Murphy- 6 Great save in first half
Hussey-4 where's his confidence gone?
Brown-4 awful
Edge-7 my MOM
Clarke-5 not fit
Jennings-4 non existent
Barton-4 did he play?
Kilbane-5 ran around chasing shadows
Baker-6 tried
Macdonald-5 hit the bar nothing else
Elliot-5 tried
Subs
Sheff-5 not much time
Mcgoldrick-6 looked lively
Murphy 6
Clarke 5
Brown 3
Edge 7
Hussey 5 form has dipped due to killer playing in front of him restricts him going forward
Jennings 5
Baker 5
Barton 5 needs to be subbed second half as he disappears
Killer 1 said it before the weak link of the team offers nothing going forward or defensively and so so slow
Cody 6
Elliot 6
Murphy 6
Clarke (looked un-fit) 4
Brown (don't care how long his throws are, stop running off to take them when you're centre back) 3
Edjenguele (didn't really put a foot wrong when his team mates around him were falling apart, so gets an 8 from me) 8
Hussey 5
Jennings 6
Baker 6
Kilbane (shocking performance & behaviour) 2
Barton (scared to pass it forward) 4
McDonald (usual lacklustre) 4
Elliot 5
McSheffrey 4
Ball (looks an awful player) 3
McGoldrick 6
Murphy- 6 Great save in first half
Hussey-4 where's his confidence gone?
Brown-4 awful
Edge-7 my MOM
Clarke-5 not fit
Jennings-4 non existent
Barton-4 did he play?
Kilbane-5 ran around chasing shadows
Baker-6 tried
Macdonald-5 hit the bar nothing else
Elliot-5 tried
Subs
Sheff-5 not much time
Mcgoldrick-6 looked lively
Murphy - 6 Exposed for the goal. Otherwise steady.
Hussey - 3 Dire. Very very limited.
Brown - 4 Don't think he was as bad as some will make out but looks very clumsy and uncomfortable in possession.
Edge - 7 One positive to come from today. Surprised how much he won in the air.
Clarke -5 Clearly not fit
Jennings - 4 Not great
Barton - 5 I think in many ways he looks very classy but almost seems to play in 3rd gear. I do worry he might not actually have any higher gears though and does seem to go missing when we are up against it.
Kilbane -5 struggled to get going.
Baker - 3 I thought he was awful. I hoped he would have some confidence after Tuesday but he's simply not good enough. The whole formation is geared up around this role and we need much more from this position.
Macdonald - 5 Fed off scraps. Good snap shop which hit the bar.
Elliot - 4 Ran around not much else. Service was awful though.
Subs
Sheff - 5 At least tried to be positive.
Mcgoldrick - 6 Some neat touches and one decent strike.
Edj was the only player that came out of the game with a better reputation. He's a guaranteed starter in next match imo. - 7 points
Murphy for the brilliant one handed save in the first I'm giving motm - 7 points
Shaw chose the team and the tactic; "pass the ball about, make sure it gets to Hussey, he can hoof it or pass it back to the keeper who can hoof it for him. Possession given back cheaply to the opposition who can attack again."
For this reason Shaw - 2 points
All other players - 5 points or less
Kilbane for lacking composure - 0 points
Me - 280 mile round trip, £20 ticket, £50 petrol and about 9hrs of my life I can't claim back
Utter humiliation of being just above relegation zone of division 3...