Search results

  1. The Philosopher

    Ratings

    Swansea weren’t excellent. They took a risk with that line and a slightly quicker no 10 would have caused major problems. Even someone who knew how to bend their runs. A McNulty type maybe. They shithoused the second half and we needed to get amongst them.
  2. The Philosopher

    Ratings thread?

    He’s some kind of troll tribute act I think.
  3. The Philosopher

    Ratings

    Moore 6 Weak wrist for first goal. We were losing and he could have sped things up. Distribution ok. Dabo 6 First 10 mins didn’t know where he was. Dithered for first goal (iirc) got better but wasn’t quick enough again in getting his crosses over. Fadz 6 Shocking first 20. Gets a point for...
  4. The Philosopher

    Transfer Rumour Billy Gilmour

    Above comment Is there something cryptic I’ve missed? Bright spending his money in Canary Wharf, an island in the river Thames?
  5. The Philosopher

    Transfer Rumour Billy Gilmour

    This is where we can spend Bright’s wage budget allocation. All good.
  6. The Philosopher

    Ratings thread?

    He doesn’t give the ball away stupid. I’ve seen a stat where he is the joint 31st best passer of the ball in a SSW direction from his left toe when playing away from home in a red shirt. That means you are wrong. I win. Ner ner ner. So there. (satire above by the way). It’s something that...
  7. The Philosopher

    Ratings thread?

    Clueless.
  8. The Philosopher

    Ratings thread?

    Fair enough. I’ll reflect on that. Any folk on here who like stats have any figures on the number of pens and such per minute that Godden wins? Any comparison stat v Waghorn / Walker? I’m interested is all. Thought Walker unlucky to be dropped after bagging 2 in 2 but stats like that (Godden...
  9. The Philosopher

    Ratings thread?

    There are a few that I think could develop between now and then to be so. Vik, Gus, Cal, Fanky some of the loanees may. Moore possibly. My point is clear: Sheaf will not progress to where he no doubt wants to get to without sorting out that side of his game.
  10. The Philosopher

    Ratings thread?

    That’s interesting. Any stat-gimps on here have the number of free kicks in dangerous areas / penalties won per minute that Godden has throughout his career?
  11. The Philosopher

    Ratings thread?

    100% agree. It’s a tricky thing pointing out any of Sheaf’s errors on this forum. There are one or two on here that will immediately pounce and point out some stat or other and say you’re “clueless” or that you aren’t astute enough to see that he has many invisible talents. It’s a form of...
  12. The Philosopher

    Bright and Robins

    I’d 100% agree if it were any other player & manager combination. Some managers believe they can get the best out of certain players. Robins grew up watching how Ferguson worked and (I’m reaching here, I know) might have thought that he could get the best out of Bright as he had (in some ways)...
  13. The Philosopher

    Bright and Robins

    I think the general consensus is that it was a punt that could have been a master-stroke. No one was to know at the time whether or not Bright was going to get his head down and become a valuable asset. There are those that like saying “told you so” but in reality no one had a clue, not even...
  14. The Philosopher

    Farke out………Robins in, What are the chances.

    Robins? Canaries? It’s for the birds.
  15. The Philosopher

    Walker

    I agree that Walker has good finishing skills but his hold up play and pressing is not the best by any stretch. We are more likely to lose the ball and as a result concede by having a player that can’t keep it very well. To be fair to Godden and Wag they do nip at defenders a bit more but this...
  16. The Philosopher

    Walker

    Hyam is comfortable in possession when he has his RWB in position and the defensive midfielders in position. When Dabo pushes high to cross from the byline (rather than whip in early) it’s a long way back. If during that time the opposition has made a break and Hyam has the ball then he’s got...
  17. The Philosopher

    January

    I think getting some of the fringe / bomb squad out on loan is the key. Even if we don’t get 100% of their wages paid, something is better than nothing. Shipley needs to go to somewhere like Dundee Utd on loan (get Max or McN to find him a spare bed) and get some games. Walker is the...
  18. The Philosopher

    Walker

    That’s right. Look how Gyok pressed back first half and won the ball tracking back to midfield. Better to have at least two forwards in the squad who can niggle, annoy, chase. See how Kazim R came on and just barged Maatsen off the ball on the touch line (knowing IM had been booked and might...
  19. The Philosopher

    Walker

    You insisted racism? Really?
  20. The Philosopher

    What has happened

    It was odd that Waghorn wasn’t given a run out yesterday. Scoring against old club jinx and all that? Odd. Odd. Odd.
Top