the M4/M5 for once!

Cardiff player ratings (1 Viewer)

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency