I think Simms is the only one you could call a dud. Even then we have had decent value out of him when you look at cannon £10m, Idah £7m Kyogo £10m etc.
Dean Austin has taken some stick on here but I think overall the recruitment has been very good since he came in. Even the likes of Kitching and Asante are starting to look like good value signings. especially when you look at some of the dross going for big money in the championship at the moment.