Millwall player ratings (2 Viewers)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
All starters 5 bar Grimes
All subs 6
Lampard 5 (same score I'd give for any manager making 8 changes)
All subs 6
Lampard 5 (same score I'd give for any manager making 8 changes)
Cally Fedora
Well-Known Member
Averageness abounds. Brau looked tidy. Grimes quality. Andrews, Simms, Allen and Raphael anonymous. Rudoni quality when on.
AFCCOVENTRY
Well-Known Member
Andrews isn’t ready for Champ football. He needs to loan out and get a proper season of men’s football.
Allen I’m sorry but he needs to move on. Adds nothing.
KKH was a car crash. He’s like Bambi. Not a single cross into the box!
Brau is a good technician and has potential. He needs more time to understand how we play but will come good.
Simms was Simms today. He is just ineffective. The way Haji came on an impacted the game shows how far he is from being a starter. He needs replacing so we have some impact.
BTA was ineffective today. Think he’s fine with the starting line up we had at the weekend but looked weak without the all stars.
Rapha had a couple of good runs but overall ineffective. Think he’s a good impact sub late in a game if we’re winning.
Allen I’m sorry but he needs to move on. Adds nothing.
KKH was a car crash. He’s like Bambi. Not a single cross into the box!
Brau is a good technician and has potential. He needs more time to understand how we play but will come good.
Simms was Simms today. He is just ineffective. The way Haji came on an impacted the game shows how far he is from being a starter. He needs replacing so we have some impact.
BTA was ineffective today. Think he’s fine with the starting line up we had at the weekend but looked weak without the all stars.
Rapha had a couple of good runs but overall ineffective. Think he’s a good impact sub late in a game if we’re winning.
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
Only brau comes out with credit from starters
KKH Andrews and allens stood out as particularly bad. Simms and bta not much better
KKH Andrews and allens stood out as particularly bad. Simms and bta not much better
SleepyGinger
Well-Known Member
Main positive is we looked really good when we had a lot of the first team out there
Andrews isn't far off imo
I don't think Andrews is far off. When Burroughs and Howley first entered the first team they were clearly a lower level. Andrews has a good touch and given more opportunities will improve. KKH clearly has attributes but was very rusty. His passing was particularly poor. However, he is decent (and better than MVE) in the air.
I do like Brau and think he looks okay pushed further forward. He has some decent skills and a good cross.
Raphael has definitely improved since last season and hopefully will continue to do so with game time. He's another with good attributes if he can improve decision making.
Ccfcisparks
Well-Known Member
BTA Was absolutely atrocious. He put his rubber boots on again tonight.
Thought Brau was ok, but both him and KKH struggled with zero cover from the wide players.
Simms fed off scraps, then had nobody around him when he did manage to get the ball under control.
Andrews and Rafa need a season playing mens football, they were too slow and not physical enough.
The need for another CB is stark and we desperately need wide player cover.
Sent from my SM-S911B using Tapatalk
Simms fed off scraps, then had nobody around him when he did manage to get the ball under control.
Andrews and Rafa need a season playing mens football, they were too slow and not physical enough.
The need for another CB is stark and we desperately need wide player cover.
Sent from my SM-S911B using Tapatalk
lord_garrincha
Well-Known Member
My early concern with KKH was not defensive - a few double ups on him left him exposed - but, when attacking, he was cutting in rather going outside... when he did that at the last knockings to play it to Kitching to cross raged me... new boy lack of confidence???
Ccfcisparks
Well-Known Member
Yes reminded me a lot of MVE in his slump start of last season. Just didnt seem to have confidence to take it past a man and whip a ball in,
larry_david
Well-Known Member
I'll defend Andrews because the lads 18 and had to play alongside Allen who's next to useless atm.
But Allen there's no excuse and we've seen that kind of game from him far more than we've seen the effective Allen
But Allen there's no excuse and we've seen that kind of game from him far more than we've seen the effective Allen
skybluecam
Well-Known Member
Wilson 5
KKH 4
Thomas 6
Bidwell 6
Brau 5
Grimes 6
Allen 5
Andrews 4
Rapha 5
Simms 5
BTA 4
KKH 4
Thomas 6
Bidwell 6
Brau 5
Grimes 6
Allen 5
Andrews 4
Rapha 5
Simms 5
BTA 4
lord_garrincha
Well-Known Member
Played the Torp role... and is not up to it. Might have been better to give Grimes the night off and play him there.
Ccfcisparks
Well-Known Member
He was one of the better players, but we can't get comfortable with him as backup CB all year.
no_loyalty
Well-Known Member
Ccfcisparks
Well-Known Member
These would be mine pretty much bang on
Wilson 6 Gives me the heebie jeebies
KKH 5 Clearly has some good attributes but he was crap
Thomas 6
Bidwell 6 Pleasantly surprised but surely he’s not the answer long-term
Brau 6 Some good final balls but he’s a long way off figuring out this system
Grimes 6
Allen 5
Andrews 5 Pretty classic example of a kid not having the nous for a senior game
BTA 5 Nothing came off for him
Simms 6 Worked admirably hard to no avail
Rafael 5 I struggle to see what he offers
Kitching 5
Rudoni 7 MOTM A cut above every other player on the pitch
Torp 6
Wright 7 Showed up Simms’ shortcomings yet again
KKH 5 Clearly has some good attributes but he was crap
Thomas 6
Bidwell 6 Pleasantly surprised but surely he’s not the answer long-term
Brau 6 Some good final balls but he’s a long way off figuring out this system
Grimes 6
Allen 5
Andrews 5 Pretty classic example of a kid not having the nous for a senior game
BTA 5 Nothing came off for him
Simms 6 Worked admirably hard to no avail
Rafael 5 I struggle to see what he offers
Kitching 5
Rudoni 7 MOTM A cut above every other player on the pitch
Torp 6
Wright 7 Showed up Simms’ shortcomings yet again
SeaSeeEffCee
Well-Known Member
There are certain players that some people simply don’t want to like.
skybluecam
Well-Known Member
go on
He's capable of 1 or 2 good games at a time, and then 1 or 2 where he's just off it.
If he's sticking around I'm glad this was one of his off games.
Bad Boy
Well-Known Member
Yep I'll own up to that.
blunted
Well-Known Member
The players who were not first choice did nothing to say put me in the team.
KKH was terrible but I am sure he just had an off day.
Rapha and Andrews were prime Ayari. Possibly good players for the future. Allen along with those two and BTA were muscled off the ball every time.
Brau is a long way off yet. Got the physicality, needs to be more clinical with his passing and especially his shooting.
Wilson. no chance with second goal. First, a top quality goalie may have saved it.
Kitch. How many yellows before a suspension?
The players who came on looked class.
My worry is we have no one to come on after our first 11 who is top 6 sub class unless Sheaf can regain his form.
KKH was terrible but I am sure he just had an off day.
Rapha and Andrews were prime Ayari. Possibly good players for the future. Allen along with those two and BTA were muscled off the ball every time.
Brau is a long way off yet. Got the physicality, needs to be more clinical with his passing and especially his shooting.
Wilson. no chance with second goal. First, a top quality goalie may have saved it.
Kitch. How many yellows before a suspension?
The players who came on looked class.
My worry is we have no one to come on after our first 11 who is top 6 sub class unless Sheaf can regain his form.
rob9872
Well-Known Member
Agree, im a bit like that with Collins and tbh the more I see of him, starting to feel the same about Simms. His service was poor, but he has zero goal threat. Times his jumps so badly. 6ft4 and jumps 6ft2
Nick
Administrator
The second goal was easier
CCFC86
Active Member
The starting midfielders shown that they aren’t good enough to be starting
It was a perfect opportunity for Andrew’s to put his name in the mix to fight for a first team place but based off that performance against millwall he won’t be starting as for Allen how is he still here?
Allen just spins around in circles and either passes to the back or the side does not effect the game at all
Obviously we lost because of bad defending but we also lost because it shows the backup midfield we have are no good. A few players had bad games but not every player can play well all the time.
Simms disappeared as the game went on BTA was not linking up well with Simms we just needed 10 extra more minutes to get an equaliser positive signs were we looked a lot better when the likes of wright torp and rudi was on
It was a perfect opportunity for Andrew’s to put his name in the mix to fight for a first team place but based off that performance against millwall he won’t be starting as for Allen how is he still here?
Allen just spins around in circles and either passes to the back or the side does not effect the game at all
Obviously we lost because of bad defending but we also lost because it shows the backup midfield we have are no good. A few players had bad games but not every player can play well all the time.
Simms disappeared as the game went on BTA was not linking up well with Simms we just needed 10 extra more minutes to get an equaliser positive signs were we looked a lot better when the likes of wright torp and rudi was on