Sunderland ratings (1 Viewer)

Otis said:

I thought Kelly was dissppointing.

Click to expand...

Agreed but I still thought he was better than Walsh. I thought Walsh over complicated things at times and gave the ball away too often.
I feel a bit mean for being critical.

Terry_dactyl said:

Agreed but I still thought he was better than Walsh. I thought Walsh over complicated things at times and gave the ball away too often.
I feel a bit mean for being critical.

Click to expand...

Hey we can all be a bit picky but we can forgive them for giving us this amazing season so far...god bless them.all

lord_garrincha said:

Is Kelly just knackered???

Usually he misses big chunks of the season with injury, and this time (other than early on when Walsh came in) he hasn't. He seems a yard off everything.

Back three were like trojans today... just a great day!

Click to expand...

Marosi 7
Hyam 9
Mcfadz 9
Rose 8
Dabo 8
Macallum 7
Walsh 8
Kelly..4..(I'm generous with 4).was one of my fav player...something very wrong. Didn't want the ball. Gave ball away at every OPPO. Abysmal. How can some say he improved 2nd half? He was at fault for their non goal. We totally carried him.

Allen 9..motm
Ohare 7
Godden 8

Baka. 6...was good substitution.

Godden has his best all round game for us only let down by the late miss

I said the other week godden wins Alot of headers and he does... He was very good today

dubed said:

Click to expand...

Fair play to him.

Marosi - 7 He looked bored!
Dabo - 7 worked hard but didn’t get down the line too much in the 2nd half and leaked a few opportunities
Hyam - 9 solid all day
Mcfadzean - 9 solid all day
Rose - 9 solid all day!
McCallum - 7.5. The better of the 2 wing backs and worked hard
Kelly - 6.5 not great but not awful, sloppy passes in the first half especially. Looks tired, would swap for shippers
Walsh - 7.5 decent game but some lapses of concentration in the second half
Ohare - 8 constant running machine, just wish his final play was complete but then if it was he would be a prem player
Allen - 9 fantastic today, never stopped and creating chances, the difference between the two sides today MOTM
Godden - 8.5 ran his socks off today, some things didn’t work out but got into the right positions

fans - 8.5 loud and constantly backing the boys

We picked motm today and it was pretty much unanimous for Allen between us with one each for Godden and Fadz. Great team performance and deserved victory.

Marosi - 7.5
Dabo - 8
Hyam - 9
Mcfadzean - 9.5 motm
Rose - 9
McCallum - 7
Kelly - 6
Walsh -7
Ohare - 7.5
Allen - 8
Godden - 8.5

Excellent team performance. Kelly’s distribution (and shooting) let him down but he made great interceptions and battled for everything. The CBs just get better every game...stopped Sunderland from any decent attempt on goal (apart from the offside). McCallum not as good in air but defensively sound second half. Dabo...one of his least effective performances for a while...but still a fantastic engine. In midfield Walsh did what was required; O’Hare and Allen (my motm) closed them down and ran at them effectively. Godden worked fantastically hard first half (should have scored a second)...and Baka did some important running/chasing when he came on. Overall 8s and 9s all round...they all played a part. When we get the ball down and move it quickly we look unstoppable.

Top of the league...and deservedly so. I’m starting to believe.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

SkyBlueDom26 said:

Silly old twat, guys an embarrassment

Click to expand...

He's alright - actually says Cov fans are decent, Mrs doing a great job etc. The Wealdstone raider, however.....

dubed said:

Click to expand...

Top you tuber and fair play for his honest thought on today.
Would be nice if a few of us could help his daughter out as well

Kelly was better second half but no doubting something isn't quite right. There was a time in the second half he chested it down with no one anywhere near him and then just hoofed it up in the air falling over. It wasn't long ago I'd bank on him never giving the ball away in any situation. Luckily for us we have 1 game a week now for a while so rest is welcome.

Glad we're out the cup now

larry_david said:

Kelly was better second half but no doubting something isn't quite right. There was a time in the second half he chested it down with no one anywhere near him and then just hoofed it up in the air falling over. It wasn't long ago I'd bank on him never giving the ball away in any situation. Luckily for us we have 1 game a week now for a while so rest is welcome.

Glad we're out the cup now

Click to expand...

Needs a rest mate nothing more than that but we don’t have anyone in there to help him I’m certain he will come out the other side couple days rest this week maybe will help

skybluesam66 said:

Godden has his best all round game for us only let down by the late miss

Click to expand...

That chance wasn’t easy mate ball was bouncing on his wrong side to get a foot around it from that angle and was still far ish out he took it on early on another day it creeps in the near post

Londonccfcfan said:

He was at fault for their non goal.

Click to expand...

Honestly, when we're looking for players being at fault for non-goals then I think we're being too harsh in our marking. Let he who has not been a fault for a non-goal throw the first stone.

marcusp said:

Top you tuber and fair play for his honest thought on today.
Would be nice if a few of us could help his daughter out as well

Click to expand...

I'll give her a donation!

Kelly hasnt been great but he's our skipper, we're 13 unbeaten, lost 3 all season and are top of the league. We need to mess with our formation to exclude him. He's out of form, in truth he might need a rest, but let's not hound him out of the team and suggest dropping him whilst things are going so well. Hopefully he'll play through it.

rob9872 said:

Kelly hasnt been great but he's our skipper, we're 13 unbeaten, lost 3 all season and are top of the league. We need to mess with our formation to exclude him. He's out of form, in truth he might need a rest, but let's not hound him out of the team and suggest dropping him whilst things are going so well. Hopefully he'll play through it.

Click to expand...

I’m certain he will come with a storming game soon possibly Saturday

cc84cov said:

That chance wasn’t easy mate ball was bouncing on his wrong side to get a foot around it from that angle and was still far ish out he took it on early on another day it creeps in the near post

Click to expand...

I was hoping he would cut across the defender, he either gets brought down and it's a red for their player or he gets the ball on the right side for a decent finish. Not important as we won anyway

JimmyHillsbeard said:

Fair play to him.

Click to expand...

The man who's offside is O'Nien, O'Nien
The man who's offside is O'Nien!

- salute the Geordies.

cc84cov said:

I’m certain he will come with a storming game soon possibly Saturday

Click to expand...

And that thunderbolt we're all waiting for

Grendel said:

it’s absurd - he runs and runs and is the most committed loaner from a premier club I can remember - he’s totally committed as if he’s on a ten year contract - Biamou would have been shocking in that game

Click to expand...

There you go again - how can you say that Biamou would have been shocking? Biamou MIGHT have been shocking, but you insist on stating such things as facts.

ps1948 said:

There you go again - how can you say that Biamou would have been shocking? Biamou MIGHT have been shocking, but you insist on stating such things as facts.

Click to expand...

No he’s far too slow and it’s why he wasn’t included

Grendel said:

No he’s far too slow and it’s why he wasn’t included

Click to expand...

Sorry Mark, obviously you know best.....

ps1948 said:

Sorry Mark, obviously you know best.....

Click to expand...

Boring

Grenners thought jch was good for us, he was usually shit. Grenners knows fuck all about football

David O'Day said:

Grenners thought jch was good for us, he was usually shit. Grenners knows fuck all about football

Click to expand...

Next you’ll be saying Willis was dropped for the play off first leg

Grendel said:

Next you’ll be saying Willis was dropped for the play off first leg

Click to expand...

I said he wasn't in the team and came back in when davies was suspended. Still you are a known liar and the board joke.

Marosi - 6
Dabo -10
Rose -10
McFadzean -10
Hyam - 10
McCallum - 6
Kelly - 5
Walsh - 5
O’Hare - 9
Allen - 8
Godden - 8



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

skyblueelephant76 said:

Someone I was sat next to was speaking to the father of one of our fitness coaches. Apparently Kelly picked up a knock in the week and isn't 100% fit.

Click to expand...

If he's not fit shouldn't be playing then. Just think his distribution has been poor over the last few games. But he's an integral part of the team and breaks the play up. And does the nuts and bolts of the game.

Grendel said:

No he’s far too slow and it’s why he wasn’t included

Click to expand...

Embarrasing yourself again with statements like that.

CovBrummie94 said:

Marosi - 6
Dabo -10
Rose -10
McFadzean -10
Hyam - 10
McCallum - 6
Kelly - 5
Walsh - 5
O’Hare - 9
Allen - 8
Godden - 8



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Click to expand...

Not sure id give Walsh same poor rating as Kelly.

Walsh carried Kelly.

rob9872 said:

Kelly hasnt been great but he's our skipper, we're 13 unbeaten, lost 3 all season and are top of the league. We need to mess with our formation to exclude him. He's out of form, in truth he might need a rest, but let's not hound him out of the team and suggest dropping him whilst things are going so well. Hopefully he'll play through it.

Click to expand...

I watched the full game again on Sky sports when i got in yesterday. Maybe im being a tad harsh on Kelly. Hes been brilliant for us for so long.

The drop in quality and experience to eccles yesterday would have been a big gamble for Robins. Hes obviously carrying an injury.

Londonccfcfan said:

Not sure id give Walsh same poor rating as Kelly.

Walsh carried Kelly.

Click to expand...

Also Godden was immense - Dabo had a few lapses in concentration where he got the ball taken off him whilst dithering in possession
I would put Godden ahead of Dabo