25/26 January Transfer Window (51 Viewers)

SkyBlueDom26

Well-Known Member
Dan Neil isn’t better than Grimes or Torp… Jack Taylor has been distinctly average in a v good setup. Neil improves them but not us.

We need a player like Matusiwa who is physical. I’d argue he was one of the key difference makers in both fixtures against us.
Neil is definitely better than Torp, and arguably better than grimes. He can actually tackle and run
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
Would love to know what our budget is. Do we reckon it’s purely wages holding us back?
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
Holding us back from what? We just signed another player?

Competing for players with other teams and spending loads on this lad and Bassette and the like who will be cheap wages. We seem happy to spend on fees but not to compete on wages.
 

SBT

Well-Known Member
Competing for players with other teams and spending loads on this lad and Bassette and the like who will be cheap wages. We seem happy to spend on fees but not to compete on wages.
Depends if you think we were ever in on those players - are we assuming that this signing precludes any more business now? Or do you think this is it?
 

theferret

Well-Known Member
Would love to know what our budget is. Do we reckon it’s purely wages holding us back?

The fact we spent £8 million, pretty much our entire transfer budget for the season (to this pont) on two players who can't get in the team doesn't help. All this clamour for new signings, the chances of us signing anyone that forces their way into the starting lineup is slim. Sure, we can strengthen the squad and that helps, but can't see us spending the kind of money needed to bring in someone that goes straight in. We have what we have.
 
Last edited:

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
Depends if you think we were ever in on those players - are we assuming that this signing precludes any more business now? Or do you think this is it?

Well it’s more looking at who we do go for. Drop £2m on Bassette and €5m on this lad and £5m on L1 players but won’t get Bamford in or whatever.

Mostly I’m genuinely curious what our constraints are.
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
The fact we spent £8 million, pretty much our entire transfer budget for the season (seemingly) on two players who can't get in the team doesn't help. All this clamour for new signings, the chances of us signing anyone that forces their way into the starting lineup is slim. Sure, we can strengthen the squad and that helps, but can't see us spending the kind of money needed to bring in someone that goes straight in. We have what we have.

We are spending that money though, just not on players who go straight in. Thats what makes it weird.
 

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
Well it’s more looking at who we do go for. Drop £2m on Bassette and €5m on this lad and £5m on L1 players but won’t get Bamford in or whatever.

Mostly I’m genuinely curious what our constraints are.
When you have 3 strikers in double figures for the season, that’s probably a constraint…
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
When you have 3 strikers in double figures for the season, that’s probably a constraint…

Eh?

edit: with you now. I suppose if it’s not down to Lampard but we’ve just spent €5m on a right winger when we’ve got two already. Would genuinely have made more sense to spend it on a LB at least. Just seems weird from the outside.
 

SBT

Well-Known Member
Well it’s more looking at who we do go for. Drop £2m on Bassette and €5m on this lad and £5m on L1 players but won’t get Bamford in or whatever.

Mostly I’m genuinely curious what our constraints are.
This guy’s costing £5 million?! Hadn’t seen that…
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
Eh?

edit: with you now. I suppose if it’s not down to Lampard but we’ve just spent €5m on a right winger when we’ve got two already. Would genuinely have made more sense to spend it on a LB at least. Just seems weird from the outside.
I’ll reserve judgement for now but you’d think we have a plan for him and potentially other players.

My gut feeling is that I can just see Sakamoto being moved somewhere else. Maybe LW or even AM, why else sign 2 RW? Since Sunderland away (2-2), I’ve wanted to see him play LW (or even LWB in niche examples) again because he’s got a good delivery. At AM, perhaps he gives us a bit of legs off the ball but question how well he’d do with 2-4 players around him.
 

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
Torp's been great this season.
It’s just a ridiculous thing to say. Neil is a good player but 2 goals and 3 assists last season doesn’t necessarily strike me as being a huge game changer.

He’s better than Jack Taylor imo, so upgrades their options.

Looking at Grimes v Neil head to head in 24/25, Grimes is the better player with Neil being more solid defensively. Torp is obviously much better than both players as a chance creator.
 

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
So does everybody with the way we play.
It’s an intensity thing, for the first 50-60 minutes last night, he was good and won the ball high up the pitch. If we had a more physically dominant player than Allen, that’d suit the system v well.

The tactical instruction is to clearly try to win the ball high up the pitch and if the opposition beat the press, to ‘turtle’ defensively in a narrow shape, hence our fullbacks retreat narrowly if they can’t win the ball.
 

19Skybluearmy76

Well-Known Member
Well this came out of the blue, let's hope there's more to follow. It seems strange we've forked out a reported £5m for a winger we don't need. The fact this money has been spent gives me hope that there will be other additions in the key areas.
 

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
Strange one that, 3rd choice RW… obviously saving the big one until Monday
Have you ever considered that it’s Sakamoto who’s probably falling down the pecking order?

It’s quite funny because even when we brought Esse in, people were insisting it was competition for Sakamoto and until recently the idea that we was ‘arguably’ better than Esse…

Sakamoto is a cult hero, if you don’t like him, you have no heart. He’s been with the club a while and his numbers are consistently ‘above average’.
 

Deity

Well-Known Member
Competing for players with other teams and spending loads on this lad and Bassette and the like who will be cheap wages. We seem happy to spend on fees but not to compete on wages.

Jesus you two. Do you ever stop moaning.

Do you know how entitled you sound ?
 

quinn1971

Well-Known Member
Have you ever considered that it’s Sakamoto who’s probably falling down the pecking order?

It’s quite funny because even when we brought Esse in, people were insisting it was competition for Sakamoto and until recently the idea that we was ‘arguably’ better than Esse…

Sakamoto is a cult hero, if you don’t like him, you have no heart. He’s been with the club a while and his numbers are consistently ‘above average’.
Sakamoto is great off the bench, he’s not dropping down to 3rd choice, and MVE isn’t the same when saka doesn’t play, they link up well,
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top