Ratings (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter MalcSB
- Start date
superskyblue
Well-Known Member
Marosi - 7 adapted well to high press and his distribution longer was generally good
Dabo - 8 very impressive defensive display again from him
Rose - 6 didn't stand out to me in a good or bad way
McFadzean - 8 the player we all thought we were signing
Hyam - N/A
McCallum - 7 continues to impress, made a couple of good recoveries
Kelly - 7 he wasn't great first half but ran it second half, our most important player
Westbrooke - 6 thought he looked really uncomfortable in the deeper position, better when shape changed after Hyam went off
O'Hare - 6 lively and tenacious without creating too much
Bakayoko - 7 a better performance from him, and did well on the right hand side, surprisingly
Biamou - 8 won a lot in the air, battled hard and great movement/finish for the goal
Shipley - 7 good energy and using the ball better than last season
Allen - N/A but looked lively enough when he came on
Godden - N/A
Dabo - 8 very impressive defensive display again from him
Rose - 6 didn't stand out to me in a good or bad way
McFadzean - 8 the player we all thought we were signing
Hyam - N/A
McCallum - 7 continues to impress, made a couple of good recoveries
Kelly - 7 he wasn't great first half but ran it second half, our most important player
Westbrooke - 6 thought he looked really uncomfortable in the deeper position, better when shape changed after Hyam went off
O'Hare - 6 lively and tenacious without creating too much
Bakayoko - 7 a better performance from him, and did well on the right hand side, surprisingly
Biamou - 8 won a lot in the air, battled hard and great movement/finish for the goal
Shipley - 7 good energy and using the ball better than last season
Allen - N/A but looked lively enough when he came on
Godden - N/A
mark82
Moderator
Marosi - 7 - Didn't do a whole lot wrong, although would need to see the goal again to see if his positioning could've been better.
McCallum - 8 - Was my MOTM. He's come on so much. Don't think he put a foot wrong today, some good tackles, good going forward. Docked a point for not chinning the Ipswich player who threw him down
McFadzean - 7 - Solid
Rose - 7 - As with McFadzean, pretty solid all game.
Hyam - 6
Dabo - 7 - Not his best game, but not bad either. Did well defensively, occasionally a threat going forward.
Kelly - 5 - Didn't think Kelly was at his best today. Gave the ball away a lot. But better second half.
Westbrooke - 6 - had an OK game. Nothing spectacular, nothing particularly wrong.
O'Hare - 7 - Looks a threat. Wish he'd run in behind Biamou a bit more though.
Bakayoko - 7 - Not great in first half but looked good when moved out to the right. Best I've seen him play for a while. Ran at them a couple of times and looked to get moving forward.
Biamou - 8 - won pretty much everything in the air first half, but no-one gambled behind him. Took his goal well and played well second half in general.ran hard for the team.
Shipley - 7 - thought he changed the game, although mostly down to the formation change thought he played pretty well.
Allen - Looks a really good player (albeit a bit of a midget). Excited to see more from him.
Godden - Great to see him back on the pitch ahead of schedule.
McCallum - 8 - Was my MOTM. He's come on so much. Don't think he put a foot wrong today, some good tackles, good going forward. Docked a point for not chinning the Ipswich player who threw him down
McFadzean - 7 - Solid
Rose - 7 - As with McFadzean, pretty solid all game.
Hyam - 6
Dabo - 7 - Not his best game, but not bad either. Did well defensively, occasionally a threat going forward.
Kelly - 5 - Didn't think Kelly was at his best today. Gave the ball away a lot. But better second half.
Westbrooke - 6 - had an OK game. Nothing spectacular, nothing particularly wrong.
O'Hare - 7 - Looks a threat. Wish he'd run in behind Biamou a bit more though.
Bakayoko - 7 - Not great in first half but looked good when moved out to the right. Best I've seen him play for a while. Ran at them a couple of times and looked to get moving forward.
Biamou - 8 - won pretty much everything in the air first half, but no-one gambled behind him. Took his goal well and played well second half in general.ran hard for the team.
Shipley - 7 - thought he changed the game, although mostly down to the formation change thought he played pretty well.
Allen - Looks a really good player (albeit a bit of a midget). Excited to see more from him.
Godden - Great to see him back on the pitch ahead of schedule.
speedie87
Well-Known Member
Marosi 7
Dabo 8 great in second half
Rose 8 solid
Mcfadzean 7
Hyam 7 caught out a couple of times before he went off
McCallum 6 some poor crosses, think mason is the better player at present
Kelly 7
Westbrooke 6
Ohare 7
Baka 6
Biamou 7
Shipley 8
352 I’d give a 5
433 an 8
Dabo 8 great in second half
Rose 8 solid
Mcfadzean 7
Hyam 7 caught out a couple of times before he went off
McCallum 6 some poor crosses, think mason is the better player at present
Kelly 7
Westbrooke 6
Ohare 7
Baka 6
Biamou 7
Shipley 8
352 I’d give a 5
433 an 8
Johhny Blue
Well-Known Member
Kastaneer deserves at least a 7
Great for team (and fan) morale
Great for team (and fan) morale
Cavan O'Doherty
Well-Known Member
O’Hare and Bakayoko a 7? O’Hare was non existent and I thought he had one of his worst games for us today, Bakayoko distinctly average but I guess that’s an improvement on previous showings.Marosi - 7 - Didn't do a whole lot wrong, although would need to see the goal again to see if his positioning could've been better.
McCallum - 8 - Was my MOTM. He's come on so much. Don't think he put a foot wrong today, some good tackles, good going forward. Docked a point for not chinning the Ipswich player who threw him down
McFadzean - 7 - Solid
Rose - 7 - As with McFadzean, pretty solid all game.
Hyam - 6
Dabo - 7 - Not his best game, but not bad either. Did well defensively, occasionally a threat going forward.
Kelly - 5 - Didn't think Kelly was at his best today. Gave the ball away a lot. But better second half.
Westbrooke - 6 - had an OK game. Nothing spectacular, nothing particularly wrong.
O'Hare - 7 - Looks a threat. Wish he'd run in behind Biamou a bit more though.
Bakayoko - 7 - Not great in first half but looked good when moved out to the right. Best I've seen him play for a while. Ran at them a couple of times and looked to get moving forward.
Biamou - 8 - won pretty much everything in the air first half, but no-one gambled behind him. Took his goal well and played well second half in general.ran hard for the team.
Shipley - 7 - thought he changed the game, although mostly down to the formation change thought he played pretty well.
Allen - Looks a really good player (albeit a bit of a midget). Excited to see more from him.
Godden - Great to see him back on the pitch ahead of schedule.
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
Non existent apart from great runs to get on the end of two through balls in either half. Bakayoko was decent once again.
AStonesThrow
Well-Known Member
My issue with O'Hare today was his needless losing of possession, sometimes I feel he tries to do too much where it would be more effective to pass. More so in the first half.
Also felt Kelly looked tired, I'd have switched him for Walsh around 60 mins
Also felt Kelly looked tired, I'd have switched him for Walsh around 60 mins
Irish Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Thought Kelly played well second half (I think Walsh was injured).I thought this was one of Bakayoko’s best games. A few nice touches first half and played really well in the second. I would love Max to succeed and really show those who simply sneer at his performances. However, I thought he had a pretty quiet game today. His movement and finish for the goal were great so not complaining too much.
johnwillomagic
Well-Known Member
I think I'd go with the following.
Marosi 7
Dabo 7.5
McCallum 7
Rose 6.5
MacFadzean 8
Hyam 6
Westbrooke 6
O'Hare 7
Kelly 6.5
Baka 6.5
Biamou 7.5
Shipley 7
Allen 6.5
Godden 6
Marosi 7
Dabo 7.5
McCallum 7
Rose 6.5
MacFadzean 8
Hyam 6
Westbrooke 6
O'Hare 7
Kelly 6.5
Baka 6.5
Biamou 7.5
Shipley 7
Allen 6.5
Godden 6
Surprised by the low kelly scores. Second half he completely ran the game and his passes for the goal and ohare chance we excellent. Bakayoko deserves credit for his second half too. He played hiwulas position better than hiwula. Their left back was hardly getting forward after the break. Ohare i thought was poor. Clearly offers us something but gives the ball away so often. After 2 awful games shipley looked better alongside kelly. Allen tho surely is a guaranteed starter very soon
