Walsh, O Hare, Dabo (1 Viewer)

Dunno m8

robbiekeane said:

I thought were fantastic today and have been our best outfield performers this season. Some of the link up play between Dabo and Walsh was great to watch.

Anyway, question is, if we were to be a championship team come the summer, what do you think the chances would be of making either Walsh or O’Hare permanent (I think very low indeed), and what are the chances of retaining Dabo?

Click to expand...

Walsh - good chance of signing him if we go up.
Dabo - Same, think we'll keep him if promoted.
O'Hare - no chance

Dont mess with the Dabo, about time we had some players willing to dish it out.

Think we would have much more chance of keeping Walsh than O’Hare. The little wizard is going all the way.

robbiekeane said:

Click to expand...

Well that wasn’t a yellow

Wonder what Villa would want for O'Hare

None of them look Premiership level, so if we are promoted there is every chance. There could be a wages issue with Walsh. But as Kelly might struggle at the higher level, having Walsh would be handy

Dabo is our player so think we’d retain him if we got promoted.

Walsh, Bristol like him and have a 1 year option in their favour (I believe), so will probably stay with them.

O’Hare is an interesting one. Dependent on if Villa getting relegated or not. Stay up, Grealish stays and they’ll have to strengthen for 20/21. O’Hare probably unlikely to earn a new contract. Relegation, Grealish will leave and there’s a space for him in the Villa squad to rebuild.

I agree they are three key players. It might seem strange classing O’Hare in that category as he isn’t always a starter but his ability to change games is significant. With more experience he’ll definitely become one be it here or elsewhere.

Dabo - definitely stay. Even if we don’t go up I think there’s an outside chance he would, dependent on who was interested.

Walsh - Bristol had concerns about him when without the ball. So depends if they think he’s improved that aspect (I’d say he has) as there may be a chance if not. If Bristol were promoted I think getting him back on loan would be likely.

O’Hare - very well thought of at Villa, so I’d guess another loan would be possible as long as we are promoted and Villa stay up.

Of the three I’d be least concerned about O’Hare, as he’s the most replaceable. While he’s a game changer, other players with that attribute and ability do exist. Ideal world though we keep all three as part of our Championship squad.

Robins will add to the squad for certain trouble with loanees apart from their parent club others will have taken note as we saw last season with Bright and Luke Thomas. MR will have done his homework but a lot will depend what division we are in and possibly our ground situation.

CovInEssex said:

Wonder what Villa would want for O'Hare

Click to expand...

His Villa contract is up in the summer. Apparently they will look to keep him if they get relegated

Heard from a reliable source that we are already enquiring about signing Walsh permanently in the summer. No surprise really,it’s just a case of whether we can pull it off or not.

If we are still playing at St Andrews no chance of signing either

Signing O'hare on a free would be some business. Walsh I imagine they'd want £1.5-2m? He obviously doesn't feature in their plans

With regards to retaining Walsh and O’Hare I think a lot depends on where Bristol and Villa end up next season. The ideal would be if Bristol achieved promotion and Villa stayed up. However, IMO both are looking unlikely. And tbf even if it didn’t, there’s the obstacle of a transfer fee - which we’d only be able to pay if we were back at the Ricoh. Otherwise acquiring both or either would be an impossibility.

CovInEssex said:

Signing O'hare on a free would be some business. Walsh I imagine they'd want £1.5-2m? He obviously doesn't feature in their plans

Click to expand...

Walsh is out of contract in the summer. If they offer him a contract then we'd have to pay a small amount as he'll just be within age for a compulsory training fee.

mrtrench said:

Walsh is out of contract in the summer. If they offer him a contract then we'd have to pay a small amount as he'll just be within age for a compulsory training fee.

Click to expand...

Walsh is on a renewable extension which their manager says he will trigger

Grendel said:

Walsh is on a renewable extension which their manager says he will trigger

Click to expand...

Really? Blast, doesn't mention that on wikipedia. Too bad.

All 3 have futures above this level

Dabo has an engine that Ive rarely ever seen at this level... He doesn't stop

robbiekeane said:

I thought were fantastic today and have been our best outfield performers this season. Some of the link up play between Dabo and Walsh was great to watch.

Anyway, question is, if we were to be a championship team come the summer, what do you think the chances would be of making either Walsh or O’Hare permanent (I think very low indeed), and what are the chances of retaining Dabo?

Click to expand...

Dabo was linking up with westbrooke on the rhs yesterday brilliantly. Westbrooke very underrated.

W

Incredible the options MR has in midfield.

Allen didn't even get on the pitch.

Westbrooke has already done more this season in league 1 , than Bayliss did last season in league 1.

As always IF we get promoted we have a chanxe of keeping the loan stars for another year

Londonccfcfan said:

Incredible the options MR has in midfield.

Allen didn't even get on the pitch.

Westbrooke has already done more this season in league 1 , than Bayliss did last season in league 1.

Click to expand...

Bayliss was massively over rated on here Westbrooke & Shipley have done a hell of a lot more than he did at league 1 level

I think we assume the loans will not be here beyond this season. Walsh and ohare have been fabulous. Giles may well have the same impact

covcity4life said:

As always IF we get promoted we have a chanxe of keeping the loan stars for another year

Click to expand...

there’s no chance of keeping Walsh

Grendel said:

there’s no chance of keeping Walsh

Click to expand...

Gotta hope Bristol get to prem i guess

covcity4life said:

Gotta hope Bristol get to prem i guess

Click to expand...

he’s only hot one year left on a contract there so there’s little point in loaning him again

Grendel said:

he’s only hot one year left on a contract there so there’s little point in loaning him again

Click to expand...

Maybe will extend it. If not wonder how much to prise him away? 3m? 5m?

Prob too much for us

covcity4life said:

Maybe will extend it. If not wonder how much to prise him away? 3m? 5m?

Prob too much for us

Click to expand...

The fee would probably be less the problem will be wages Bristol are likely to be paying a lot more than we can offer

robbiekeane said:

Click to expand...

what a fuckin beast, love him

Evo1883 said:

All 3 have futures above this level

Dabo has an engine that Ive rarely ever seen at this level... He doesn't stop

Click to expand...

Yes with us

Grendel said:

The fee would probably be less the problem will be wages Bristol are likely to be paying a lot more than we can offer

Click to expand...

If we can’t compete with wages let’s throw the towel in now. Championship players will want championship wages and you can’t have players valued a million here and a million there and pay lower league wages. If sisu can’t get that sell us.

covcity4life said:

Gotta hope Bristol get to prem i guess

Click to expand...

Bristol City have Szmodics out on loan at posh too. What a phenomena player he is. Scoring goals for fun since January.

How good is their midfield when 2 players of Walsh and Sczmodocs ability out on loan.