Officiating (3 Viewers)

Forums New posts
T

thekidfromstrettoncamp

Well-Known Member
The Tats foul If you're having the neck of you're shirt pulled downwards for about 10 yds running at speed, there is only one direction you are going and that is down.The holding of shorts is because when your falling you grab at the nearest thing to try and stop yourself going down which he was not doing until the foul.
Anyone doubting it look at post 241 on here the linesman and the ref. have a clear view. Why no action?
 
Johhny Blue

Johhny Blue

Well-Known Member
thekidfromstrettoncamp said:
The Tats foul If you're having the neck of you're shirt pulled downwards for about 10 yds running at speed, there is only one direction you are going and that is down.The holding of shorts is because when your falling you grab at the nearest thing to try and stop yourself going down which he was not doing until the foul.
Anyone doubting it look at post 241 on here the linesman and the ref. have a clear view. Why no action?
Click to expand...
If you refer to a clip it should prove your point. This one doesn’t. There was no foul.
 
rob9872

rob9872

Well-Known Member
Johhny Blue said:
If you refer to a clip it should prove your point. This one doesn’t. There was no foul.
Click to expand...
Stevie Wonder Fan GIF
 
Colin Steins Smile

Colin Steins Smile

Well-Known Member
I think we all agree that the standard of officiating is poor. What I would like to see is the Premier League recruiting the best officials from around the world, as the PL has the money and arguably a high proportion of the best players playing in the PL.
The impact of some of the best coaches joining the PL & EFL has had on player development is significant and I would hope that this would be duplicated in officials development.
 
Brighton Sky Blue

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
Colin Steins Smile said:
I think we all agree that the standard of officiating is poor. What I would like to see is the Premier League recruiting the best officials from around the world, as the PL has the money and arguably a high proportion of the best players playing in the PL.
The impact of some of the best coaches joining the PL & EFL has had on player development is significant and I would hope that this would be duplicated in officials development.
Click to expand...
Or alternatively divert a bigger chunk of that obscene TV money into better training of officials
 
Adge

Adge

Well-Known Member
Brighton Sky Blue said:
Or alternatively divert a bigger chunk of that obscene TV money into better training of officials
Click to expand...
There are good methods in terms of development and excellent pathways for officials for the right candidates. I have said many times on here that officials that show promise are sky rocketed to quickly. I have seen it so often even at grass roots level that officials and local county’s are in to much of a rush to propel people who are not quite ready to take the next step. I always advise promotion candidates to “get another year in the tank” experience wise before they take the next step. Unfortunately that is not toeing the party line and often politics come into play.
 
Brighton Sky Blue

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
Adge said:
There are good methods in terms of development and excellent pathways for officials for the right candidates. I have said many times on here that officials that show promise are sky rocketed to quickly. I have seen it so often even at grass roots level that officials and local county’s are in to much of a rush to propel people who are not quite ready to take the next step. I always advise promotion candidates to “get another year in the tank” experience wise before they take the next step. Unfortunately that is not toeing the party line and often politics come into play.
Click to expand...
The skyrocketing happens because we don’t have enough people doing it full stop. If you invested the money into providing better protection and support for people doing Sunday league and non-league you’d probably have better retention which would in turn lead to people being able to take more time to learn their trade.

I did it for a good 5-6 years but was just sick of getting dog’s abuse for not much money and not much support from my local FA
 
skybluecam

skybluecam

Well-Known Member
Brighton Sky Blue said:
The skyrocketing happens because we don’t have enough people doing it full stop. If you invested the money into providing better protection and support for people doing Sunday league and non-league you’d probably have better retention which would in turn lead to people being able to take more time to learn their trade.

I did it for a good 5-6 years but was just sick of getting dog’s abuse for not much money and not much support from my local FA
Click to expand...
People really don't realise how intimidating refereeing even at the amateur level can be - verbal abuse is basically a given and from my experience as a player I'd see physical/violent threats or abuse at least once a season.

At the premier league level you have clubs paying millions of pounds per week in squad salary costs yet the referees, who can impact the result more than any single player, get just £180k per YEAR + match fees.
 
L

Legia Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
skybluecam said:
People really don't realise how intimidating refereeing even at the amateur level can be - verbal abuse is basically a given and from my experience as a player I'd see physical/violent threats or abuse at least once a season.

At the premier league level you have clubs paying millions of pounds per week in squad salary costs yet the referees, who can impact the result more than any single player, get just £180k per YEAR + match fees.
Click to expand...

I didn't know they earned that much! Just 180k a year you say :eek:

I personally don't see how paying them more money somehow equates to them making better decisions, or helps the grass roots refs to get less abuse.
 
skybluecam

skybluecam

Well-Known Member
Legia Sky Blue said:
I didn't know they earned that much! Just 180k a year you say :eek:

I personally don't see how paying them more money somehow equates to them making better decisions, or helps the grass roots refs to get less abuse.
Click to expand...
You don’t see how offering more money (at all levels) will attract more and higher quality referees?
 
Adge

Adge

Well-Known Member
Brighton Sky Blue said:
The skyrocketing happens because we don’t have enough people doing it full stop. If you invested the money into providing better protection and support for people doing Sunday league and non-league you’d probably have better retention which would in turn lead to people being able to take more time to learn their trade.

I did it for a good 5-6 years but was just sick of getting dog’s abuse for not much money and not much support from my local FA
Click to expand...
Yep-and as part of the FA and County FA I can’t disagree. I have had many phone calls recently in regards to mentioning “promising Referees who are showing potential”
Unfortunately there are not enough people within the circle (such as myself or even ex referees) to offer support and be at the side of the pitch on a Saturday/Sunday to offer guidance in the early stages. Candidates will then turn their back on the game due to as has been said previously the amount of abuse.
I would be very surprised if 1 in 20 new referees has any support from a mentor or the local County FA. Those who do are the lucky ones.
 
Brighton Sky Blue

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
Adge said:
Yep-and as part of the FA and County FA I can’t disagree. I have had many phone calls recently in regards to mentioning “promising Referees who are showing potential”
Unfortunately there are not enough people within the circle (such as myself or even ex referees) to offer support and be at the side of the pitch on a Saturday/Sunday to offer guidance in the early stages. Candidates will then turn their back on the game due to as has been said previously the amount of abuse.
I would be very surprised if 1 in 20 new referees has any support from a mentor or the local County FA. Those who do are the lucky ones.
Click to expand...
I started reffing as a teenager, so my dad was often by the pitch just as @Sky Blue Pete was for his lad. When he was I performed a lot better knowing there was some support there if needed.
 
shmmeee

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
Legia Sky Blue said:
I didn't know they earned that much! Just 180k a year you say :eek:

I personally don't see how paying them more money somehow equates to them making better decisions, or helps the grass roots refs to get less abuse.
Click to expand...

Pay peanuts get monkeys
 
L

long way home

Well-Known Member
Didn't rate him at all, but then again i haven't seen a great ref for a long time and in the championship hardly ever. So some decisions i was not shocked at which way he pointed.
 
pusbccfc

pusbccfc

Well-Known Member
It was an outstanding call to give Preston the red. The lino also got a brilliant call right for the EMC offside.

Generally he was giving Preston a lot of niggly fouls against EMC but overall they did well tonight.
 
Robinshio

Robinshio

Well-Known Member
skybluecam said:
People really don't realise how intimidating refereeing even at the amateur level can be - verbal abuse is basically a given and from my experience as a player I'd see physical/violent threats or abuse at least once a season.

At the premier league level you have clubs paying millions of pounds per week in squad salary costs yet the referees, who can impact the result more than any single player, get just £180k per YEAR + match fees.
Click to expand...
Compared to the prime minister who gets £172k
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 4 (members: 0, guests: 4)
Top