Player ratings vs Brighton (1 Viewer)

Doyler 10

Burge 6
Grimmer 5 (not match fit)
Hyam 5 (poor centre half)
Willis 5
Haynes 6
Kelly 5
Shipley 5
Bayliss 6
Barrett 3
McNulty 5
Clarke Harris 7

Ponti 6 (busy when he came on)
Biamou 5 (has no goalscorer's instinct, that cross that JCH put in that keeper fumbled he wasn't even looking at)
McDonald 6 passing generally better than other defenders

Burge 6
Grimmer 5
Hyam 5
Willis 5.5
Haynes 6
Kelly 5
Shipley 6
Bayliss 6
Barrett 0 should never play again. Bottler
McNulty 6
Clarke Harris 7

Ponti 6
Biamou 5
McDonald 5

Pre 80 mins, everybody 5.
Post 80 mins, everybody 7.

Robins, 2. Dreadful tactics standing off and gifting them 3 easy goals. As soon as Ponticelli came on and we got at them we scored. Should of gone at them from the start. Why it took 80mins for us to pressure them is beyond Me.

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk

westofrayne said:

Barrett 0 should never play again. Bottler

Click to expand...

That's one thing I reckon you can judge a player on straight away. I'm pretty sure he completely bottled his first 50/50 for us. That's it for me then.
The old arc your run slightly so you don't quite make it there in time so you've got an excuse, except he still made it in time and didn't know what to do then.

hill83 said:

That's one thing I reckon you can judge a player on straight away. I'm pretty sure he completely bottled his first 50/50 for us. That's it for me then.
The old arc your run slightly so you don't quite make it there in time so you've got an excuse, except he still made it in time and didn't know what to do then.

Click to expand...

He also bottled a number of tackles at MK Dons, doesn't look interested, you can forgive a lack of skill but not effort. If it was just today then you could say an off day, but it been every game so far.

westofrayne said:

He also bottled a number of tackles at MK Dons, doesn't look interested, you can forgive a lack of skill but not effort. If it was just today then you could say an off day, but it been every game so far.

Click to expand...

He was a passenger at FGR too. Might as well of played with 10 men with him on the pitch!

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk

Barrett just doesn’t look ready for the mans game.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

hill83 said:

That's one thing I reckon you can judge a player on straight away. I'm pretty sure he completely bottled his first 50/50 for us. That's it for me then.
The old arc your run slightly so you don't quite make it there in time so you've got an excuse, except he still made it in time and didn't know what to do then.

Click to expand...

throw the extra stone he's carrying into the equation and you know he's a wrong 'un.
Young lad hoping to become a pro letting himself go like that tells me everything about him.

Burge 6 Got the jitters early with a couple of fumbles but couldn’t do anything about the goals.
Grimmer 6 Not bad while he was on-thought he was one of the better ones till he went off.
Haynes 5 Abysmal-most things down his side-gets an extra point as he had a reasonable last 15.
Hyam 5 Just a steady player really but had a tough afternoon trying to cope with Ulloa and Locadia.
Willis 5 Same as Hyam and lost his battle for the 2nd goal.
Barrett 3 Over weight pub player-bottler who ducks out of 50/50’s.
Shipley 5 One or 2 decent set plays but on the whole disappointing. Didn’t help with Haynes behind him.
Kelly 7 Better than of late and didn’t give the ball away at all! Still a bit sideways and backwards though.
Bayliss 6 Had a decent run first half and as usual tried to go forward.
McNulty 6 Ran his socks off but no chances were created for him so was feeding on scraps.
JCH 8 Had a beast of a game. Got in amongst them and ruffled a few feathers and not overawed. Deserved his goal-Biamou take note.
Biamou 5 a poor mans JCH.
McDonald 5 Put forward a couple of decent balls but pressure was off us when he came on for last 20 minutes.
Ponticelli 6 Fresh legs when needed and really put a shift in.

Robins 6 Didn’t understand why he didn’t go for it from the start with nothing to loose? Maybe we all think we are better than we are and Brighton really were a cut above us. But glad we scored a goal at least.

Fans 8 Went a bit quiet understandably after the early goal but got behind them well generally.

Mention also to the Brighton fans who had a Sisu out banner in the home end-great effort! :emoji_thumbsup:

Adge said:

Burge 6 Got the jitters early with a couple of fumbles but couldn’t do anything about the goals.
Grimmer 6 Not bad while he was on-thought he was one of the better ones till he went off.
Haynes 5 Abysmal-most things down his side-gets an extra point as he had a reasonable last 15.
Hyam 5 Just a steady player really but had a tough afternoon trying to cope with Ulloa and Locadia.
Willis 5 Same as Hyam and lost his battle for the 2nd goal.
Barrett 3 Over weight pub player-bottler who ducks out of 50/50’s.
Shipley 5 One or 2 decent set plays but on the whole disappointing. Didn’t help with Haynes behind him.
Kelly 7 Better than of late and didn’t give the ball away at all! Still a bit sideways and backwards though.
Bayliss 6 Had a decent run first half and as usual tried to go forward.
McNulty 6 Ran his socks off but no chances were created for him so was feeding on scraps.
JCH 8 Had a beast of a game. Got in amongst them and ruffled a few feathers and not overawed. Deserved his goal-Biamou take note.
Biamou 5 a poor mans JCH.
McDonald 5 Put forward a couple of decent balls but pressure was off us when he came on for last 20 minutes.
Ponticelli 6 Fresh legs when needed and really put a shift in.

Robins 6 Didn’t understand why he didn’t go for it from the start with nothing to loose? Maybe we all think we are better than we are and Brighton really were a cut above us. But glad we scored a goal at least.

Fans 8 Went a bit quiet understandably after the early goal but got behind them well generally.

Mention also to the Brighton fans who had a Sisu out banner in the home end-great effort! :emoji_thumbsup:

Click to expand...

Bloke on the phone in said we should ha e played biamou from the off and if we used Haynes in the first half as we did in the second we’d have at least drawn - not joking

Grendel said:

Bloke on the phone in said we should ha e played biamou from the off and if we used Haynes in the first half as we did in the second we’d have at least drawn - not joking

Click to expand...

Certainly I’d biamou had been on for Barrett from the off we would have done better both going forward and covering Haynes. If Barrett playing out of position why not biamou?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

lifeskyblue said:

Certainly I’d biamou had been on for Barrett from the off we would have done better both going forward and covering Haynes. If Barrett playing out of position why not biamou?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Click to expand...

He wasn't out of position

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk

He is not a left winger surely? He don’t play like one.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

lifeskyblue said:

He is not a left winger surely? He don’t play like one.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Click to expand...

He doesn't play like a footballer. Not sure why your digging at his position. He doesn't look like a footballer FULL STOP.....

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk

Barrett overweight ? We've had a few chunky players, Micky Quinn liked a pie or two, but knew where the net was. I remember a player John Smith in the 60's wasn't exactly svelte, but could play a bit. Weight is only a problem if the player is crap !

bringbackrattles said:

Barrett overweight ? We've had a few chunky players, Micky Quinn liked a pie or two, but knew where the net was. I remember a player John Smith in the 60's wasn't exactly svelte, but could play a bit. Weight is only a problem if the player is crap !

Click to expand...

Theyr both players from when the game was much, much slower.

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk

Grendel said:

Bloke on the phone in said we should ha e played biamou from the off and if we used Haynes in the first half as we did in the second we’d have at least drawn - not joking

Click to expand...

He probably gives half his wages to some religion or another every week

Nick said:

Barrett wasnt was he?

Click to expand...

He was he should have been on the bench

Didn't see or hear the game today, very disappointed to hear about Barrett's performance, especially with Maguire-Drew looking awful so far.

pastythegreat said:

Robins, 2. Dreadful tactics standing off and gifting them 3 easy goals. As soon as Ponticelli came on and we got at them we scored. Should of gone at them from the start. Why it took 80mins for us to pressure them is beyond Me.

Click to expand...

Ah yes we should have gone at Premier League opposition right from the start, it's not like they have a £15mil striker up front or anything.

FFS mate get a grip, we're in Division 4, we can't go after Premier League teams like that, we'd get destroyed.

lifeskyblue said:

Certainly I’d biamou had been on for Barrett from the off we would have done better both going forward and covering Haynes. If Barrett playing out of position why not biamou?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Click to expand...

Lol

PVA said:

Didn't see or hear the game today, very disappointed to hear about Barrett's performance, especially with Maguire-Drew looking awful so far.




Ah yes we should have gone at Premier League opposition right from the start, it's not like they have a £15mil striker up front or anything.

FFS mate get a grip, we're in Division 4, we can't go after Premier League teams like that, we'd get destroyed.

Click to expand...

So what you suggest we should of done? Stand off them and hand them 3 goals! We went at stoke from the off, unsettled them and gave them no time to think. We stood off Brighton allowing them to ping 50 yard diagonal balls to unmarked men all game.

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk

stevefloyd said:

He was he should have been on the bench

Click to expand...

For Reading U23s

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk

pastythegreat said:

Theyr both players from when the game was much, much slower.

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk

Click to expand...

Yes but when the game was much more physical.

Burge 6
Grimmer 5
Hyam 5
Willis 5
Haynes 5
Kelly 6
Shipley 6
Bayliss 6
Barrett 3
McNulty 7
JCH 7.5 MOTM

Ponticelli 4
Biamou 4
McDonald 5

Jeez there’s some shockingly bad ratings for the team here. Yet the team were clapped off and Mark Robins name was sang out loud and proud.

I think obviously these brainless folks were thinking we were playing against Accrington at home again.

Last 30 mins in fact 2nd half we were a match for this lot. Very proud of the team. Hit the crossbar and hit the post too!

Burge 7
Grimmer 5
Willis 7
Hyam 5
Haynes 6
Barrat 5
Bayliss 7
Kelly 7
Shipley 7
McNulty 7
JCH 8

McDonald 6
JP 7
Max 6

Well done ponticelli !!

Burge - 6
Grimmer - 5
Willis - 5
Hyam - 5
Haynes - 6
Kelly - 6
Bayliss - 6
Barrett - 3
Shipley - 5
McNulty - 5
Clarke-Harris - 7

shelby76 said:

Well done ponticelli !!

Click to expand...

For what?

SlowerThanPlatt said:

For what?

Click to expand...

Personally, I think his introduction changed the game for us. Should of come on for Barrett at half time tbf.
Injected pace and directness which we lacked completely until he came on.

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk